"I always like to remind people that effectively treating heart disease is going to involve a significant period in which us normals have to deal with long-lived rich people. Sounds awful, like, just about the worst societal dynamic I can think of."
[Back to the present]
Our age is characterized by the fact that access to types of medical technology is basically flat. Rich people get to hire better doctors, but there are no super-secret, ultra-restricted forms of medicine that are inaccessible to everyone else. Your chances of getting into clinical trials of the new new things are about as good as theirs, provided you are prepared to pick up a phone and put in the time.
As for the organ transplants; somebody needs to pour more money into stem cell research and related fields so that we can start growing organs, thus eliminating the whole organ market (including the black one) and zero-sum dynamics of transplats.
Why is it not only bad, but worst you can think of? I, for one, can think of much worse things than immortal Bill Gates, however annoying it may be for some. Just turn on the news and watch long enough, I'm sure you'll see some of it. Then head to the library and open any 20th century history books. I guarantee you you'll find things much worse than an annoyingly long-living billionaire - such as genocide a of millions, for example. And not once but multiple times.
>>> Don't be surprised if they realize there isn't enough room for the rest of us.
Why there wouldn't be enough room for the rest of us?
Put yourself in the mind set of a super rich and powerful immortal human being. The stakes are hard to imagine, you are trying to preserve your existence for an infinite future. People who stand in the way are not even going to have a chance, an immortal can't afford such a risk.
>>> The stakes are hard to imagine, you are trying to preserve your existence for an infinite future
Human brain can not comprehend infinite, so it won't be much different from any regular person who's trying to stay alive - most people don't know when they'd die and don't think about it as a definite endpoint anyway, so it as well could be in infinite future.
>>> People who stand in the way are not even going to have a chance, an immortal can't afford such a risk.
Chance of what? And if the risk is so high, why would you want to alienate people that outnumber you million to one and on which your whole existence - since you can't personally produce any of the technologies needed to support your immortality, right - is based on? You'd rather try to prove them keeping you alive is a good thing and not start to murdering them in droves like you seem to imply. After all, even if medicine somehow reaches the level where all diseases could be cured (which is very improbable but let's allow it for a moment), one can still be murdered, and for a rich and potentially immortal person the risk here would be much higher than for a would-be murderer that has much less to lose. So the strategy you describe would be very foolish.
Hopefully there will be some sort of colonization of space at that point and they can at least leave Earth to us mortals.
Ultimately I just don't read enough sci-fi to have all the debate points down. I'm just trying to apply to marxist concepts to something which perhaps will have completely eclipsed Karl's reality.
Because the army will almost certainly be robots or drones.
a) make humans immortal
b) make a non-human conscious being that's immortal
I would argue that we're much closer to b), and that it's a much easier problem to solve.
Even if the above is wrong, an artificial lifeform would solve many more problems that merely immortality. How do you let humans operate in tiny spaces (e.g. in tubes with a diameter of 2cm). How do you let humans operate "in the large", e.g. moving 5000ton concrete blocks ? How do you let humans operate in unstable conditions (e.g. mining, handling explosives, on the battlefield, ...). How do you build a star-trek transporter (for computer programs, that's a solved problem). How do you keep them alive in space, underwater, in the ground ?
All of those are things where an artificial lifeform would have a massive advantage.
So I believe in the matrix prediction. We'll build artificial lifeforms. We'll get our collective asses handed to us by these lifeforms first economically, then militarily. And this lifeform will colonize the galaxy in ~1 million years.
But I notice you can't name even one way that would be bad. All you can do is a vague prediction "oh, it would be so bad you won't believe". Not really convincing.
The amount of wealth controlled by top 1% in US stayed essentially the same for the last 100 years - about 1/3 (with some fluctuations, but roughly stayed around that). Some say US has an unusually high inequality, so if we take it as a top boundary, we can say that in the world top 1% controls no more than 1/3 of the wealth. Yet while one can say there are a lot of problems, no unimaginable horrors came out of it and society wasn't destroyed - on the contrary, life of virtually every person in all the strata of the society has become better.
I don't think that statistically follows - I've not done the math, but it reminds me quite a bit of Simpson's Paradox.
History tells us that people will quickly use that to their advantage.
They have the technology to reassemble human body on molecular level and they still need millions of humans to work in degrading conditions to build those robots - because those molecular-precision technologies somehow not applicable to building robots? And yet despite their dire need of those workers - they not only dispose of them without second's hesitation but also allow their robots to mutilate them for no reason, thus degrading their productivity significantly. This movie really doesn't led itself to any thinking - it just falls apart like wet toilet paper if you start to think about it.
Don't be surprised if they realize there isn't enough room for the rest of us. These new 1% immortals may also require a special country in which they are not at risk of being tragically harmed by one of us billion mortals. Watch you don't get bit by their 2 tonne Boston Dynamics guard dog...