Is vim perfect? Well, for me it's not. Because of vimscript, because it doesn't have mechanism to work with non-text information (for example it has to open up another window to show me rendered LaTeX). Sometimes I even think of switching to emacs. Plugins to do some advanced processing (like rope for python) are slow quite often. But I still prefer it to any IDE in most cases. It's not perfect, but it's the best thing I've met so far in this imperfect world.
Because (a) some of us aren't convinced that things like IDEs give a better view of what's going on in the system; (b) some of us think that fundamental tools like terminal emulators, editors and so on should be debugged and stable because we have to earn our mortgage payments using them and chasing the shiny isn't on our job description; (c) any actually useful new idea winds up in Vim anyway.
You want to use a new shiny unproven editor, grand, have a ball. But don't ask me to purely on the basis that it's not new and shiny.
(d) When did I specifically pick out IDEs as the sole example of new and shiny? Or did you just read my comment without parsing it?
- Ability to select any symbol and find semantic uses of it
- For OO code, being able to visuallize the OO graph usage of certain symbols
- Refactoring across the whole project with semantic knowledge (no, search/replace does does not cut it)
- Navigation in third-party libraries deployed in binary format
- Code completion for static/dynamic languages, while showing tooltip documentation
- Graphical visualization of data structures on the debugger
- Background compilation with static analysis
- unit test debugging infrastructure
- integration with modelling tools
- integration with SCM tooling and being able to interact with them directly from the editor. For example, generating a blame file, with navigation across the file revisions.
- integration with continuous integration servers
- integration of developer workflow with task management servers
As an example of such developer workflows, have the IDE talk to Jira, edit the code, automatically bundle it in a workflow that binds the code changes to the Jira issue being worked on, get a Jenkins notification after the code is checked in and gone through the CI system.
Sure you can get part of it in Emacs, after spending a week configuring plugins, with different levels of maturity, and in the end it is still mostly textual.
For me, Vi and Emacs are only when I don't have an option in terms of IDE support, even though I know at least Emacs quite well.
What can I say, the world of Amiga GUIs, Smalltalk and Lisp environments spoiled me as an IDE fanboy.
It baffles me why in 2014, some developers still prefer to work as if UNIX System V had just been released.