But of course if you fly over water to the Bahamas every weekend or the Rocky mountains the pros outweigh the cons right?
My point is it's all relative. Being a relatively low time pilot in NJ I see no need for a twin. Assuming I could afford one in the first place.
In other words, anything can fly if you give it enough afterburner.
Its probably a bit more important in a hobbyist or even a commercial plane.
1) How disciplined are you as a pilot, Are you going to insure your plane is ready to fly every single time to mitigate risk. Most fatalities in GA could of been avoided. You will have to make hard calls like. "I have a meeting tomorrow but the weather looks terrible, should I fly through it anyway to get there?" or "My oil pressure is low but I need to get home". You will get stranded and have to get a hotel room or car if you plan on using your aircraft for travel, I guarantee it.
2) Where are you flying? are you flying over water, mountains, cities? Are there roads where you could easily put down or nearby airports? One of the first things you learn as a pilot is what to do in an emergency. Step 1 when you lose engine power - Get the best glide speed and find a place to put down.
As an aside there are aircraft that have parachutes. Cirrus is the best known right now with the CAPS system. But, if you have a parachute are you going to try to fly through the storm to make it to that meeting above?
The situation on turbine powered engines is completely different. The above only applies to piston engines.
With turbo{fan|jet}s I think there is an issue that its just difficult to construct aircraft with a single engine as opposed to wing or tail mounts.
I pulled a comparison from Wikipedia:
Cessna 310 (twin): 2x240hp, max speed 220mph, range 1000mi.
Cessna 182 (single): 230hp, max speed 201mph, range 930mi.
I'm sure the twin has more useful load, but it sure doesn't go much faster or farther.
Power required is force times velocity, so power required goes as the cube of velocity. Twice the power adds only 26% to speed.
http://www.skybrary.aero/index.php/Engine_Failure_After_Take...
Long flights over water, mountains, or in poor visibility is a different matter.
I remember sitting in on a lesson while my brother was getting his private pilot's license. The instructor would randomly idle the engine in flight and have my brother practice the procedures for a engine loss in flight (put the plane into the ideal glide position, identify all possible landing spots, runway or field, etc...)
Yes, several times in the ten years I've been driving automobiles. Is that not common?
My answer: "Turn around go home and land"
It does help that I started out on gliders (sailplanes) first, of course... but losing the engine really isn't that big a deal in level flight in many small aircraft (or even big ones actually - a 747 has a surprisingly decent glide ratio (not actually surprising if you think about it, tbh)).
I've never flown twin engine, but as others have mentioned, losing one engine in a twin can be catastrophic - unless it's the Boomerang of course ;) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rutan_Boomerang
In summary: I would choose zero engines, one engine, or four engines - but not two.
Tell me about single engine (what you appear to have) vs. multi engine (twin, I guess) ?
Should I be thinking about redundancy in plane engines the same way I think about redundancy in ... say ... kidneys ?
It seems to me that I would really, really want a twin engined plane...
edit: I found this [1] but I'm not sure I buy it. I am all about simplicity in systems, but redundancy in a critical component is a different thing. Further, Perrow speaks of fortuitous surpluses (or whatever) as an unalloyed good in [2]. This seems like just the kind of surplus I'd want...
[1] http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?AirplaneRule
[2] Normal Accidents (run, don't walk, to buy and read it)