News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by benched on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:11PM (#7265492)
This is quite an issue in my life. Believing and practicing positive thinking seems like such a self-evident, unquestionably good thing. Especially among a certain class of people, it's almost never popular or ... I don't know - "socially tenable" to challenge this. But I can't help but challenge it. Because to me, it just looks like a nervous tic. In fact, it looks like a stubborn, neurotic horse that insists on only turning to the right. It looks compulsive, and subtly fear-driven. In conversation, it's a non-stop, predictable and inescapable barrage of "Yeah, but", "Well, on the bright side", "Hey, at least" - and no matter what I say, they won't stop returning like it's tennis and they're scrambling all over the court to stop the ball going out of bounds by any means.

And the people who do this are as offended by my view of the world as if I spilled shit on their white suit. I'm biased, but I don't see myself as overly negative. The way I see it, I just don't go out of my way to see the bright side, or try in a motivated way to hit positive notes while conversing. I don't feel motivated to be negative, either. But this sure as hell makes me the most negative person I know, by default. To me, I just can't have a view of the world other than the view I have; and I can't speak things other than what I think and see.

From the other side, for myself, I have been guilty of the same thing in the past. But since I became more aware of it, I now try, when someone talks about bad luck or unpleasantness in the world, to listen and nod, rather than allow my larynx to reflexively spasm into a positive platitude.

No, I am not fun at parties. Not to worry - I don't go to them.

Also, yeah I think criticizing positive thinking in general, and The Secret in particular, both in the same short article, is pretty sloppy.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:11PM (#7265894)
"It looks compulsive, and subtly fear-driven. In conversation, it's a non-stop, predictable and inescapable barrage of "Yeah, but", "Well, on the bright side", "Hey, at least" - and no matter what I say, they won't stop returning like it's tennis and they're scrambling all over the court to stop the ball going out of bounds by any means."

Yeah. Those people suck at it. You are absolutely correct that, use of "Yeah, but" and "Well on the bright side" "Hey, at least" generally indicates trying to gold-plate pig shit.

As I have mentioned in other comments, "positive thinking" is a misnomer. You're really working with emotions, not thought. Thoughts arise from emotions. "Positive thinking" is not so much as using your language to try to gold-plat pig shit so much as tuning into the underlying emotions, and perhaps, shifting the emotions to a different shape. When that happens, the thoughts will arise in a different pattern.

"I'm biased, but I don't see myself as overly negative." <-- A lot of negative people wading through their crap don't see themselves as negative. I speak from personal experience. I can say this kind of stuff now, only because I was able to tune into the darker emotions and learned how to release them. There are lots and lots of methods to do this, much literature, teachings, and trainings on this. The darker emotions stay within you and color how you experience the world; unless you've had a lot of training and practice at being aware of yourself, it is unlikely that you would even know how much crap you carry, though it would feel as if you were being neutral. (It isn't that you are neutral; it is that it feels normal to you).

Perhaps, be open to the possibility that there are people who don't suck at this stuff. Observe what they do, the play of emotions running through them, and how they affect people around them. There are folks like that out there.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by lsc on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:53PM (#7266151)
>I was able to tune into the darker emotions and learned how to release them. There are lots and lots of methods to do this, much literature, teachings, and trainings on this. The darker emotions stay within you and color how you experience the world; unless you've had a lot of training and practice at being aware of yourself, it is unlikely that you would even know how much crap you carry, though it would feel as if you were being neutral. (It isn't that you are neutral; it is that it feels normal to you).

I think it's pretty unbalanced to not have any darker emotions. I mean, certainly, one can take it too far, but I find this social pressure to be always happy to be... very fake, and very irritating.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by redblacktree on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:19PM (#7266299)
It's not about not having those emotions. It's about releasing them rather than dwelling on them. I think what you're describing is avoiding negative emotions, which actually makes things worse. You have to feel through them, if that makes any sense to you at all.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @10:26PM (#7268639)
@redblacktree +1

@lsc there is another aspect to this too. A lot of people are addicted to their darker emotions. It is possible, your feeling of irritation is arising from such an attachment. It is also possible that you have an aversion to the feelings of joy, affection, love, happiness. Lots of people do, even the ones who are clearly faking their happiness :-D

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by benched on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:33PM (#7266393)
No offense intended, but this makes me think of how many times I've heard people speaking about 'working' with emotions. It always makes me raise an eyebrow. Examples: "Don't dwell. Release! Don't avoid... Own! Don't absorb. Transmute! Don't feed. Nurture!" I hope the idea is apparent.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @10:19PM (#7268607)
Um. No, your eyebrow-raising idea is not apparent. Of course you don't dwell, you release. Of course you transmute, not absorb. Of course you nurture, not feed.

All of those are emotional skills. Why do you feel so surprised about this?

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Thursday February 20, 2014 @10:03AM (#7271040)
All right. Would the person who downvoted the above want to explain the downvote?

I was asking @benched why the person is surprised. What is obvious to @benched is not obvious to me; what is obvious to me is not obvious to @benched. What's the point of the upvote or downvote? Why did you feel the need to take the time to read all the way here and then downvote that comment?

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by lsc on Thursday February 20, 2014 @11:14AM (#7271545)
because Benched was saying that these things sound like meaningless platitudes, then you essentially say "Of course they aren't platitudes, that is obvious!" when it isn't obvious at all to me.

Then you seem to imply that anyone who doesn't find these things obvious is emotionally unskilled, whatever that means.

If you took a stab at explaining what those things actually mean, I'd have upvoted. That would make for an interesting conversation, even if I didn't agree with you. As it stands, though, your post reads like a content-free insult, which is exactly the sort of thing that ought to be downvoted.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Thursday February 20, 2014 @01:03PM (#7272434)
@lsc So an insult is something that happens when someone takes one action, and the other person feels offended by it. You, @lsc, cannot know whether @benched feels offended by it through just looking at the text. Rather, it is more impeccable to say that you felt offended by my words to @benched. I appreciate your efforts though.

Next time, just ask for clarification rather than hitting the downvote button. I don't mind that you downvoted it; but without explaining your action like that, you are doing just the same as I am: failing to communicate.

To address your questions. When you say "platitude", that means that those are words empty of power. That is for example, someone says: "Don't dwell, release!" Now, if you have never, ever experienced how to release emotions, you are also unlikely to know how your mind and awareness dwells upon those emotions. Because you have never directly experienced how to do it, in your mind, it is impossible to do. So when someone says to you, "Don't dwell, release!" there is no frame of reference to even understand what that means. To you, they are meaningless platitudes -- regardless of whether the person speaking to you has those skills or not. But for folks who have experienced this, it is obvious. It is obvious because the word obvious stems from the same word as "observable". (It is interesting you took the word "obvious" and filtered it to apply your emotional response to it, probably something along the lines of, "you are stupid because you cannot even perceive this"; for me, the intent and emotional content at the time I wrote this was more along the lines of, "yes, it can be this easy too, you should try it, don't think too much about it").

Most people are emotional morons. That is not an insult. That is exactly what most people are: confused and unskilled with emotions. If anything, it is a cause for compassion, not a means by which someone can feel better about themselves by being "better" than someone else. It also does not mean someone will stay like that forever. Like all skills, you can develop this, though it takes effort.

Most people avoid painful emotions. Part of their subconscious dwells on there. It stays there because they do not want to surface it to the consciousness allow themselves to really experience that feeling, and allow it to fade on its own once it surfaces. Feeling insulted or offended, or feeling offended on behalf of someone else are examples of this dynamic in play.

Usually, if something like that surfaces, and the person tries to shunt off the suffering onto someone else as quickly as possible. One typical and popular method of shunting off suffering is a process called "blame". Our justice system, in fact, is not really about justice so much as divying up blame, that is, divying up suffering among the people. That kind of stuff persists, as each person passes blame on to the next person. It may also take the form of abuse and assault. It may also take the form of more subtle things -- little revenge, or rationalizations. Sometimes, the person isn't fully aware of it, since the misery is so intense, it blocks out whatever it is that is surfacing.

Even more subtly is when those emotions shapes and changes your thought pattern, and you think you are being reasonable. But you're not. Anytime someone has those hidden agendas, they speak or act in one way while trying to get at something else, this dynamic is at play.

Usually, when I teach someone these skills, we'd work on what is being experienced right now. If this were a real-time conversation in meatspace, we would be talking about the emotional impulses within you that led to the downvote. It would be easier in meatspace, since I would be able to tell when things start getting sidetracked, like turning this into a drama about @hosh vs. @lsc rather than what is arising right now. Since this is not meatspace, by the time you read this comment, the arising feelings would likely be different.

If you're truly impeccable about that bit about wanting a serious conversation about this, PM me privately. Indirect means of contact are in my profile. Alternatively, send me your contact info and we can go from there.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by lsc on Thursday February 20, 2014 @01:51PM (#7272768)
A downvote is not a punch in the face. It's not an act of violence. It's not even an insult. It doesn't materially harm you. A downvote is "I don't think this comment is contributing to the conversation" - I think downvoting the comment I downvoted was completely appropriate. This doesn't mean that I think the site would be better off without you; this just means that I thought the site would have been better without that particular comment.

I'm not going to downvote /this/ comment, because I think it's contributing something. It's... too large and complex for me to properly digest and respond to right now, but I think there is something there... you are attempting to convey something to me... which is going to be quite difficult, because we have very different ways of relating to emotions, and because we have very different jargon, and even when we mostly agree on a word (like your example of 'obviously') the emotional connotations associated with that word are quite different.

I suspect that we even have a different way of relating to the emotional connotations of a word, and separating those from the thing actually being described.

But, if this was your response the other night, when I had more time, I likely would have put significant effort into responding instead of just downvoting.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:45PM (#7274728)
My point is that I doubt you actually examined the emotion that arose where you felt you needed to downvote it at all. It does not matter if it is not a punch in the face, act of violence or an insult. You could have not downvoted and simply let it go. Why didn't you?

Your reasoning is that you are helping contribute to the site, and it is nothing personal. That's fine, and perhaps admirable. So why do you feel that this is helping the community? Where does the need to help the community arise from? Where is it located in your body? These are experiential.

I think you are right that we have different ways of relating to the emotional connotation of the word. There is a particular skill at play here. Hmm. I'm not sure how to describe it without jargon.

In order to understand a word, you experience the meaning. That experience tends to be an aggregation of a lot of things: patterns of sensations within the body, which tends to be interpreted as plays of emotions, which give rise to a narrative... a reason. Since this experience plays out at the sensory level, you can observe this on other people. Some people see things. Some people hear things. Some people get things. (There is mismatch when say, you hear an exchange like, "Do you see? It's crystal clear." "No, you don't get it. You don't grasp the significance.")

The other thing is that we tend to think awareness is the same as experience. It's not. It is possible to simply have awareness without content. There are also examples where someone's body might experience something, but the person is not aware of it, often because there is armoring or aversion.

Further, there are people who tend to associate thought with consciousness and awareness. Typically (but not always), such a person do not have enough awareness of the emotions at play. I speak of these things because I've been like that before, so I know what it is like to be emotionally clueless and what it is like to be much more in tune with the play of emotions.

If most of your awareness rests in your intellect, and you feel comfortable using your intellect, you're not as likely to be aware of the underlying emotional or sensory experiences. So if you attempted to use "positive thinking", you could make a change in the pattern of thought. But that does not necessarily make a change in the pattern of emotion.

The Litany Against Fear from Dune is a great example. That never worked for me :-D But I know folks where it does work for them. There is enough awareness and presence with the emotional that, when they speak "I will let fear pass me by..." it really does pass them by. The experience the fear arising in their body ... and leaving. (And that is actually how you release. You allow it to go on its own). It never worked for me because I was simply pushing symbols around in my mind, yet since my awareness was not on the fear, there is no connection between my intent/will with the emotion. For me, I have to direct my intent/will to tune into the fear, recognize it, and watch it, and allow it to pass out of my system on its own. Simply speaking the concepts are powerless platitudes for me without the presence of my mind in my emotions.

Does that help?

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by SamReidHughes on Friday February 21, 2014 @02:04AM (#7275788)
Downvoting is better than other ways of telling a person their posting is bad because it keeps the signal:noise ratio of the thread lower.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Friday February 21, 2014 @01:46PM (#7278588)
@samreidhughes Ok. Then in that case, my question to you: why do you feel that keeping the signal to noise ratio of the thread is a good thing? Where is that experience arising from in your body?
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by benched on Thursday February 20, 2014 @03:52PM (#7273485)
Yes, this is what I was getting at. That if I don't already have well-developed meanings for all of those verbs in this context, they look like they were pulled out of thin air. They might as well be interchangeable - I don't even know which ones are supposed to be the 'good' ones and which 'bad'. So it's a subtle form of jargon, and it can't be regarded merely as plain English.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:18PM (#7274626)
Fair enough. It's possible for you to experience these things with a skilled teacher. If you're interested in it, I'm sure you can find such a trainer. These are very useful skills.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by saraid216 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:38PM (#7266425)
I have to ask, because the lack of jargon makes it harder for me to register heuristic labels.

Are you talking about being a darkworker? Or is that too far afield?

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:03PM (#7268789)
And, caveat to all of that other comment:

I heard Gregg Braden speak recently about his new book, Turning Point. I admire his skill at communicating. He is able to talk about this kind of shadow-side work without freaking people out.

He explains it like this. That there are vast changes going on right now in the world. That people are waiting for "things to get back to normal". And he gently leads the person to understanding that ... this is the new normal. And accepting that, you can adapt to the conditions that have already change. And to do that, you need to look at what is going on instead of avoiding it.

I have not started his book, though it is in my queue. The subject matter interest me as much as his communication skill. Maybe I can learn to speak in a way that won't freak people out about shadow-side work :-)

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by jaredsohn on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:42PM (#7267506)
I don't think that's the right jargon. Darkworkers/lightworkers are more about serving yourself vs. the greater good. (i.e. making money via phishing is more darkworker while building Watsi is more lightworker.)
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by saraid216 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @07:20PM (#7267775)
Eh. The way I heard it discussed, that was exactly the kind of simplistic misconception that made people think darkworking was terribad. The way hosh talks about tuning into your "darker emotions" and "releasing them" reminds me of those conversations.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @10:47PM (#7268715)
@saraid216 No, that's not too far afield, though if you want to get into the details, I'd rather discuss this privately. Indirect contact methods are in my profile.

I have never heard someone use the term "darkworker" until you brought it up, but it makes sense if people are going to talk about "lightworker". I have met and know a lot of folks who polarize things like that; many of them have great wisdom and I respect it, yet at the same time, I have learned not to bring up things like deliberately stalking your shadow. It freaks them out too much.

I'll try to describe this in a way that is OK for a public forum (and as I said, feel free to contact me privately).

If you ever had the experience of unity consciousness, that is the base. A lot of "lightworkers" have experienced that. However, I don't think they ever went through the implications of what that experience means. For them, there is some notion of "alignment with source" or something similar. Lots of wisdom comes out from it.

However, if you have attained in the insight of oneness ... then how can anything, no matter how dark, terrifying, or evil be not an emanation of source?

There are significant teachings and methods where, after attaining the insight of oneness, you have a basic connection of true nature; and as such, you can also recognize true nature in any and all phenomena. It is in this way that transmutation can happen. You stalk the shadows in order to bring light there, to see the truth for yourself and to see the truth within the dark.

It is also risky, since, this kind of practice easily attracts people who have a fixation on darkness (for a variety of reasons). Or, if you have any shred of arrogance, or messiah complex, or trying to be the hero, all of that comes out when you stalk the shadows. But then again, if you have the insight of oneness ... where else is there to go? There is no such thing as raising the consciousness of just the folks who are good, or "in alignment" or some other such notions. And further, stalking the darkness like that will suss out all the karma and obscuration within you faster than anything else will. This is why there are yogis and sadhu who meditate in the cremation grounds (because they recognize all is the cremation grounds).

What is also interesting is that these practices themselves tends to trigger a lot of fear in folks. One of most potent practices is awesome: it will, over time, allow you to release deep trauma like few other practices will. We're talking heavy shit here: PTSD, ardent desires to self-annihilate out of shame and guilt, rape, etc. A teaching and a method that helps heal that kind of stuff, that's an awesome gift to the world. Imagine the kind of compassion it took for the originators to see into the dark and create such a gem.

Yet when I have recommended it for friends, they react to it just like the first two times I encountered it in my life: great fear and aversion. For example, they'd buy the book, and keep it on the shelf, and never read it. Something inside them knows that it will work to relieve their suffering, and they avoid it like hell. They avoid it like hell because the price for relief of trauma is realization. Most people won't try it until they get desperate enough.

One more thing: I don't use labels about identity. I don't consider myself a darkworker or a lightworker. Or a programmer. Or a meditator. Or any X. I might practice stalking the shadows, or emanating peace, or program computers, or meditate. Saying I am X is not impeccable. Eventually, I might even drop "I practice X", who knows? ;-)

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by Gtwhite90 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:40PM (#7266975)
Thought process are really interesting to me, what kind of literature and teachings are you referring to?
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @10:53PM (#7268747)
Sure. Lots. Vipassana. Shamanic journeys. Dream yoga. Alchemy. Many teachings arise from a very small set of essential principles (we are, after all, talking about the play of Consciousness). They come in a lot of forms, appropriate for the culture and for the individual.

I guess the followup question is: what are you looking for right now?

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by ryanjshaw on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:41PM (#7266981)
> hosh> Thoughts arise from emotions

Not according to the theory behind one of the most effective psychotherapies we have available today [1], CBT. In the cognitive theory of behaviour, thoughts drive emotions; emotions drive behaviour, the consequences of which drive further thought, thereby creating a feedback loop. Thoughts are based upon beliefs; distorted beliefs lead to distorted thinking and distorted actions. Thought-directed self-help would be directed towards resolving these distorted beliefs.

So "Positive thinking" can mean different things to different people.

This article seems to be discussing a definition I would prefer to label somewhere between "wishful thinking" and "the lazy person's effortless alternative to diligent-self-help-practice that just may work if you're lucky enough to independently rediscover proven self-help techniques indirectly as a consequence of your raised consciousness, or through dumb luck".

In the framework of diligent-self-help-practice, "positive thinking" can be considered as a subset of "rational thinking". CBT, for instance, acknowledges that there are often different ways to view any given situation, and that there is no single "right way". Your personal beliefs will determine which perspective you take, and therefore what emotions you will feel (and consequently what your ultimate behaviour will be). Many people are not aware of the beliefs driving their thought processes, or do not believe that beliefs are malleable, and consequently have a blind spot towards solving their problems.

> benched> I just don't go out of my way to see the bright side, or try in a motivated way to hit positive notes while conversing

The belief that hosh and benched appear to share - that they're just "stating the facts" for everybody else - can, from the perspective that beliefs are malleable, be seen as an unnecessarily self-limiting view of the world.

For instance - let's say you've just been convicted of murder and will serve a life sentence without the possibility of parole in some hellhole. Sure, you could just "state the facts". That may lead to saying to yourself, matter of factly, "well I've just destroyed all my chances of X!". And if you believed X is the most important thing in the world to you, with this thought brought upon by your belief you may find yourself feeling suddenly very depressed at the loss of X.

Now: some people accept that this is a perfectly valid perspective, but not a particularly helpful one. "Positive thinking" in this context means finding a more helpful belief to drive a more constructive perspective. Because whatever is going to happen in that hellhole is going to happen; unless you choose suicide, the best chance you can give your sanity is to give life a meaning invulnerable to what's going to happen [2].

Of course all of this is easier said than done. I'm damn sure if I were ever in this situation I would struggle very much to think positively. I do think I'd have a big advantage of coming to a constructive solution over the guy next to me who hadn't been practising positive thinking, though.

A good part of CBT is helping people find and change toward more empowering beliefs but in practice our beliefs are often tightly coupled together in the worst imaginable tangle of ropes, requiring significant insight and diligence to untangle and restructure a working solution, like refactoring in-memory a production system that has been continuously developed on the wrong foundation for 20, 30, 40 or more years.

Perhaps some people can sense the cognitive dissonance (that a new belief will interfere with an existing belief) but not how to resolve it (usually the introduction and/or refinement of other deeply held beliefs), and become disillusioned with the process, preferring instead to label themselves as just "stating the facts" ;)

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_behavioral_therapy#Ev...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logotherapy

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @10:11PM (#7268571)
That theory is why a lot of people are so screwed up. It is bullshit. Emotions drive thought, not the other way around. You can observe this dynamic within yourself. You can observe it within other people. Go see it for yourself.

I have literally watched people, with this notion that thought drive emotion, attempt to talk their way through things. It never works. When it appears to work is when there is emotional acceptance -- what you call "belief".

What is even more interesting is that a lot of people are emotionally attached to this notion that thought drives emotions. It's both absurd and tragic, watching folks fixated on this notion that thought rules emotion thrash their way through life, creating misery for themselves and others and not knowing why this is all happening.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by goblgobl on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:41PM (#7267498)
I found this incredibly helpful. Could you list any additional resources for CBT and positive thinking you might have? I have some other question if you don't mind, my email is in my profile.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by npsimons on Thursday February 20, 2014 @03:45PM (#7273438)
Try "Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy" by David Burns and "A New Guide to Rational Living" by Albert Ellis. Wikipedia has some relevant information:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_emotive_behavior_ther... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_behavioral_therapy

Contrary to what some would have you believe in this thread, you can change your beliefs and emotions through consciously directed thought, but it's not easy.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:46PM (#7274733)
I think you mean, consciously directed intent and will. Intent and will are not necessarily the same as thought. Perhaps you are using the wrong tools, and making it more difficult than it needs to be.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by Florin_Andrei on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:39PM (#7265709)
> it's a non-stop, predictably and inescapable barrage of "Yeah, but", "Well, on the bright side", "Hey, at least"

In moderate dosage, it is useful to blunt negativity and hopelessness, which can also cause failure. But use too much of it, and you're lost in la-la-land. As they say, it's all in the dosage...

I think the positive thinking method would get a lot better if it focused less on the outcome, and more on the process. Don't focus on having the great job and enjoying it, focus on the qualities that it takes to get there.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by benched on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:57PM (#7265821)
Personally, I tend to agree with your second paragraph. I would much rather hear "Run! Run!" than "We can still make the bus!"
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by Florin_Andrei on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:12PM (#7265898)
What most people today think about spirituality is childish at best, a hideous deformation at worst. "The Secret" is an instance of that.

I've spoken with some Orthodox monks in Eastern Europe, where I grew up. Some of them (a rare few, yes) are surprisingly un-dogmatic, and focused on spirituality instead. Take their prayer for example. It's not so much a naive conversation with an imaginary deity, as most people think. It's more like an old-school mental self-programming technique.

They instruct you to never say "give me money", but instead say "give me the strength to attain success" - and visualize it, the process, not the result. They emphasize that you remain the material agent; if you're "given" anything, it's the mental conditions that boost motivation and clear thinking.

Even from a purely material and scientific perspective, I'm definitely fine with that view, give or take a metaphoric understanding of the process of "giving" (it's ultimately a change in your mentality that occurs due to prayer and visualization, and even they emphasize that the way the change happens is a mystery better left alone if you're practical-minded).

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by saraid216 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:43PM (#7266448)
> Take their prayer for example. It's not so much a naive conversation with an imaginary deity, as most people think. It's more like an old-school mental self-programming technique.

This is historically very, very common. Any deep dive into religious mysticism of any type will immediately blur the line between self-programming and conversation. It's not great (though hardly impossible) as a route to secular authority so it's rarely the dominant understanding.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by dubfan on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:44PM (#7265737)
I've had a similar outlook for most of my life and have faced the same response. The criticism I faced for simply being realistic and pointing out flaws in the "power of positive thinking" was overwhelming and made me think there really was something wrong with me. It wasn't until I was out of the American public school system that I was able to completely distance myself from these ideas and associate only with people who were similarly realistic and grounded (not negative).
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:01PM (#7265837)
Grounding and solidity does not necessarily make something feel more real. Rather, grounding and solidity feels real to you. There are other modes of consciousness where less grounded and less solid experiences will feel real. It is also possible to train your awareness to slip between these different modes of consciousness.

Most people tend to stick with one or two modes of consciousness as that feels the most familiar and comfortable.

Further, depending on what kind of emotional triggers you have, you might be leaking a kind of emotion that is perceived as negative to other people. To you, you might be looking at something "realistically". Perhaps others are afraid to look at that stuff. Or perhaps, you have some form of aversion yourself where you avoid experiencing the "positive". (I cannot really tell just by reading your comment, just offering possibilities).

In all these cases, I don't think there is necessarily anything wrong with a person, whether they are experiencing different modes of consciousness or they have aversions.

Having said all of that, I had mentioned in other parts of the thread: "positive thinking" is usually taught incorrectly by people who suck at it. To use it correctly, you actually do have to look at what you don't want to look at. It is also not enough to think positively; you need to generate a different feeling until that feeling feels "real", from which the thinking will naturally shift into a different direction. As such, this kind of stuff requires quite a bit of skill with emotions.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by redblacktree on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:22PM (#7266327)
Where would you suggest a person start if he wanted to gain this "skill with emotions?"

That's a serious request. On re-reading, it sounds snarky, but I don't know another way to phrase it.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Friday February 21, 2014 @02:13PM (#7278777)
@redblacktree Also want to point out ... based on one of your other comments (about releasing and feeling through things rather than dwelling), you might already get some of the stuff in the Sedona Method. I wrote the above because I don't know where you are at now. There are more intense kind of practices, like the one written in Tsultrim Allione's Demon Feeding: Ancient Wisdom for Resolving Inner Conflict. Most people freak out about practices like that though.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by jaredsohn on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:35PM (#7267451)
I think you can start by reading up on emotional intelligence to gain awareness and then applying it more to new situations.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by hosh on Friday February 21, 2014 @02:07PM (#7278735)
Sure :-)

The easiest way is to find someone who is emotionally sane. You probably have at least one such person in your life. That person tends to remain calm, yet seem to be fully aware of what is going on around them. They might quietly step in to calm the situation, or perhaps, just their presence seem to calm any panic of fear. People tend to go to them for advice, not necessarily for solving problems, but because hard problems don't seem to seem as hard when you talk to such a person. It might be your mother, father, or grandmother, or grandfather. It might be be a mentor or a teacher. You ask them for help with getting in touch with your emotions. If you have someone like this in your life, and they know you well, then they'll be happy to help you on this... often because they can see how you suffer from being unable to process emotions well.

There are other approaches:

- Take the 10-day Vipassana retreat. You would get in touch with the things that arises within you.

- There are various shamanic medicine ceremonies using some form of psychedelics. These are guided, though the quality will vary. Since psychedelics alter your experiences, it opens up ways to experience emotions.

- You can go to a licensed therapist. Like gurus, meditation teachers, and shamans, quality varies ... and sometimes, therapists will have their own pet theories (as you can see in other parts of the thread on Cognitive Behavioral Therapy). A licensed hypnotherapist, or a psychologist/psychiatrist that knows how to use hynotherapy and practices meditation themselves are likely to be able to better help you with this. (Since we're not talking about behavioral modification, we're talking about becoming more self-aware). There may be other indicators, but I don't know this space well. There is usually stigma attached to this since people associate this with going to get "fixed" rather than going to get advice.

- There are also lots and lots of different kinds of seminars, workshops, etc. related to this, often crossing into the woo.

Books are the last resort, though if you read a method and like it, you can check out their their CDs, videos, and attend seminars. Books are good for sampling techniques, though without an in-person guide, it might be difficult to touch intense emotions. On the other hand, if you do have someone in your life that is emotionally sane, you could ask them to help you work with techniques from the book.

One book that is interesting is called the Sedona Method. I want to preface it to say that, what is written in the Sedona Method is not unique, though sometimes the language might make it appear so. The methods are solid though, and the authors used NLP to guide you through the experiences step by step. It is fairly accessible.

Finally, if all else fails or you have more questions or want other ideas or where to go looking for this skill, feel free to contact me. Indirect means of contact are in my profile.

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by lutorm on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:23PM (#7265972)
My own line of thinking is close to yours. However, I think it's important to draw a distinction between trying to see the positive side of things and being realistic about outcomes. Because human emotions around happiness are very relative, the way you choose to think about your situation does affect your mood. On the other hand, just having blind optimism that things will work out in the future clearly is not helpful in motivating you to put in your best effort to make it so.
Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by NDizzle on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:47PM (#7266113)
We would probably get along fantastically.

Your (our) way of thinking strongly reminds me of the "let it crash" philosophy. What are your thoughts on that?

Re:The Powerlessness of Positive Thinking by benched on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:50PM (#7266492)
Interesting that you would call that out. Yes, it so happens that as an approach to problem solving, that seems like one of the simplest to me. It's also a significant feature of my approach to programming - I've written code with minimal error checking for a long time, and it's never been a problem. Specifically, I avoid writing error checks motivated by an abstract worry that ill-formed inputs 'might' get into the system.