News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by Shivetya on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:39AM (#7264444)
Well as soon as we find a reason to use space, solving something we can only solve there that is dire enough to warrant the cost, or prove manufacturing there is well worth the expense of the cable, then perhaps the question will matter.

Its not like not having the cable prevents from exploiting space based industries, we just haven't come up with the value of the proposition

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by ef4 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:05PM (#7265023)
That's kinda missing that the whole point of researching space elevators is to dramatically change the value proposition.

Space will be economically uninteresting until somebody manages to drop the price-per-pound by a few orders of magnitude, and then an awful lot of things becoming economically interesting. A viable space elevator might just accomplish that.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by fancyketchup on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:23PM (#7265146)
Can you expand on which things you think might become economically interesting?

I can't see the cost of delivering and supporting humans in space dropping below the cost of, say, delivering and supporting humans underwater in SCUBA gear. Living in a space hab is like living in a deep-sea hab in many logistical ways (including no need for decompression time).

The only major uses of SCUBA I'm aware of are 1) the military; 2) mineral exploration; and 3) tourism. Is there really any reason to think there will be "an awful lot" of other economically interesting things to do in space?

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by adwf on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:11PM (#7265491)
Asteroid mining.

Mine some asteroids for iron, carbon, silicon, water. Now you have the raw materials for the biggest solar powerplant ever made. Ship the power down the space elevator and you have cheap renewable energy without the downsides of it being earthbound. Ship any excess ores down to earth for more profit. Some of those asteroids could have billions, if not trillions of tons of raw materials ready to use.

It's a bit far out there as ideas go, but so was visiting the moon at one point!

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by mcv on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:25AM (#7270389)
There are some big differences between space and the deep sea: easier communication, there's abundant precious metals in space, there's plenty of sunshine to generate power, and the view is a lot better. The only real similarity is that they're both really hostile environments where people need serious protection.

But you don't have to send people. There's lots of stuff in space that can be done by robots. Easier than in the deep sea, because of easier communicaton.

And if you're not talking about the deep sea, but fairly shallow seas, then doing things there isn't really all that expensive at all, and driving the costs of operating in space down to that level is going to be incredibly attractive.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by TheLoneWolfling on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:00PM (#7266561)
Forming monocrystals and other delicate processes, for one.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by comicjk on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:12PM (#7265501)
We have; here's an example. A solar panel in geostationary orbit only has a few hours of shadow per year. The incoming power is so much greater than that at the surface (about 4x the best desert) that a solar array in space will have a positive energy balance even when launched with current rockets. With a space elevator, orbital solar might be the most lucrative source of electricity. http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2012/03/space-based-sola...
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by sopooneo on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:54PM (#7266156)
How would geostationary orbit have only a few hours of shadow per year? My understanding is geostationary orbit requires you be pretty much over the equator, which would mean the satellite spent as much time on the far side of the earth as the near.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by icegreentea on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:02PM (#7266198)
Geostationary orbit is 36,000 km above the earth surface. The earth is 12,000 km in diameter. The sun is 150 MILLION km away. The about of time the something in geo-stat stays in earth's shadow is tiny.

Imagine a base runner in baseball after a home run. Spends half the time on the far side of the pitcher from the homeplate umpire, but he is only occluded from the homeplate umpire by the pitcher for a very short amount of time. That's (very!!) roughly the scales involved here.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by gliese1337 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:17PM (#7266715)
Not only that, but thanks to the fact that the Earth's rotation (and thus the plane of the equator) is tilted off of the orbital plane, even equatorial satellites far below geosynchronous orbit will only pass through the Earth's shadow at all close to the equinoxes (twice a year). Most of the time, you have eternal sunshine throughout an orbit. It's as though the metaphorical baseball player takes a flying leap so that the umpire can see him over the pitcher's head.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by sopooneo on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @08:07PM (#7268048)
Thank you. That answers it. I had no idea geostationary orbit was so high, but I probably should have.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:46PM (#7265755)
"The incoming power is so much greater than that at the surface (about 4x the best desert)"

But with 22k miles (3x earth diameter) of transmission losses.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by bsder on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @10:59PM (#7268772)
You don't have to transmit the power. You can manufacture energy-intensive things right there and then transmit the end products.

It's really easy to send stuff from orbit to Earth. The trick is keeping it from burning up on the way in.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by mcv on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:29AM (#7270401)
And that's where the space elevator is very handy. It's good for getting satelites and factories up there, but it's just as good for getting the end products down again.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by comicjk on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:59PM (#7265826)
The losses when transmitting through vacuum are pretty negligible; it's only the last fifteen miles that really cost you.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:08PM (#7265871)
That certainly might be the case, but I don't immediately see why.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by csense on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:07PM (#7266229)
I'm not a physicist, but my understanding is that there are two ways a wireless photon-based energy transmission system loses energy in transit.

First, each molecule has a specific set of frequencies where photons are "easy" to absorb because they correspond to transitions between quantum states. Any system whose goal is to deliver energy wirelessly through the atmosphere will obviously not use those frequencies.

The other way for a photon to lose energy to the medium it's traveling through is, if the medium contains molecules like water that have different parts with positive and negative charges, the electromagnetic wave will move the differently charged parts in opposite directions. The energy to do that is lost [1].

[1] "Lost" is an application-specific notion. This mechanism is also how a microwave heats food, and in this case the energy imparted to the water molecules in the food can't be considered "lost" because it's supposed to go into the food!

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by gliese1337 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:20PM (#7266753)
A third way is by diffraction- any beam, including a laser, will spread out as it travels. You get less spread with short wavelengths and large transmitters, but both of those imply expense. If you use long wavelengths and small transmitters, you need huge receivers to get all the beam energy back.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:15PM (#7266281)
Ah, you intend to keep them photons. I had been imagining converting to electrons and running down cabling attached to the elevator cable. The other approach might very well be better, but doesn't really require a space elevator does it?
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by adwf on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:55PM (#7267138)
I'd imagine they'd go with super-conducting cables personally. Space is extremely cold, so achieving a super-conducting state is simply a matter of shielding the cable from the sun. Shouldn't be too difficult... At least, not in comparison to building a space elevator in the first place!
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by lutusp on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:19PM (#7267359)
> Space is extremely cold, so achieving a super-conducting state is simply a matter of shielding the cable from the sun.

Not quite so simple. If we're talking about a cable near the earth, where the sun sometimes shines, there are always two heat paths -- from the sun to the cable, and from the cable to deep space. It's not easy, nor is a way self-evident, to make the cable fall to deep space temperatures at a reasonable cost, given that the sun is providing heat energy that must be diverted.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:05PM (#7267225)
Space is cold, but getting rid of heat is not easy in a vacuum. Not sure what that means with respect to this particular project, though.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by lutusp on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:15PM (#7267324)
> Space is cold, but getting rid of heat is not easy in a vacuum.

On the contrary, getting rid of heat in a vacuum is easier than getting rid of heat in an atmosphere. Here's a diagram of human heat loss at the surface:

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/thermo/coobod.htm...

According to this source, at the surface of earth, under the atmosphere, a person loses:

Perspiration: 17 watts

Conduction: 11 watts

Radiation: 133 watts

Without an atmosphere, the direct radiation of heat energy into space becomes more efficient (no greenhouse effect), and it's always the most efficient way to radiate heat.

It is the efficiency of direct radiation of heat energy that explains why objects at the surface can fall below air temperature overnight under a clear sky, as they surely do.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:18PM (#7267348)
Hm, that's contrary to what I'd heard, but I'll certainly defer to you on the question.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by lutusp on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:25PM (#7267398)
> Hm, that's contrary to what I'd heard

I think some of the confusion arises because of vacuum thermos bottles, which are really efficient at holding onto their heat. But how they work is a bit complicated. They deal with conduction and convection losses by having the vacuum barrier between the contents and the outside. As to radiation, they rely on a reflector that's part of the vacuum bottle, which has the effect of greatly slowing the rate of heat loss by radiation.

So the vacuum thermos avoids radiation heat loss, not because of the vacuum, but with a reflector. That works in space too -- many orbiting telescopes use reflectors to keep the sun's heat energy from heating up the sensors and spoiling their performance.

But a vacuum is a pretty good medium for heat loss by radiation. The moon's surface, heated to several hundred degrees Celsius during the lunar daytime, drops to 26 Kelvins after a few (earth) days of darkness (26 degrees above absolute zero). That's a new figure, lower than had been realized, and seven degrees colder than the surface of Pluto.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:42PM (#7268925)
Interesting speculation. I can't say whether it was related in my case - certainly it wasn't first-order (discussions I am very vaguely recalling revolved around satellites, but it was at least a decade and a half ago), but it could easily have been a cause of the meme in the first place.

I do recall someone explicitly stating that radiation is a poor means of losing heat compared to convection and conduction - which seems to just be wrong.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by lutusp on Thursday February 20, 2014 @01:23AM (#7269225)
> I do recall someone explicitly stating that radiation is a poor means of losing heat compared to convection and conduction - which seems to just be wrong.

Yes -- it's a common belief, and it's wrong. Under clear skies after dark, objects on the surface that are convectively coupled to the atmosphere will quickly fall below air temperature because of radiation heat loss, which can produce what is called "radiation fog", so named because it's caused by the air being cooled by the ground, which in turn has been cooled by direct radiation into space.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fog#Radiation_fog

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by delluminatus on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:01PM (#7264992)
And the space elevator is not something that would be developed by interplanetary travelers but by people who just want to get into Earth orbit.

I think it would mainly be useful for people either launching/maintaining a lot of satellites, or living in Earth orbit. Or if someone is producing energy or material in space (orbital solar power stations?) and they want to easily transmit it back to Earth, an elevator would probably be more efficient than weekly collection runs.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by ef4 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:07PM (#7265040)
> And the space elevator is not something that would be developed by interplanetary travelers but by people who just want to get into Earth orbit.

That's not true at all. The vast majority of the energy cost of going to another planet is incurred just getting into earth orbit. A space elevator radically improves the economics of interplanetary travel.

In fact, you can get certain transfer orbits "for free" by just extending your tether a bit beyond geosynchronous orbit and using it to fling bulk payloads to Mars, etc.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by timdiggerm on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:16PM (#7265536)
Although it does make getting into orbit very slow.

In "Blue Mars" by Kim Stanley Robinson, we get to a point where travel between Earth and Mars is faster than the elevator ride from the top of Earth's elevator to the bottom.

Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by mcv on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:17AM (#7270366)
We already have reason to use space. The big problem is that it's prohibitively expensive to get there. A space elevator solves that problem. Of course the elevator itself is prohibitively expensive too, but if it's possible at all, those costs will eventually be recouped.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by Zikes on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:43AM (#7264468)
Asteroid mining.
Re:Can Quiet, Efficient 'Space Elevators' Really Work? by polymatter on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:01PM (#7264993)
Not in the short term see (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asteroid_mining#Financial_feasi...). It is a lot cheaper, easier and less risky to mine even very rare minerals on Earth rather than do so in space. And will be too for the foreseeable future. Plus any investor doesn't want to dump platinum on the market as then the price would plummet and seriously erase the profit. And you'll want a lot of guaranteed returns to undertake such a financially risky investment.

I could see Space Tourism taking off though. Taking space jet skis out for a spin round the moon and back that kind of thing. Perhaps some exclusive space hotel.