News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by beloch on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @02:45PM (#7260567)
You've had critial success. You've made so much money you could retire, buy an island, and still have enough left over to turn it into a supervillain lair! I get it. You're only in it now for the love of creating, so why not leave the headaches of A titles behind? This is perfectly sensible. Handing off irrational to a protégé, taking your buddies and spinning off a smaller studio would be a great way to do this. Firing half the company that brought you success, however, is a bit of a dick move.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by bertil on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @03:19PM (#7260759)
He writes:

> There’s no great way to lay people off, and our first concern is to make sure that the people who are leaving have as much support as we can give them during this transition.

I've been through that recently (individually, though: specific skill-set, not right for the stage of development of the game) and recommendations go a very long way. Gaming, especially AAA, is actually a lot like the film industry on the HR point of view, except they don't really admit it: one-to-two-year-long projects, with a release date; little need for the same workers after that; many very specific, creative, expertise; a lot of rule of thumb, best practice to master through apprenticeship; recommendation being the tell-all; producers with far too often a horrible reputation; etc. Having a structure that handles that (union, special temporary worker status) would help facing the reality, which is frequently changing employers. Studios, movies and games alike, like to work with the same people for the next projects if things went well -- but half the time, no re-employment in the film industry is not a bad review, just a different creative direction. I'm not saying Hollywood Unions are the best example (or that French’ high direct subsidies and Status d'intermittent are cheap) but thinking about the differences between the two industry would help.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by jimwalsh on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @03:56PM (#7260981)
Not really. Their last game (Infinite) was a flop (AAA game that only sold 4m units). Take Two control the money, and with those kinds of results (huge team of 300 something, that took six plus years to create Infinite) you can imagine they weren't lining up to do another title. So Ken did what he could so that some of the studio would stay alive.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by hybrid11 on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @04:14PM (#7261109)
4M units is as of last summer (March to August), they've sold more than that by now. That's comparable to Bioshock 2 sales.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BioShock_Infinite#Sales http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BioShock_2#Sales

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by scott_s on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @04:37PM (#7261280)
I disagree with your characterization of Bioshock Infinite as a "flop." Usually, calling something a "flop" means that it was wildly unsuccessful. Infinite may not have re-couped its investment, but it was not wildly unsuccessful. That would be selling under, say, 100,000 units.

(Keep in mind this is a semantic distinction, and not a value judgement of the game itself.)

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by kosei on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:29AM (#7262323)
The last game that studio published was 6 years ago - Bioshock in 2007; Bioshock 2 was shipped by another studio. If they had 100+ employees (not unreasonable for a AAA game studio), they could have incurred personnel costs of $60M+ for the game's development. Which could definitely be considered a failure in the eyes of a game that only shipped 4MM games.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by scott_s on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @09:20AM (#7263695)
Right, but there is a difference between a "failure" and a "flop."
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by csbrooks on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:49PM (#7266126)
There isn't one in terms of publisher behavior. Either way the series gets axed.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by antimagic on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:37AM (#7262942)
Sure, but just look at the numbers - let's firstly boost the number to 300 employees, not 100, I think that's closer to real, with an everage salary of around $60k. That puts salaries at about $180m. But, they sold 4 million copies at about $60 each, which makes $240m profit. Allowing for a decent ad spend, you're still looking at a back of the envelope break-even. OK, I get that investors might be bummed about that, but it's enough money to mean that they live to fight another day, have another crack at hitting it out of the park.

As others have noted, AAA games are hit-based propositions. You pretty much have a few (3-5) titles that make all of the money each year, another 10 or so that hold the line, and everyone else loses. It's the last group that are flops, the second group are the par result. I think we can safely say that Bioshock Infinite was in the second group...

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by timje1 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:45AM (#7262961)
The $240m figure is not profit, it's gross income. Taxes, marketing costs and distribution costs will dwarf that figure. In some cases, AAA games can even spend more on marketing than wages.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by benbou09 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:10AM (#7263017)
I think 60$ average is a bit high

Source: I bought it on Steam for 8€

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by fat0wl on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @09:54AM (#7263860)
lol yea i bought this for.... $7.50 and got the DLC bundle (which sucked) for about 5 IIRC
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by Shivetya on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @07:18AM (#7263219)
they certainly do not get the full 60 per copy. I am not sure what current publishing deals are set at but I would be surprised if they even see 40
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by kosei on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:56AM (#7264539)
Yup. Usually I remember the rubric being about $30 back to the publisher on a $60-$70 title. MS/Sony each take a cut and so does the distributor (Steam, Wal-Mart, Best Buy, etc). Plus, as pointed out in comments below, there's also the fact that not all copies were sold at full price. So you're looking AT BEST at $120M in revenue, plus Irrational had TV ads and other large costs in addition to their staffing.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by AmVess on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:05AM (#7264232)
For PC games, Hard copies return roughly 40-45% of the title to the publisher.

Valve gets a 30% slice for distribution on Steam.

I do not know what the breakdown of costs are on consoles, but I assume both Sony and MS still get a cut of the sales.

Consider that the bulk of a game's sales will be realized during the first week, and the rapid time to discount, it's no wonder T2 decided to pull the cord on Irrational Games.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by ijk on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:34AM (#7261989)
The problem being, AAA game development is hit driven enough that a common publishing strategy is blockbuster tentpole or bust.

Many of the games produced are fine games, and some even sell well, but may not match the (possibly extremely overoptimistic) financial forecasts. So, "flop" is probably pejorative. It does fit what the business reaction seems to be to some of these games, but that may be a problem originating with something other than the game.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by enraged_camel on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @11:37PM (#7261812)
>>Usually, calling something a "flop" means that it was wildly unsuccessful.

To me, "flop" means it failed to meet the rather ambitious expectations, and instead performed only moderately well.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by uchi on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:47AM (#7263118)
So what would you call something that actually 'flops' by the English definition standard? A cataclysmic failure bound to ruin any and all associated with it?
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by naiyt on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @07:12PM (#7261408)
Kind of odd that 4m units is considered a flop. Jim Sterling did a video on that idea of what AAA "success" in terms of sales is awhile ago:

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/jimquisition/712...

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by sliverstorm on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @04:08PM (#7261063)
Wasn't it widely considered one of the best games of the year? How did it flop?
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by chops on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @04:15PM (#7261117)
Just like he said: Though it was an amazing game (I bought it opening day), it only sold 4m units. Unfortunate that that's considered a flop.

By comparison, Modern Warfare 3 sold 10m copies on day one.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by kayoone on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:35AM (#7262746)
And thats sad... More mindless military shooters year after year after year
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by deevus on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @04:23PM (#7261174)
It was such an amazing game. Is this just like Looking Glass and Terra Nova?
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by AimHere on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @09:36PM (#7261486)
Well LGS made about three games after Terra Nova, so maybe not. Their last full game was Thief 2 which I think made money but not enough to warrant them being kept alive in the wake of the Daikatana fiasco.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by gendoikari on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @05:38AM (#7262946)
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by deevus on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:27AM (#7270395)
Terra Nova was the disaster that led to their demise. It's a shame because I was one of the 100,000 people that purchased it, and it is still one of my favourite games of all time. It's up there with SS2, Half Life, Quake.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by afterburner on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @09:18PM (#7261445)
The 16th best-selling game of 2013 was a flop?

http://metro.co.uk/2014/01/16/100-best-selling-video-games-o...

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by ijk on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:05AM (#7261900)
Note that number 6 on that list is Tomb Raider, which Square Enix publicly declared to be a flop:

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2013-03-26-tomb-raider-has...

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by cwyers on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @09:39AM (#7263782)
Well, they said it missed the sales target. The game did make Square Enix a profit:

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/7.839763-Tomb-Ra...

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by bunderbunder on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @10:08PM (#7261565)
Considering how much it must have cost to produce, yeah it's believable. #6 on the list was also considered a failure for not selling enough copies.

Rough outline of the business plan behind most AAA titles:

1. Assume all 10 of us have a >50% chance at being among the year's top 3 sellers.

2. Scale budget according to assumptions from step 1.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by sspiff on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @07:58AM (#7263355)
4 million in retail, that's excluding Steam and other digital distribution platforms. I know a lot of gamers, but none of them buy games in retail.
Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by sspiff on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @08:01AM (#7263371)
Exactly. I was expecting to read about the rising costs of developing quality AAA games and how even well received games failed to recoup their cost.

Instead, I read a story of a guy who wants to do something else, and decided that the best way to do that is to fire most of his employees. Quite frankly, I'm surprised this is even legal. Handing over the group seems like a much more sensible plan.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by mikegreiling on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @08:24PM (#7268128)
you're surprised that it is legal to do what you want with a company you own? how would you suggest the government get involved exactly?

there's nothing stopping these fired employees from banding together and forming their own company.

Re:Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down by jamesaguilar on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @03:47PM (#7260925)
Hard to say without knowing the current ownership structure of the studio. It may not have been his call to make. Or maybe they couldn't find a buyer who could offer terms they found acceptable.