Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by tbrownaw on Monday February 17, 2014 @07:45PM
(#7255564)
You literally can't put too much emphasis on hiring the right person.
You (almost) can't put too much emphasis on not hiring the wrong person.
Which is not the same.
Suppose your interview process has a 5% false-positive rate. Do you get more incompetents (say, bottom 5%) by looking for people in the top 50% or the top 5%?
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by derefr on Monday February 17, 2014 @07:08PM
(#7255408)
This only applies if you actually allow people to assume that "hired" means "staying." If you "hire" people on a tentative basis, and tell them that you're doing so, then this can work. (And you don't tentatively hire people who would have to relocate, etc.)
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by greenyoda on Monday February 17, 2014 @07:21PM
(#7255459)
Why would an employee who is not desperate for a job give up their current job in exchange for a position that's probationary? Setting up a situation where the employer can bail out with no cost to themselves indicates that they have zero commitment to making the relationship work.
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by derefr on Monday February 17, 2014 @07:33PM
(#7255512)
How about an employee who is not desperate for a job, but who also currently does not have a job? This would be the situation created by a Basic Income Guarantee.
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by PeterisP on Monday February 17, 2014 @08:13PM
(#7255679)
As per TFA, we're talking abot 0%-unemployment industry here. Such situations happen, but they're the exceptions, not something to base your policy on.
Seriously, even all the quality 2nd year undergrads I see are working already, at least here if you want to hire people who don't have a job then most of them are seriously incompetent people or extremely young.
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by derefr on Monday February 17, 2014 @08:23PM
(#7255724)
I guess I'm thinking of a different definition of "unemployed" than you are. Maybe replace your mental definition with "independently wealthy." E.g. "I'm happy just spending all day coding my own projects, but if you give me the right incentives, I'll join your company... tentatively. With the tentativeness going both ways."
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by eropple on Monday February 17, 2014 @11:19PM
(#7256348)
Which doesn't exist...so what's the point of this subthread you well-actually'd me about?
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by natrius on Monday February 17, 2014 @09:40PM
(#7256019)
You're overselling the basic income. Most software developers have grown used to the lifestyle their income affords and would have to uproot their lives to live on a basic income. The average San Francisco rent would probably eat up all of it.
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by pekk on Monday February 17, 2014 @10:04PM
(#7256098)
Why wouldn't you just prefer someone more desperate - who you could therefore get more out of for the same money?
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by greenyoda on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @02:03PM
(#7260238)
Sure, if you're looking for a random developer to exploit, and the only requirement is that they can code fizzbuzz, go for desperate. But if you're looking for a highly competent and experienced developer, chances are that they'll already have a pretty good job and you'll need to work very hard to convince them that your job is better.
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by eropple on Monday February 17, 2014 @07:32PM
(#7255509)
What remotely healthy environment in this industry does not assume a hiring without specific contract length means "staying"?
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday February 17, 2014 @08:06PM
(#7255649)
If I wanted contract work, I'd do that instead.
Re:By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out Th...
by 6d0debc071 on Monday February 17, 2014 @07:50PM
(#7255589)
It depends what sort of life you're turning upside down. For low level jobs I can see hire fast fire fast being a fairly good thing, it lets people have a crack and maybe prove themselves, where they wouldn't be able to pass a more risk averse setup.
Both sides gamble. What's kind's going to depend on what they're putting up.
You literally can't put too much emphasis on hiring the right person. Not because of you. Firing someone, at least in the U.S., is easy. But you hurt people when you hire the wrong people. You turn their lives upside-down because you made the wrong decision. If you have a shred of a conscience, you'll hire scrupulously because doing otherwise makes you shitty.
"Hire fast, fire fast" is immoral. "Hire slow, fire fast" less so, if you compensate the worker because in almost every case (that is, this isn't true in cases of criminality, harrassment, etc.) it's your mistake, not theirs, and you owe them.