Not inherently. Arguably, a large-scale mesh network would be more susceptible to interference, due to the larger number of distinct parties involved in each communication. The difference is that because a mesh network assumes the lack of trust in the intermediate nodes, a sensible design for one has to include end-to-end security.
I've been thinking about this recently. The idea is that it's transparent. Imagine, for example, if Apple started shipping this on all iOS devices, or it became a common android feature. Here is a blog post I wrote on the topic last month: http://stevenjewel.com/2014/01/android-mesh/
I'm not so sure, your links are almost c, whereas optic fiber is substantially slower, so it depends entirely on how little processing you can get away with in the message passing code.
edit - was just thinking about this, an arm cortex runs at ~ 2,000 MIPS, which gives you just under 15 cm per instruction for radio in air. Fiber is about a third slower, so your links do not actually have to be massively long to give you quite a few cycles to play with.
* Consumers would no longer be dependent on monopolies like Comcast for internet service (OSI layer 1)
* It is much more resistant to eavesdropping and censorship (OSI layers 2-3)
These seem like two totally different problems to me, and I'm still struggling to understand how the physical layer part can work on a large scale.
I get how they could work on a small scale. For example, you could easily set up an ad-hoc wifi network in a college dorm for, say, file sharing purposes. But in most other settings, I don't get how it could work. Most people don't even talk to their neighbors, so even if you lived in a neighborhood that had a high enough density of nodes for this to work, why would you want to share a little ad-hoc network with your neighbors?
Of course, wireless networks alone aren't going to be sufficient to build a large-scale mesh network that could disrupt existing ISPs. The latency alone makes this infeasible. So you need someone to invest in physical links, especially physical links that cover long distances. That's why the BTC part of this proposal is so great -- it provides a way to compensate these people. Of course, this is just a slightly different problem than the one we have today, but instead of being stuck with Comcast we're stuck with whoever runs these physical links.