That's likely true, since only a couple of firms can do it, and there are millions of people's interest in the markets. The NYTimes article this article pulls from specifically points out that these few firms are taking money out of the pockets of "slower" firms, like hedge funds. Given that a large number of people in the country have their retirement funds tied up in hedge funds, until someone shows otherwise, this is clearly the rich stealing from the poor.
I understand that those in the industry have a different worldview, but try to see the bigger picture. The only difference between grossly immoral and illegal is a few years and a new law. If this isn't illegal, its because the population hasn't been sufficiently outraged. Yet.
The greatest thing Wall Street sells is dreams. This will never go away. Every buy carries with it the thought that this one will go higher. Otherwise people wouldn't buy. As long as Wall Street continues to allow retail investors to play in the markets, there will be people who will come along for the ride.
EDIT: Don't get mad at me for saying it. I think I'm doing people a favor by pointing this out. You won't hear this from many other people.
It boils down to this, in my opinion:
1) The market is simply random. Every stock you buy is a bet placed on a roulette table.
2) Mutual funds, derivatives, etc are just ways of hiding the randomness. (Hey, why play at one roulette table when you can play at 1,000 at the same time! Less risk!)
3) Even if you do decide to take the plunge and buy in, the system is rigged against you. Much smarter people have figured out how to get theirs and get out before you know what's happened. The house always wins.
But I don't see that market as being ABOUT that anymore. It's become a world of side bets and arbitrage plays. When an outsider analyst has more influence over the price of a stock than the company itself, then the market is a game, not an investment.
For example: a company can show growth, real POSITIVE growth...but ohmygodholyjebus if it's not EXACTLY what the analysts predicted then the stock is toast for the quarter. What the hell is that all about? Why do we play quarter to quarter instead of decade to decade? Because Wall Street is now about churn. And churn makes commissions.
Now, with that said, I will say that I don't believe the markets are 100% efficient. No matter how many papers Sharpe, Fama, French, and others publish, I will never change my mind. Globally, the markets are extremely efficient, but there are local inefficiencies. Identifying and exploiting the local inefficiencies are what makes one really good at making money off of the markets.
I don't 'have a problem' with automated trading. I'm just opining that frequency and legality, in and of themselves, are not compelling defenses.
Imagine Party A says 'marijuana's awful' and party B says 'everyone's doing it, and it's technically legal because we all have glaucoma'.
I'm pointing out --separate from whether I (dis)agree with A-- that party B isn't going to sway anyone with that approach.