News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by tptacek on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @12:57PM (#7225973)
Penn’s response? – Sending some administrator to see me in the hospital (HUP). The first and only thing that she said was, “Are we going to make this an annual pattern?” because I had been hospitalized the year before. I said “No” and she gave me her business card.

My kids are going to college in a couple of years. How do I avoid sending them to places like this?

People expect (and should expect) to be treated better than this by their employers. But by their vendors?

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by carbocation on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:35PM (#7226255)
I have no affiliation with Penn. However, I would be cautious before accepting the literal words of the story at face value.

I accept without reservation that this is how this person perceives the interaction with the administrator. But before accepting that this is how Penn's administrators believe they interacted with the person, or how a third party would perceive the interaction, I'd like more information. Being ill enough to be in the hospital -- even for non-psychiatric disease -- can cloud the sensorium. And this is a grave allegation.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by tptacek on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:38PM (#7226286)
I'm happy to hear other people agree that it's a grave accusation.
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by lmkg on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:07PM (#7226059)
Send them to a small teaching-focused college. Institutions that are large, focused on graduate students, and/or focused on research have an incentive structure that puts a lower priority on the care of individual students.

I went to a <1000-student college, and when I had some trouble at home I had an hour-long session with the school counselor, who referred me to a nearby professional. I was also on a first-name basis with some of the deans, and they were able to help accommodate me.

tl;dr Go somewhere that you're a person and not a statistic.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by haberman on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:17PM (#7226574)
It's really interesting to notice the trade-offs. I went to a small-ish, teaching-focused college (The University of Puget Sound: http://www.pugetsound.edu/). And just as you say, I found that the faculty and staff was really supportive and concerned with our well-being.

And while the faculty was very strong, I sometimes felt jealous of friends from the University of Washington (the nearby Huge Research Institution) and what seemed like a more extensive CS program with more resources. I heard about some of the classes my friends took that our program didn't really have any equivalent for. I would read about some of the problem sets that sounded amazing, like a security class where you're given a VM image and the problem set is to compromise some of the programs inside the VM. Advanced curriculum like that seems difficult to develop without a lot of grad students around. A part of me has always pined for that experience I didn't get to have.

I guess it's hard to have it all.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by tptacek on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @03:09PM (#7226937)
As someone who has done a pretty serviceable job of building those kinds of courses for systems security: I wouldn't be jealous of that at all; the fundamentals of CS are what matters.

If that's something that's still interesting to you, check out http://microcorruption.com.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by haberman on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @03:57PM (#7227228)
> If that's something that's still interesting to you, check out http://microcorruption.com.

I was very excited to see that for just that reason. :) I think I peaked at #24 on the day it was announced, but I'm sure I've slipped quite a bit since then.

Fundamentals are important; agreed, but the difference between knowing the theory of buffer overflows and having actually exploited one is a huge to me. Now I can say that I have actually done that, thanks to you having packaged everything up so nicely on microcorruption.com, but even that isn't 100% of the experience I would like to have, because the environment is a lot different than what I program on day-to-day.

For example, I know that I shouldn't map any memory wx (and I explained this rule in my article about JITs: http://blog.reverberate.org/2012/12/hello-jit-world-joy-of-s...), but I don't really know why. I don't actually know what an attack would look like where having wx memory around makes an exploit easier.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by pbsd on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:48PM (#7227938)
If you can control what gets written to the wx memory, then all you have to do as an attacker is rewrite a function pointer or return address to that memory. Better yet, if you can rewrite a return address, you can "return" to a read call (or some fancier ROP chain) that will read the rest of your shellcode into the wx memory and execute it.

In either case, having that kind of memory around can only make things easier for an attacker, while by itself not being exactly a vulnerability.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by lutusp on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:37PM (#7226270)
I suggest that you think a bit more deeply about this. It's possible that the administrator was being thoughtless, but there's another interpretation -- it's a bad idea to give suicide attempters too much attention. By responding with too much sympathy, one can become a "suicide enabler", the suicide equivalent of a narcissistic enabler.

If a person threatens suicide and gets nothing but attention and sympathy, this can trigger a cyclical, escalating pattern of threats and sympathetic responses that can sometimes trap the person into going through with the suicide.

Here's a true story -- many years ago one of my brothers committed suicide. After a few weeks, another brother told me he was compiling a list of people he felt were responsible for the suicide. My first comment was, "Is [the suicide] included on the list?" Of course, he wasn't. My next comment was that the list was dangerous -- the suicide's son would see how attentive and sympathetic everyone was being and he might begin to think suicide was a good idea. My brother didn't really understand what I was saying, the list got created and passed around, and a few years later, the suicide's son committed suicide also.

True story.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by gizmo on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:45PM (#7226342)
I'm very sorry you lost people to suicide. Compiling the list may just have been a coping mechanism for your brother, and I don't think it's fair to think it had anything to do with the son's suicide.
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by lutusp on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:22PM (#7226616)
> Compiling the list may just have been a coping mechanism for your brother, and I don't think it's fair to think it had anything to do with the son's suicide.

I didn't say it that way, either here or at the time. I only warned my brother that the list might provoke my nephew to kill himself, not that this would make my brother responsible. The actual suicide was, of course, solely the responsibility of the nephew.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by dennisgorelik on Thursday February 13, 2014 @12:25PM (#7232663)
Did your brother tell you that he was sorry for ignoring your advise, after your nephew killed himself?
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by tptacek on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:43PM (#7226333)
I find this sentiment alarming. I'd ask you to reread the article, particularly the first quarter of it, and stipulate that the account is accurate. What do you think of this particular response to an actual suicide attempt?

I'm sorry about your brother. I've lost close friends to suicide. For what it's worth: I don't blame them, anymore than I would blame someone who died of leukemia for their illness. But a suicide has many victims, and I can't blame you for being angry either.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by lutusp on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:16PM (#7226569)
> I find this sentiment alarming.

It's not a "sentiment", it's a case history. My brother created a list of guilty parties, people responsible for a suicide, but didn't include the suicide on the list. My nephew drew the obvious conclusion -- if he killed himself, this would place him outside any notion of responsibility, and he would get massive sympathy as well.

It was unbelievably irresponsible to portray suicide that way, and it had a predictable effect. But the responsibility for suicide rests solely with those who kill themselves.

> I've lost close friends to suicide. For what it's worth: I don't blame them ...

I do. To me, if suicides understand that they'll be held responsible, that they will be judged to have ungratefully thrown away the gift of life, they shouldn't expect sympathy, that might have a beneficial effect on the suicide rate.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by tptacek on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @03:11PM (#7226946)
I'm not here to judge anything your family did in response to a suicide. I'm sorry you had to deal with it at all. I don't have an opinion beyond that.

But I can be clinical about a case I read in a blog post by a stranger, and I remain interested in your response to that case.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by DanBC on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:43PM (#7226770)
How important do you think the list was as a factor? Is it the main factor? Or do you mention it to support a point?
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by lutusp on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @07:02PM (#7228401)
I only brought it up to warn my brother of the dangers in making suicide look attractive, as a way to get sympathy. Once my prediction came to pass, obviously I dropped the topic. In any case, as far as I am concerned, the person committing suicide is entirely and solely responsible.
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by DanBC on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:04PM (#7226488)
When someone expresses suicidal ideation you get that person support because suicidal thinking is a risk factor for attempted and completed suicide.

Treating a suicidal person harshly because you don't want to encourage suicidal behaviour is a sub optimal strategy if your aim is to reduce the numbers or people attempting suicide and dying from suicide.

Suicide is a significant cause of death so it's probably a good thing to better understand suicidal thinking and behaviour.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by lutusp on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:13PM (#7226547)
> Treating a suicidal person harshly ...

Wait, what? That's not what I said. I'm saying it's a mistake to give too much attention and sympathy to suicidal ideations.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by DanBC on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:41PM (#7226756)
I would equate that to being harsh.
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by lutusp on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @10:52PM (#7229261)
It's a simple question of what works. Giving too much sympathy and attention to someone who discusses suicide is a bad idea. It is to suicide what an enabler is to a narcissist.

It's more constructive to think of a way to get the person to imagine something other than suicide, but in a way that doesn't encourage a repeat performance.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by javert on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:13PM (#7226105)
You have to really be there for yours kids, as a parent, and make efforts to understand them and support them. That's about all you can do. And that's probably enough.

College students everywhere are cruel and callous (which seemed to be one of the big factors in the story). And my school did not have the kind of therapist support described in the article---seems like Penn is probably ahead of 99% of large US schools in that regard.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by Volscio on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:06PM (#7226052)
I went to and live near NYU and not much time passes between each attempted undergrad suicide. I experienced the same thing among soldiers (particularly those in basic training and AIT) who would harm themselves.

The general dismissive attitude of higher-ups and admins is that pill overdosing is attention-seeking behavior and that things like kids jumping off high locations is communicable behavior. So that's what suicide prevention folks are up against in terms of enlisting help from those on campus.

I would guess if this is a significant concern to you then you'll want to make sure the college has an active, directed, intentional position for a suicide prevention specialist or group whose sole responsibility is identifying, preventing, and treating potential suicide cases.

Because unfortunately admins and even RAs aren't always going to be the most attentive about this issue on their own.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by mrjaeger on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:36PM (#7226262)
I think this very much depends on what your kids are like. Are they very outgoing and good in new situations? Then it most likely won't matter where you send them - they will find a place they fit in and have a great group of friends they can be supported by. However if they may not be as naturally personable, then looking into what the school itself offers and how your child will be able to take advantage of that is crucial.

And the other huge factor to me is what your kids want to study. A big factor in this person getting into this situation in the first place was the crushing sense of loneliness she felt at Penn due to the fact that she couldn't have real social interactions with her friends. There was always some secondary motive (studying most often) that didn't allow her to just relax and be comfortable. I went to a large state school where people certainly valued doing well at school, but where socializing and being there for each other was paramount. There just wasn't such an ingrained culture of '4.0 GPA or death' that seems to come up in these more competitive schools. I had a bunch of friends with minor to severe mental health issues and there was never any doubt about what came first - grades or friends, and this seemed to be the way I saw most people interact.

However I was also lucky to be in a field where my side-projects and initiative counted for more than anything else. If I had been trying to become a doctor, or a lawyer, or some trader on Wall Street, my choice in schools could have been a serious detriment to my career. But to me becoming a well adjusted person and learning to deal with all the world can throw at you were perhaps the most important things I got out of college. Just my 2 cents.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by rnprdk on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:51PM (#7226407)
I went to Butler University and I struggled much like the Penn student above. Two hospitalizations while there, I believe. Everyone involved there--all the professors I knew, and all the administrators who took on my case--were just exceptionally supportive and kind. They really cared, and they were damned good at what they did. In the end I wouldn't have gotten onto the path of getting better without them--especially my advisor, who intervened in a very personal way that probably took some guts.

Another person suggested small teaching colleges. Seeing as Butler is a 4000-ish person college, maybe there's something to this. But I'd like to think that even in big colleges, the student-health-oriented administrative staff would be on their game. I dunno.

Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by meat_fist on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:39PM (#7226291)
Unless you're the best of the best, or you really care, an ivy-league school isn't going to be great for your quality of life. I know tons of kids that have cracked under the pressures of penn/cornell/etc. Send your kids to smaller, less prestigious school.
Re:Why I Tried To Kill Myself at Penn by smartistone on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:19PM (#7226148)
If you're kids are at risk then perhaps college should be postponed..you're kinda out of luck because at some point they will have to make their own choices.