2) More secure password. You won't be susceptible to many brute-force based hacking methods because your password won't be in any rainbow tables or anything like that.
Two-step verification (also known as two-factor authentication) is a process involving two stages to verify the identity of an entity trying to access services in a computer or in a network. This is a special case of a multi-factor authentication which involves the presentation of two or more of the three authentication factors: a knowledge factor, a possession factor, and an inherence factor.
Think about what would happen if your phone gets owned by some malware that escalates to root. It can simply log the PIN, extract the key and then login as it wishes. That's because the phone is the single factor for the service.
Compare that with the auth against, say, Gmail, where even if a malware were to own the Authenticator, it still couldn't login as you, since your password goes directly to the service.
This thing basically looks like a more automated version of Google Authenticator. Cool, but meh, would it really change my life?
But maybe it would make a difference for the same market that feels like the iPhone 5s's fingerprint scanner is way more convenient than previous security mechanisms on the iPhone and so can never go back. I dunno.
Not true. From his list of problems, TOTP does not require the Clef servers (or any third-party server), nor does it require your phone camera or (more importantly) phone networking to be working.
And to make the comparison fair, you have to realize that this is not two-factor. There's only one factor (something you have) since there isn't a password requirement.
click login box, type, tab, type, enter
It is moreso:
click login box, type one of passwords 1-10, tab, type, enter
Which assumes you remember each one. It's an even better use case scenario if you are the guy with only one password for everything.
1. click login button 2. there is no step 2
Also, Lastpass doesn't seem to offer to do as much for me anymore. Maybe I screwed something up in my config, but I don't see an AutoLogin option anymore.
So I'm just about ready to abandon Lastpass if anything else comes along that gives me a user experience like Lastpass used to give me. I don't know whether Clef is that service, but I'm at least glad that someone is exploring the space.
It's a tough problem. Human memories are fallible, yet it's with you always. Passwords can be given to others, which can be convenient in many situations (something bio recognition can't do). Bio markers like fingerprints are left everywhere as CCC has demonstrated, or the markers themselves can change such as with Macular degeneration in eyes. Phones can be stolen or run out of battery, physical key cards lost, and centralized systems like RSA's SecurID hacked.
In a lot of ways the banks have it done best, with combining a replaceable physical object (loanable) with a short PIN (sharable and more memorable), and then throwing fraud detection on top of it. It's the last piece that's the best and also the least available for others to do easily.
The problem would be better addressed by having a turn-key solution that any company can easily plug into their code to detect fraud attempts on short passwords. Big hole waiting for a startup to fill...
Obviously a benevolent site will NOT save/process those failed passwords, it may even take care to have them NOT stored in any logs...
An malevolent site on the other hand may even trick you into providing it some of your other passwords to it...
...cache invalidation, naming things and secure authentication for a broad public
battery not dead...
Step 1: Install the Yubico Authenticator from the Play Store.
Step 2: Install the OATH applet. Linux instructions are at http://forum.yubico.com/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=1159, but there are OS X instructions kicking around on the forums as well.
Step 3: Wherever you would normally use Google Authenticator, use the Yubico Authenticator instead.
You now have proper two-factor authentication.
EDIT: Wrong link...
The whole point of two-factor authentication is to make it so you need two things of two different types. You reduced this problem to having two passwords (two things of the same type).
(Even worse, until relatively recently they had used numeric passwords (those had to be set from a phone, using DTMF tone dial). This had changed only 3 or maybe 4 years ago. Wonder whenever that change was 2FA-related. :) )
So I'm uncertain whenever SMS is more secure.
Current process: click login box, type, tab, type, enter. With clef: click cleff box, find phone, unlock phone, launch clef app, hold in front of screen, wait.
All of this to create an "advantage" of not having to remember a password at the cost of probably 15-30 seconds longer login time and a login process with more brittleness, as many steps, and more complicated steps.
Is there a big advantage I'm missing, because right now this looks worse in almost every way and dubiously better in only one.
I say dubious because I wouldn't trust the system to work, so id still memorize backup passwords. But some people have higher trust and thus would get the benefit.
The animation is cool though.