At one point, they probably were a Unix. But Unix as a place and Unix as a goal are two very different things. Both skiers and mountainclimbers find themselves at the tops of mountains.
> When the term "Linux" is used in general, we mean a unix.
You mean a Unix. I mean Linux. There is no "we".
> So yes, refugees from Windows coming over to distros that have always been unix(-like) and trying to change them into the some sort of Windows-like junk is a problem.
I don't believe you. Where are these vanguard Unix-style Linux distros? RHEL? Adopting systemd. Debian? Adopting systemd. SUSE? Adopting systemd. These are distributions from the days of old. They have formed a consensus that systemd-style Linux is the future.
I mean I think it is fair to say that the Linux community is divided on this issue. But characterizing the systemd/dbus/ufs folks as "Windows refugees" is totally inaccurate. Systemd has the backing of important community members of the Linux community.
Not really. The implementation of the kernel, userland features etc are quite different between traditional derived unices and Linux.
But it sure is a full blown POSIX.
The irony here is that they can go fork all of this stuff, it's not like none of it has forked before, if they don't like redhat they can run something else. Getting passed off and forking is also the UNIX way
This philosophy (along with it being Free Software) is why I chose to migrate to Linux in the first place, so long ago: it was Unix. Ya, ya, "Unix-like", technically, due to the trademark on Unix.
That last statement is very strange:
> Fedora that they ought to be Unix
As somebody who wore an authentic Red Hat fedora for many years, this makes no sense. They've certainly called themselves a unix (in the generic, no trademark), and alternative to Unix (tm, aka Solaris, HP-UX, and others derived from Bell Labs IP) http://www.redhat.com/solutions/migration/migrate-from-unix-...
Wikipedia, on fedora: "OS family: Unix-like"
etc
When the term "Linux" is used in general, we mean a unix. The distinction has only ever a trademark thing.
So yes, refugees from Windows coming over to distros that have always been unix(-like) and trying to change them into the some sort of Windows-like junk is a problem. Some of us left that world of bad design little choice a long time ago, and have no intention of returning.