News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You never did math in high school by cperciva on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:00PM (#7222003)
Yes I did. Also:

when a freshman college student tells me that he was always good at math, it translates to “I was very good at following obscure steps to manipulate mysterious symbols, without any real understanding of what they mean.”

The most common complaint I hear about undergraduate students is that they aren't able to blindly manipulate symbols, and consequently get hopelessly confused when they have to deal with "unintuitive" concepts.

Re:You never did math in high school by baddox on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:07PM (#7222047)
It's even worse than that. It's more like "I was very good at doing enough of the practice/homework problems to memorize all the possible combinations of problems that will end up on the test."
Re:You never did math in high school by Pxtl on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @11:05PM (#7222418)
Exactly. You have to remember who the loudest complainers in a school are - not the nerds, not the losers, but the keeners. The kids who play the game of earning marks instead of learning to think.

That's who the current system panders to, because they're the ones who scream loudest when it doesn't. And they find it morally offensive if you ever ask them to solve a problem that isn't extremely similar to an example they've already seen.

And they're the ones who think they're "good at math". That's who highschool caters to because that's what standardized testing caters to and that's what the noisiest parents and students want... and teachers that have higher ideals are swimming up-stream if they want to actually challenge the kids.

Re:You never did math in high school by pseut on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:14AM (#7223024)
Ah, if only...
Re:You never did math in high school by rsofaer on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @10:07PM (#7222277)
From teaching a little CS and numerical computing in college and now teaching programming, I agree with you. Too many students come out of high school without the ability to manipulate mysterious symbols without any real understanding of what they mean. Some students only know how to follow scripts to solve a problem from a template. Others need a concrete understanding before engaging with the abstraction, so they can't explore the math in order to gain an understanding. Maybe that's what he was trying to get at with "following obscure steps".

High school teachers, please make your students manipulate mysterious symbols more.

Re:You never did math in high school by ctide on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @10:50PM (#7222392)
This is what my exact thoughts were. That's why I struggled with Calculus, while I blew through Physics and high school 'math' with no real problems. I didn't need to care about the pedantry because it all just made sense to me. Once it stopped making sense, and it veered off into the abstract, I had to actually study to do well.

It's funny because when that article started I was totally on board with him, then we got there and I just laughed.

Re:You never did math in high school by wfunction on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:09PM (#7222055)
Shouldn't you understand what you're doing?
Re:You never did math in high school by pseut on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:25PM (#7222116)
Yes, but you have to be able to do it first.
Re:You never did math in high school by shiven on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:31PM (#7222154)
This whole sub-conversation felt eerily like the quote from Richard Bach's Jonathan Livingston Seagull:

"The trick to flying is to be able to throw yourself at the ground, and miss."

Re:You never did math in high school by charlieflowers on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @10:48PM (#7222388)
I always thought that quote was from Douglas Adams in the Hitchhiker's Guide trilogy. Did Adams get it from Bach?
Re:You never did math in high school by e12e on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @12:50AM (#7222753)
As far as I can figure out (from the electronic copy I got my hands on) that quote isn't in Bach's book, but from some glances it would appear some of the concepts might be?

The quote does appear in HHGTG.

[edit: I don't have a copy of the original radio scripts on hand, but from the book:

    "The Guide says there is an art to flying," said Ford,
    "or rather a knack. The knack lies in learning how to
    throw yourself at the ground and miss." He smiled
    weakly. He pointed at the knees of his trousers and
    held his arms up to show the elbows. They were all
    torn and worn through.

    "I haven't done very well so far," he said. He stuck
    out his hand. "I'm very glad to see you again, Arthur," 
    he added.

     -- Life, the Universe and Everything
That doesn't mean the phrase doesn't appear on any of Bach's writing, though -- but I've been unable to find it.]
Re:You never did math in high school by glenra on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @03:27AM (#7223191)
I vaguely recall a very similar sort of sentiment in a different Bach book, Illusions.
Re:You never did math in high school by shiven on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @08:35AM (#7224121)
You may be right and I am mis-remembering the source!!
Re:You never did math in high school by taeric on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:23PM (#7222106)
Maybe? Really depends on what you are doing, and what level of understanding you mean.
Re:You never did math in high school by pjaun on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @03:25PM (#7227024)
Not being being able to do the symbol manipulation is a different problem. That's what you see from the students who have B's and C's in their previous math courses. The problem discussed in the blog post is what you see from the A students. It's probably more obvious in a class like analysis than in calculus.
Re:You never did math in high school by maxerickson on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @10:58AM (#7224991)
I wonder if 'blindly manipulate' just lacks precision.

Isolating a variable is, in some sense, a blind manipulation, but so is, "I see a plus sign, that means I have to subtract". As a first thought about a problem, they represent very different understandings.