News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by bnegreve on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:10AM (#7216806)
> Well, artificial intelligence is a slippery term. It could refer to just getting machines to do things that seem intelligent on the surface.

But is "natural intelligence" any different?

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by simonh on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:20AM (#7216837)
Yes, because it is general purpose intelligence. Google Translate can't even play the simplest of games, let alone Chess or Jeopardy. Watson can't even begin to tackle translation or Chess. Deep Blue has absolutely no capability towards translation or playing Jeopardy. They are fixed-function, single-task algorithms optimized towards a single very tightly defined problem domain. That sort of research isn't going to get us to general purpose AI.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by ivanca on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:30AM (#7216873)
Cats cannot play the simplest of games; does that mean that they do not have general purpose intelligence?

And I do think this research is going to take us there; what is winning a game more than translating your enemy actions into yours? Like translating a face gesture on a poker game (or translating a word) into a action such as doubling inside the game (or a http response).

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Ygg2 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:36AM (#7216883)
Actually cats can play catch. So even by that definition they have some rudimentary intelligence.

Cats aren't as intelligent as dogs, and they aren't social animals but they have some intelligence. They can learn on their own to navigate surroundings, move, catch prey and mate.

I'd love to see Watson do any of these without pre programming.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by kamaal on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:33AM (#7217073)
>>I'd love to see Watson do any of these without pre programming.

I'd love to see a Human do anything without any kind of pre programming(I mean without giving it the knowledge and training it to use that knowledge).

If I take a tribal person from a amazon jungle who hasn't seen the outside world ever and disclose him the rules of playing chess, will he able to play as well as Gary Kasparov in a few minutes? Or if say I disclose the usage of a paint brush and paint, can he paint like Michelangelo or Da Vinci?

Each human is a self learning self programming machine.

Humans, including us can do so many things only because our brains are getting programmed with information every single moment and are being told how to act on that information.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Ygg2 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:43AM (#7217116)
Problem with your description is that given if you take a human from jungle and leave it in New York, if he understands language he'll be able to function on at least some level.

In same manner, if you take Watson and for example change format of questions (they are still asked in plain English, just rephrased) and way Daily bonus prize functions, he won't be able to function without some human coming in and tweaking it.

You generally don't have to open head of a human, rewire their brains and then send them to do another task. They adapt. Autonomously. It's like if software could auto investigate sites for weather API and adapt to it, instead of having a human come and rewire API adapters.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by vidarh on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:15AM (#7217020)
> they aren't social animals

You haven't spent much time around cats (or haven't paid attention) if you think they aren't social animals.

Our various cats when I grew up would bring "friends" around - cats of both genders that they played with, and who would be allowed into our garden. Some of them were "introduced" to us - our cat would walk up to us with his friend in tow and stay until we'd pet his friend.

You'd often find them lying on our patio together during the summer. They'd also occasionally groom each other.

Our current neighbours oldest male cat sometimes "walks" the two young cats she recently got around the neighbourhood.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Ygg2 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:38AM (#7217092)
You misunderstood me, cats aren't social animals as in domesticated cats and their descendents aren't likely to form a and hunt in a group. The main majority of their life is spent in solitude. Cats do need contact, but most contacts in 'wild' (i.e. without human supervision) is spent either fighting or mating, not socializing for some benefits.

Humans kinda forced the whole social aspect of their lives. I read somewhere that cat holding tail upward is a new construct of cats. It's usually used by kittens around their momma.

The behavior you describe is more unique. Here where I am two cats are no way likely to sleep near each other. Basically they might sleep at least two feet distance. Most contacts are violent.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by jjtheblunt on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:59AM (#7216960)
Rudimentary intelligence? How primate a thing to write. Cats and dogs are evolved with different priorities, as are primates, and have ingenuities that surprise one another, except when the others stop watching. I've seen cats learn how doors work by just watching, doorknobs, etc. They are clever, geometrically, but humans seem to resonate with the more vocal/verbal and generally cooperative nature of dogs, as it's a very primate characteristic.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by bad_user on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:42AM (#7217111)
I think this is because dogs are friendlier and more willing to learn from us, whereas cats are very selfish :)

Either way, people claiming that either dogs or cats aren't very inteligent haven't lived with one. It is true that it is not human intelligence, but personally I feel that the only piece missing is natural language, which if you think about it is the only distinctive trait separating us from primates.

And this will be the ultimate test for AI, the ability of a computer to have a meaningful conversation with a human.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Ygg2 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:57AM (#7217153)
I think dogs are more intelligent BECAUSE they are social animals. Social animals need to do everything a solitary animal does + ability to know what his peers are thinking or about to do in order to coordinate.

Dogs can fake emotion (ever been bitten by a dog that waggles his tail?), know what appeals to humans(sending cutest or most wounded pup to beg for food), understand how subway works, etc. Cats have greater independence, but overall aren't as clever.

Crows and killer whales, now those fuckers are intelligent.

The only thing exceptional about human mind is the ability to be EXTREME in every aspects of our mind. Most creatures can do same as we, but we do it to a higher degree.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by bad_user on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @07:52AM (#7217330)
Speaking of social animals, spotted hyenas are very clever and groups of hyenas are not only very big, but have very complex rules for social interaction.

On the human mind, I do have a problem with assertions such as yours - saying that we can be "extreme" doesn't say much about how we are built or why other animals can't do it. We definitely don't have the biggest brains.

Sometime in the evolutionary process, we developed the ability to speak. Chimpanzees have symbolic capacities which are rarely used in the wild. Something happened to us, some social change and we've been practicing this ability since tens or hundreds of thousands of years ago.

And speech is tremendously important because that's how we learn - we pass and receive knowledge to and from others by means of natural language. Society also leaped forward along with agriculture because that's when written language happened, also allowing us to pass knowledge to future generations. We also leaped forward when common people started learning to read. And because of the ease of access to information nowadays, I also believe we're amidst another revolution.

Now if you look at animals, they do have language. Most intelligent animals rely on body language and even sounds to communicate. But one thing that we do effortlessly is to invent new words, new metaphors to describe whatever we want and our language has gotten so big that we can describe anything.

So there's a strong correlation there and the question on my mind is - are we smart because of the ability to communicate, or are we able to communicate because we are smart?

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Ygg2 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @08:21AM (#7217444)
Well I haven't say or hypothesized why is that so.

Chimpanzees and crows can make tools, we make tools that make tools that make tools.

Animals have language(s), we have several highly symbolic languages. Ours is just more sophisticated.

I'm pretty sure there are examples of animals empathizing, humans can empathize with a large part of biosphere.

There is nothing that fundamentally divides us. Or you can say that humans are nothing special. It's just we have more most mental tasks at greater lengths and do it more consistently. That's all.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Ygg2 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:40AM (#7217101)
Rudimentary intelligence, based on what my parent's written. I'm sure nearly all creatures have some rudimentary intelligence. I'm defininitely not classifying them on same level as worms or insects.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by bnegreve on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:51AM (#7216928)
I've seen some people talking about how they taught their robot to play ping ping, it's pretty amazing

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SH3bADiB7uQ

Edit: The speaker was Jan Peters at ECML/PKDD13

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by catshirt on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:53AM (#7216936)
define "pre programming"? is a cat not pre-programmed to prey, mate, etc?

also, by some of these definitions, sounds like my roomba approaches natural intelligence.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Ygg2 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:48AM (#7217123)
I doubt it is encoded much other than a set of few needs you need to fulfill. Keep in mind kittens pretty much suck at walking, balancing, but learn it eventually.

They are not pre-programmed to fight no more they are pre-programmed to open doors.

As for roomba, depends if you caught it fighting or mating with other roomba's ;)

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by arethuza on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:40AM (#7216894)
Well, our cats can play fetch - does that count?

On the subject of the "game" of fetch - it turns out that dogs can actually show some fairly sophisticated behavior when playing fetch:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fetch_%28game%29

[NB They are Burmese - quite dog like cats and still behaving like overgrown kittens even though they are 8 years old.]

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by jjtheblunt on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:55AM (#7216944)
that's quite normal among hundreds or thousands of cats i've been around, as I used to volunteer with rescued animals. breed didn't seem correlated.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by xerophtye on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:10AM (#7217002)
Any cat owner would know that cats are actually smart enough to train YOU rather than the other way around. So i personally feel that you might be underestimating cat intelligence. The fundamental difference i feel they have with our AI programs is their general purpose ability to learn whatever concerns them. Like cats observing human behaviour patterns and learning a ton of things from them, even how to open doors etc.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by x3c on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:35AM (#7216881)
Cats have limited intelligence but general purpose intelligence. Compare a kitten to a computer with computing power but without intelligence. Now kitten to cat maturity gives the animal a wisdom and intelligence. That maturity is in nowhere similar to Watson as a pure hardware (kitten) to Watson with software of AI (cat).
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by ximeng on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:44AM (#7217117)
A computer recently designed a published board game called Yavalath, by deciding whether randomly generated games are interesting or not. That algorithm wouldn't be difficult to integrate into Google if they decided to do it. As you add more and more capabilities to Google at a more abstract level (design something "fun" like here), it's closer and closer to general purpose AI. It's not just that, see also http://www.gamesbyangelina.org/ .
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by simonh on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:57AM (#7217151)
Did the algorithm decide what the characteristics of an interesting game are, or were they hard-coded? Could is analyze the interestingness of games generally? Could it analyze why some people like some games and other people don't?

If it couldn't do these things, then it was in no way intelligent, because it was not analyzing at a conceptual level. Programs that simply optimize data towards a set of target characteristics are clever, but not intelligent. Hofstadter goes into this in the article.

You're making exactly the same mistake those over-optimistic AI researchers made back in the 60s. They created some whiz-bang optimisation algorithms and thought general purpose AI must be just around the corner, but it turns out that actual conceptual analysis and reasoning is a completely different and fundamentally unrelated problem.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by Houshalter on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:01AM (#7217611)
That's an arbitrary distinction. The goal might have been decided by human programmers, that doesn't mean the process isn't itself intelligent. You are right it is using a crude optimization process that is a lot weaker than human intelligence, but it's still "intelligent".
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by jkldotio on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:50AM (#7216923)
It's worth pointing out Google just bought the startup with the guys who wrote the "Playing Atari with Deep Reinforcement Learning" paper which is supposedly just an algorithm working on the raw pixels and then beating all other programs and half of the human experts.[1]

[1] http://arxiv.org/pdf/1312.5602v1.pdf

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by chongli on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:43AM (#7216903)
You could run all of these programs on one computer. Comparing a person to a piece of software is apples to oranges. Build a computer big enough to run all of the software in the world (and all of the data, too) and compare those capabilities to a human.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by bnegreve on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:40AM (#7216896)
> Yes, because it is general purpose intelligence.

Right, but playing jeopardy is far more general than instructing a computer to sort an array, so why do you think that we are on the wrong path?

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by simonh on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:50AM (#7217132)
I am sure basic algorithmic techniques like knowing how to sort an array are likely to be very useful when building an AI, or at least some forms of AI, but an array sorting algorithm is not itself a general purpose artificial intelligence and neither are Deep Blue, etc.

As Hofstadter explains in the article, far better than I could, these applications are not contributing to progress in developing software that understands the data it is manipulating. I recommend reading the article, or even better GEB itself, it's very illuminating.

Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by stdbrouw on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:27AM (#7216860)
Isn't the brain itself a good mix of general-purpose and special-purpose intelligence?
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by arethuza on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:46AM (#7216910)
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by icot on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:52AM (#7216932)
This. And also, is it truly a general purpose intelligence, or a special-purpose one which evolved into general by just extending the domain of application? I'd say that most of what is considered intelligence comes from pattern matching plus inference; and there is a number of 'illusions' and cognitive biases that trick the mind because one of these processes fails. This may for example by finding patterns where there is none, which is quite normal.
Re:Why Watson and Siri Are Not Real AI by ibelong2u on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:51AM (#7217137)
In my opinion, it's not. Natural intelligence is another way of saying that dynamics and interactions of millions of neurons in our brain is too complicated for us to understand. Our brain is just a complex machine, and the complexity at the level of its individual components is based on very fundamental laws of physics and chemistry.

In that sense, you bring up an excellent question. I don't think there exists any unique "natural intelligence" which Hofstadter in the linked article is referring to. Watson is only different from "natural intelligence" in terms of complexity.

Conway's Game of Life can perhaps be used as an analogy here. The uninitiated is likely to assume a very complex source code upon observing setups like 'spaceships' and 'glider guns'. However, it all is based on some very simple rules which can be easily implemented by a high school computer science student.

I'd to extrapolate this logic towards the concept of 'life' itself. I feel that what we call life is just collective of natural processes too complicated for us to comprehend completely. Scientific research has allowed us to understand biological processes to some extend, but not enough to us to deduce the state of a living entity at t+1 by observing the state at t=0. The common assumption is that there is some independent/supernatural force (consciousness) which allows the living entity to 'chose' the new state at t+1 (free will).

Watson appears to be "intelligently" making a chess move, but as Hofstadter points out, Watson is simply following a set of rules. We can independently calculate Watson's move since we know it's source code.

My conjecture is that if we are theoretically able to capture the complete state of your brain cells at t=0, and understand how they work, I can theoretically calculate your chess play before you make it.

For example, check out this White Blood Cell chasing and killing bacteria: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JnlULOjUhSQ

WBC appears to be a living entity, acting out of free will. But the reality is that, molecular composition of WBC is merely attracted to the chemical trail left behind the bacteria, which in turn is repelled by WBC.

We do not consider a piece of rock rolling down the hill to be a living entity, because our understanding of physics allows us to calculate the state of a rock at t+1, given it's position a t=0.