The "unfairness" here is limited to other traders who'd be trying to profit by selling the same liquidity, and now can't compete. But your occasional market order benefits.
http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2009/07/24/business/0724-w...
Most high-frequency trading provides liquidity to a market, not takes it, especially in US stocks. That way, you not only possibly get some edge from the bid/ask spread, you also may collect "liquidity rebates" (see http://www.batstrading.com/FeeSchedule for one fee schedule for an exchange that's actually founded by some high-frequency traders). There's tons of high-frequency trading that's actually gross negative (they sell for less on average than they buy), but net positive (on average, they get paid more fees than they lose gross).
To be clear, this has nothing to do with algorithmic trading. Using computers to detect trends or to plan strategic trades is natural and healthy for the market. I am also not suggesting that computerized trading and reduced fees are bad - they have made the market far more efficient.
> One could easily say the Broadcom buyers described were upset they couldn't screw the sellers as badly anymore.
But in this case, the Broadcom sellers AND buyers were both screwed by a third party, who bought at a price that hurt sellers and sold at a price that hurt buyers, on the order of milliseconds. This third party runs the same scheme all day, every day, taking money out of everyone's pocket without doing any real work. This is why people would distrust the market.