News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by overgard on Monday February 10, 2014 @08:13PM (#7215010)
I donated $100, and yeah, our healthcare system is a goddamn travesty. I don't get it. If you're fortunate to live long enough, the one thing that's guaranteed to eventually happen is you're going to get sick in a very expensive manner. It's not an "if" question, it's a "when" question. I don't think that should mean financial ruin. People against universal healthcare must think they're just immune to ever getting sick or something.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by ElDiablo666 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:57AM (#7217150)
People against universal healthcare are just good people who are confused and/or deluded. Their arguments will never really add up because it's only about corporations making profits and to that end people will need to be deluded and manipulated into believing that we shouldn't implement a proper system. Just remember this when you say you don't get it: it's just the political power of traitors speaking through humans via propaganda.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by sp332 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @07:46AM (#7217305)
I'm against public healthcare in the USA because there's no way (in the current political climate) it won't be massively corrupt. Did you know the insurance companies were lobbying in favor of our new system? It's still about corporations making profits.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by Kurtz79 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @08:34AM (#7217495)
By living in a few different countries, I found out believing that the current political climate of your own is somewhat worse than other ones where supposedly things work better is a common fallacy.

Universal healthcare exists (and works, with various degrees of success) in most countries that are otherwise very similiar to the US in terms of culture, form of government, and in some cases have worse corruption and bureocracy.

As in many things with democracy and social security, there would be inefficiencies, abuses and problems, the real issue is, in my opinion, if the people would be better off in the end, all things considered.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by lewaldman on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @03:31PM (#7220205)
I'm brazilian...

You can't, and should not, ever; spoke about corruption on a media were a south american/african could read you. US got corruption? We got it worst! Much much much worst. Worst in a level were the King of Soccer (Pelé) can say on national television that the money that would be stealed during the construction of the stadiums for the world cup would came back as tourists money.

And, beside that... we have universal health care. (It's not fancy nor without big lines of people or up to 5 hours waiting to a doctor but it exists, and works. Specially for serious illnes like cancer, HIV or Hepatitis).

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by specialist on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @01:25PM (#7219273)
massively corrupt

The data, comparative experiences, and commons sense, disagrees with you.

Single payer is easier to audit. Because it's more simple.

Healthcare Fraud: Auditing and Detection Guide [2012] http://www.amazon.com/Healthcare-Fraud-Auditing-Detection-Gu...

Healthcare Fraud: Auditing and Detection Guide [2007] http://www.amazon.com/Healthcare-Fraud-Auditing-Detection-Gu...

And before you say "tort reform", single payer and universal coverage largely eliminates need for malpractice insurance. Again, because we have existence proofs (every country that has single payer) that discerning people can use to inform their opinions.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by ElDiablo666 on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:27AM (#7223537)
Tort reform also has no bearing on cost outcomes, according to the data. Texas is one example. It's solely designed to prevent human beings from holding corporations accountable for their actions.

The reason people bring it up is because it's just straight up propaganda preventing them from thinking. Single payer is inarguably more effective, efficient, and cheaper. Also, "I'm against a public system because it's corrupt"? But this private system is a-ok, no corruption at all! FFS.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by cwaniak on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @01:44PM (#7219438)
of course! Centralized economic solutions always work the best. The USSR is the best example of that. You people go back to coding and leave economics to economists.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by huherto on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @03:08PM (#7220042)
That is simply not true.

Centralized economic solutions work better for some things. Free market soluctions work for other types of things.

The USSR was a dictatorship where everything was managed by the State. This is not what it is being proposed.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by specialist on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @03:54PM (#7220363)
Markets are not always the most efficient way to determine price information.

Further, most transactions are private or semi private, meaning not conducted via an open market. The amount one business unit (or agency) charges another for goods and services may be informed by a market price, but not necessarily.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by cwaniak on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:46PM (#7221074)
> Centralized economic solutions work better for some things.

I could also say that 2 and 2 not always is 4. Please give concrete examples.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by arg01 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @11:31PM (#7222500)
Tragedy of the commons type problems. Concrete example: CFC Regulations.

Prisoners Dilema type problems. Concrete example: Cigarette advertising bans. (I'll clarify that this is better for the companies involved on a competition between company basis and "better" for the public in the form of a shrinking tobacco market)

More to the point a real concrete example is healthcare costs. Per person they are cheaper in comparable countries to the US such as UK, Australia, Canada all countries with public healthcare systems (this is including the tax money spent). I would also point out that if you are going to argue that health outcomes are better in the US than those other systems (Maybe that's true, I couldn't say) you are missing the key point of what these non free market systems can be good at (that is capturing externalities, like in this instance bankruptcy or inability to afford service).

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by cwaniak on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:32AM (#7223752)
You claim cigarate bans helped tobacco industry? CFC helped grow corporations? Because if all you are saying is that regulation is destroying industries, well that's actually my point.

And yes the US Government involvement and regulation in the Healthcare industry in the US destroyed it too. Up till 1960s and invention of Government intervention into US healthcare system, the healthcare in the US was cheap, affordable and the US kept #1 spot for longevity in the world. After medicare, medicaid and all the other Government involvement and regulation in healthcare in the US (i.e. 10% of GDP in the US goes to healthcare) we have #50 in longevity and nobody can afford it. Blaming capitalism for that just shows your ignorance.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by specialist on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @07:27AM (#7223899)
Apologies, I don't follow.

Healthcare was cheaper before cigarettes were heavily regulated or after?

Which is it?

Or perhaps you're arguing that corporate profits are more important than people?

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by cwaniak on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @09:30AM (#7224434)
Just read again and if you still don't get it, keep reading.

And no, Government regulation isn't more important than people.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by arg01 on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @08:26PM (#7228744)
Firstly the entire point of my comment was that capitalism is not the best system in all cases and that there are situations especially those involving externalities where an approach involving regulation is the better solution. I repeat it here so you realise what I'm arguing and what statement you made earlier.

Secondly you grossly misrepresent what I say with the first few sentences of your reply which makes me worry about whether you paused to give any thought to what I said or just decided to be argumentative and pick out random words you disliked. Nonetheless I'll go through your points.

>You claim cigarate bans helped tobacco industry?

No I claimed ADVERTISING bans on cigarettes helped the companies by reducing expenses related to competition between cigarette companies. I also claimed that outside of the industry it had other positive effects. However you will have noticed the quotes around "better" in ' "better" for the public' because I felt I should qualify that a non smoker generally costs the health system more by living longer.

> CFC helped grow corporations?

I'm sorry, perhaps I shouldn't have assumed you knew what CFCs are and why they are relevant to the conversation. CFC are a widely useful range of chemical compounds that were used in a great many products, they also deplete the ozone layer. The regulation of CFCs which phased out their use is an example where government intervention was required and the free market solution of localized profits failed. I have no data on whether it helped grow corporations, it is however known that the requlations reduced the amount of CFCs in the atmosphere which led to the shrinking of the hole in the ozone layer.

>Because if all you are saying is that regulation is destroying industries, well that's actually my point.

You're the one that's taken the hardline position of saying that centralized solutions never work better than pure free market and as I reject your reframing of better to be only industry, I am pointing out that centralized/regulated solutions do work better in some cases. Even if I didn't reject your definition of industrial production as the basis for better, wartime america with centralized planing on production was a 'better' idea than the free market system it had before it, being much more productive.

>And yes the...

It may have been cheap and affordable but that doesn't mean everyone was getting it, in fact that's the reason the government stepped in. So sure the system got screwed up by regulation, because it was the wrong regulation, they should have gone whole hog on the nationilization like the other countries and then the US would have a better system. (And by better I mean has a positive effect on the the most peoples lives, not maximises the money spent on basic healthcare, or the total wealth of the "healthcare industry")

I'm sure I've persuaded you that your original statement about the free market system always being the best system is an untenable position. If you still disagree could you explain to me how a system without regulation deals with atomic weapons. (Now a flippant question because I really would believe it to be absurd to hold to the unregulated premise at this point (I hope you realise I'm poking fun at the premise not you)) Do they always go to the highest bidder cash wise or do they only sell them if there's a sales contract not to blow up the seller... and whatever court the breach of contract trial would be held in?

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by specialist on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @12:49AM (#7222750)
I've got a better idea.

You give concrete examples of decentralized (unregulated) markets working better than open (regulated) markets.

I could also say that 2 and 2 not always is 4.

I don't doubt it.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by cwaniak on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:33AM (#7223755)
internet search for one.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by eropple on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @07:06AM (#7223851)
Internet search has led to a market where, if Google doesn't like you, you don't exist. Are you sure this is the example you want to roll with?
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by cwaniak on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @09:33AM (#7224457)
Free markets means that stupid/wrong decisions (i.e. Google hurting people) result in competitive advantage to companies that don't do those stupid things. I'm sure CEO of DuckDuckGo.com just can't wait for Google to start hurting its customers.

And then I take corporations competition every day over Government regulation.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by specialist on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @10:42AM (#7224858)
Please provide one example of a free market.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by cwaniak on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @11:24AM (#7225177)
China.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @09:25AM (#7224407)
I'm continually amazed at the number of ways the current US system is centralized, usually in an arcane manner e.g. prices that hospitals can charge for things being set by a committee.

You've got all the bad parts of centralized bureaucracy without any of the good bits.

(edit: also, it's hard to tell how many layers of sarcasm your post has, but economists generally agree on centralising certain aspects of healthcare. Insurance is a fairly well studied topic in general.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by mikeash on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:25AM (#7223055)
I'll leave economics to economists the moment economists can agree on, well, anything.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by Xdes on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @07:57AM (#7217343)
Public healthcare ought to be implemented at the local level for those that want it (which I don't). I'm quite fine with not seeking treatment when I get a terminal illness. If it ever gets to that point I would prefer euthanasia (illegal in the USA).
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by shawabawa3 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @08:18AM (#7217424)
> I'm quite fine with not seeking treatment when I get a terminal illness. If it ever gets to that point I would prefer euthanasia (illegal in the USA).

You say that now, but I guarantee you the moment you get diagnosed you change your mind. Especially considering so many terminal illnesses can in fact be cured with (very expensive) treatments.

Also, what about all the non-terminal illnessess? What happens if you break your leg? Or get stabbed? Or get in a car accident? Or any of the millions of other things that can happen?

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by blueskin_ on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @08:56AM (#7217594)
>You say that now, but I guarantee you the moment you get diagnosed you change your mind. Especially considering so many terminal illnesses can in fact be cured with (very expensive) treatments.

By definition, they aren't terminal illness then. In any case, in the US (or many other countries), those treatments are unavailable or will literally make someone homeless (and preclude them ever getting insurance again). There's also the question of if it's worth it - will the end result provide proper quality of life or not.

Breaking a leg is a specious analogy as it is neither terminal nor permanent; but if something worse did happen and it would permanently affect my quality of life, yes, I'd still feel the same.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by blueskin_ on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @08:15AM (#7217407)
Best bet is to fly to Switzerland when terminally ill, it's what I plan if it ever happens to me.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by mikeash on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:28AM (#7223062)
What if you get hit by a bus and go into a coma and your treatment costs millions of dollars? If you're not awake, you can't refuse treatment.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by nedwin on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @12:50PM (#7218978)
The lobbyists were lobbying to get the new system setup in a way that was favourable to them.

That doesn't mean the new system is inherently wrong.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by coldpie on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:06AM (#7217636)
As opposed to the current situation?
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by ekianjo on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:22PM (#7215568)
> that's guaranteed to eventually happen is you're going to get sick in a very expensive manner.

Wrong, there's still a large part of the population who will end up dying of what we call "natural causes" such as Heart attacks and stuff like that. These are very inexpensive, because you don't see them coming, usually. So, no, not everyone on Earth dies from Cancer.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by overgard on Monday February 10, 2014 @11:09PM (#7215745)
That's why I qualified it with "if you're lucky to live long enough".

So, yeah, you might be lucky enough to unexpectedly drop dead before some other scourge takes you

However if you don't happen to fortune into a sudden unexpected death, your body will inevitably decay to the point that you will become a large financial and emotional burden on someone. (Or die homeless and friendless). But we can't take care of those people, cuz socialism! They should have had the common courtesy to just hurry up and die.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by hueving on Monday February 10, 2014 @11:30PM (#7215793)
If the probabilities were as bad as you suggest, there would be no such thing as health insurance. They need to bring in more than they spend on health-care costs. Most people can't end in a devastating health-cost manner.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by overgard on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @12:13AM (#7215920)
So.. your argument is that because insurance companies can profit, it's not so bad? "Well, your legacy might be financial ruin for your children, or an early death to avoid that, but since most people die before they realize they're severely ill, ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I'm not arguing probabilities here, I'm arguing deductive reasoning. You are a decaying meatsack. So am I. At some point something very bad will happen to that decaying meatsack. Such an event will be absurdly expensive to treat. Since I think we'd all agree that for pretty much anyone it makes sense to have health insurance, the obvious next step is: just give everyone health insurance and take it out of tax, and simplify these things 1000 fold. (Not to mention that a single payer would have WAY more leverage, and thusly could negotiate way lower prices. And that's not a hypothetical.. that's how it works in pretty much every country that isn't the US).

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by na85 on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @01:54AM (#7216232)
>So.. your argument is that because insurance companies can profit, it's not so bad?

His/her argument is, AFAICT: "Because insurance companies can profit, that shows that less than a majority of people die after a prolonged, expensive illness.

Therefore the earlier statement that "it is 100% certain you will have a long, expensive illness at some point in life" is not true.

Plenty of people die of sudden stroke or heart attack in their 70s after a relatively healthy life up to that point.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by tripzilch on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @05:19AM (#7216833)
But the problem is also that healthcare in the US is just absurdly expensive, insurance or not. Sure, many EU countries have universal health insurance, but if you look behind those, costs (paid by the insurance or not) are quite a bit lower than the US. They're still quite hefty and you do want to be insured for them, but why is healthcare in the US so expensive in the first place?
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by specialist on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @01:20PM (#7219224)
1/3rd of US healthcare costs is administrative. Single payer (Medicare for all) fixes that.

The lowest hanging fruit, biggest bang for the buck, best ROI, the most logical common sense way to control US healthcare costs is to switch to single payer with universal coverage.

Sure, do all the other kabuki, like quality of care, healthcare insurance exchanges, price transparency, generics, whatever. Because better is better. But know that you're weeding the flower beds while the house is burning down.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by eloisant on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @07:57AM (#7217346)
I think the real problem that affects everyone in US is the cost of anything health related before insurance. This may be a consequence of the fact that everything is private, but just look at the numbers.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/post/why-an-mri...

You may be thinking "OK, the system is not great but I'm fine because I've got a good insurance", but that's not true. Even with a good insurance you're getting ripped off before of the cost before insurance of healthcare.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by makomk on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @02:52AM (#7216403)
Not really. Hugely ruinous medical expenses could be something that happened, say, once every hundred or two hundred person-years and still affect a massive proportion of people who lived long enough. Also, even just health insurance for critical illness and emergencies isn't exactly cheap...
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by Fuxy on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @04:39AM (#7216719)
Well it's not like the health insurance companies really want to pay for the bills the contracts are always phrased in such a way that the can just say... well we don't cover that when you get sick but the do expect you to pay every month when you are healthy.

They wouldn't have that ability in a European like country sponsored insurance since everything would be covered.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by xeroxmalf on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:46PM (#7215655)
Though some heart attacks are "natural causes" many could actually be prevented[0] if the patient had access to specialists and testing.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseases_of_poverty#Cardiovasc...

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by d23 on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:43PM (#7215647)
> Wrong, there's still a large part of the population who will end up dying of what we call "natural causes" such as Heart attacks and stuff like that. These are very inexpensive

Oh nice, they should put that on the brochure.

Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by rch on Monday February 10, 2014 @09:51PM (#7215442)
I think a key feature of health insurance is that not everyone gets hit with 6 or 7 figure healthcare bills. It's because of that fact that we can and should do better as a society.
Re:Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former co... by prophet_ on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @10:56AM (#7218170)
Why people mention how much they donated? Am I missing on something?