I'm not sure what I'd recommend as a replacement. However, what I actually did when I last suffered Slashcode was replace it with WordPress and a suitable set of extensions (e.g. a submission extension). Which, for all its problems, didn't make me actually want to stab myself in the face repeatedly whenever I went to touch it in any manner whatsoever, including to post anything.
The LessWrong codebase, which is a derivative of Redditcode, does pretty well for that site. https://github.com/tricycle/lesswrong Might suit a Slashdot replacement. Not many maintainers, could do with more.
The quality of Scoop's code and the vibrancy of its development community can both be inferred from the fact that, in 2014, its FAQ warns you that it doesn't run well under Apache 2.
Mediawiki site is just a temporary thing.