Aso by any reasonable measure Apple's market cap should be well over a trillion. Take away their $165 billion cash pile from their $465 billion market cap, give them 0% growth and you're left with the idea that Wall St's expects Apple to be turning out the lights in 4 or 5 years depending on how you value their IP, tangible assets and other investments. That's why Apple is buying Apple stock like whoa.
Would people prefer that they be like Google, with piles and piles of R&D projects that go public, get users, and are shorty abandoned? Ask me how long Google has been working on MMS support in Google Voice for. I honestly wish they'd never bought Grand Central, at least it would have improved in the last several years.
I honestly wish they'd never bought Grand Central,
at least it would have improved in the last several years.
Or more likely Grand Central would have been acquired by someone else or shut down.I was a Grand Central user and while Google Voice hasn't lived up to all my hopes and dreams it's a pretty kick-ass service.
My personal favorite: Text conversations get new messages from the bottom. But when you open the app, it doesn't automatically load new messages. How do you get them? Pull to refresh. At the top of the conversation.
Yup, scroll up past several pages of messages to get to the start, pull to refresh, then go back down to read the new texts. Brilliant.
So I think you're wrong about your conclusion but I also think you're wrong about your premise. Product development cycles take several years. It took 3 years to follow the iPhone with the iPad -- essentially just a big iPhone and a product that they started working on before the phone. There were 6 years between iPod and iPhone. It's not like cash is the only constraint here.
I of course do believe in Apple, and I use their products, and yes I'm definitely long on their stock. And I see so many people today frustrated by their low P/E. It delights me. Every month I dollar cost average into it and the longer it stays in this "cheap" P/E range the better.
Google is literally unproven.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BlackBerry_Ltd#Financials
BB was growing like crazy for the whole decade till 2011, consistently ~40% year over year both in revenue/profit AND users. Just a dink in 2012, and kaboom, you know the rest of the story. And note that enterprise email was supposed to be the unbreachable moat for a business.
At least Saudi Aramco, if not some of the other state-owned oil companies, are already over $1 trillion.
Despite a million products, they're still a one-hit-wonder in terms of revenue.
As for their non-advert products: how big a market is the thermostat market, and what are the chances that Google will somehow screw up Nest? Google isn't exactly very good at customer service, and you need that for hardware.
As for these amazing robots, we've been hearing for 50 years about how robots are going to be making our lives easier at home, but it hasn't happened yet.
As has been expressed at various places on the web, the Nest acquisition was most likely about more than just thermostats and smoke detectors. It was probably about good consumer product design in general.
Seriously, are you really arguing that Google's revenues are not primarily from ad revenue? With the sale of Motorola, it'll be back above 90%—just like it was before Motorola.
You could generalize any company that way. Apple would be a one-hit-wonder who's revenue comes from one source - selling consumer electronics.
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aA1jw...
Google has never successfully reinvented themselves. They were founded as a search engine, and that's still what most people associate them with.
I would give the crown to Apple. Since Google was founded, Apple has been best known for the Mac, iPod, and iPhone at varying points, each product eclipsing the prior one in popularity, mindshare, and profit.
I think they understand the process of re-inventing themselves better than any other tech company. They acquire a lot of companies, some of which continue to grow and change the very nature of Google itself (example Android). They also understand Black Swan Farming and practice it at a level (billions of dollars at a time) that almost no one else does.
Andy Rubin's robotics undertaking is a good example. Page wrote him a billion+ dollar blank cheque and should it succeed, it'll make Google the leading robotics company - likely alone worth as much as Google today. Should it fail, well, it's only 2% of their cash pile. They've made similar bets on almost all promising future tech - AI, clean energy, the internet of things etc.