News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is NASA for? by zwieback on Thursday February 06, 2014 @10:21AM (#7190771)
I don't get the fascination with manned space flight. To me it's such an obvious waste of money. I find the robots we send to space a million times more fascinating.
Re:What Is NASA for? by maaku on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:12AM (#7191043)
Permanently expanding the human race into space is "an obvious waste of money"? I think you need to justify that.
Re:What Is NASA for? by TallGuyShort on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:30AM (#7191167)
I think his point is that the burden of proof is more on the people wanting send humans into space. I agree with him, actually. I'm one of those people who still retains their child-like wonder at the thought of space exploration, but I can't stand it when manned spaceflight has been justified primarily by political purposes. I think manned spaceflight has a place, but I think in many instances the robots are just as interesting and useful - and we should be careful to not spend tons of money in the wrong way.
Re:What Is NASA for? by maaku on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:27PM (#7194257)
Permanently sending humans into space is about making life itself a cosmic phenomenon - transforming the dead matter of the universe into self-aware consciousness, instead of merely passing from one oblivion to the next.

It is about making a future for uncountable trillions of (post-)human beings, instead of the few measly billion our single planet can support.

It is about blossoming new cultures in far off places, instead of stagnation and unity.

It is about expanding the human economy to include effectively limitless new land and resources instead of fighting the same zero sum game.

It is about providing a cosmic lifeboat such that one single catastrophe doesn't wipe out the human race or all life on Earth.

Sorry, I think the burden of proof is on those who say the above is meaningless.

Re:What Is NASA for? by TallGuyShort on Friday February 07, 2014 @10:37AM (#7196680)
Well being that you're the only one in this thread that seems to be referring to permanent colonization, no. Manned spaceflight to date has been more about displaying national superiority. How noble.
Re:What Is NASA for? by maaku on Friday February 07, 2014 @04:38PM (#7198911)
That was manned spaceflight 23+ years ago. It's debatable how much that was true after Apollo, and it certainly not was the case from 1991 onwards. NASA's manned space flight purpose today is to learn how to live and work in space, aka develop the skills and experience required for permanent settlement.

For confirmation just look to NASA's vision, mission, and strategic goal statements, and the report of every blue ribbon commission to have looked at NASA over the past three decades.

Re:What Is NASA for? by craigching on Thursday February 06, 2014 @01:34PM (#7192051)
At some point, humans will need to get off earth. So when should we start working on that? Of course, there's an implied premise to my point, that humans should work towards preservation of the species or some derivative.
Re:What Is NASA for? by epsylon on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:18AM (#7191086)
There's a documentary[1] that aired on French television that basically said the same thing. Manned space flight is good for public approbation, but it's an extremely inefficient way to spend money on space research.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WGgtsn9SCkg (in French)

Re:What Is NASA for? by pekk on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:05AM (#7191007)
Let me get this straight: sending a man to the moon was an obvious waste of money?
Re:What Is NASA for? by leoedin on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:37AM (#7191212)
Without the context of cold war one-upmanship, almost certainly. What did landing on the moon actually give us? A slightly better understanding of early earth geology perhaps? It was mostly an excercise in building national pride and sticking it to the Soviets. In that role, it was effective.

Spaceflight has contributed very, very little technology to earth. The reality is that anything we fly into space is already generations behind the equivalent earth technology.

Put it another way: What were the obvious benefits of the Apollo program?

Re:What Is NASA for? by mcguire on Thursday February 06, 2014 @01:13PM (#7191897)
"The reality is that anything we fly into space is already generations behind the equivalent earth technology."

There are many reasons for that. For one thing, the environment that it has to operate in is...poor. The "best of breed", most modern technology typically doesn't like that sort of thing. The technology in your automobile's engine compartment is also typically generations behind, as is the stuff in your toaster (for slightly different reasons).

Second, the technology of the manned program (and the same argument applies to a lesser extent to the unmanned program) is "man-rated"---it's specifically tested to ensure that it won't fail in some spectacular fashion and kill everyone. That is expensive, and takes a lot of time. One way to make that cheaper is to maintain a pedigree; what you fly today flew yesterday, or is based on something that you flew yesterday.

And then, of course, at current effort levels, building a new launch platform is mostly a non-starter. So, you might as well go with what's already working.

"Spaceflight has contributed very, very little technology to earth."

You need to keep a distinction in mind: manned vs unmanned. Unmanned flights are plenty competitive in terms of basic research.

Further, many people, before the Internet Boom, got into science and technology because of the manned spaceflight program. To an extent, some of those that went into spaceflight-specific programs were lied to. But still, they have made some contributions, somewhere.

Re:What Is NASA for? by MrMeker on Thursday February 06, 2014 @12:00PM (#7191365)
Freeze drying is one of many it seems.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spin-off_technologies

What were the direct benefits of Amundsen's expedition to the south pole? Is exploration a waist even if its results are less than stellar? I would say that by its nature, exploration is a hard thing to waste money on. Necessity is the mother of invention and nothing provides necessity like pushing the envelope. For example, look at the picture that accompanies this article. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_algorithm

Re:What Is NASA for? by leoedin on Thursday February 06, 2014 @12:51PM (#7191725)
Optimisation algorithms are used widely in all sorts of industries. That antenna was used in 2006. If you read the "History" section of the GA article you linked it talks about developments made since the fifties. Certainly it has space applications, but the technology wasn't developed for space uses. The photo was probably used because space is interesting to people and because NASA photos are in the public domain.

You can't simply say that all exploration gives value for money. With finite resources, we have to direct spending to where it will result in the most benefit. Funding of human spaceflight means that there's less funding available elsewhere. I'm not familiar with who funded Amundsen's expedition, but I'd imagine that it cost a lot less than the trip to the moon did.

There has been innovative developments in the space industry. Some of those spin-off technologies are definitely valid (although the question of whether the return they provide given the absolutely huge R&D budget is worth it) but others are less so. Freeze drying was apparently initially developed in 1938, long before the space program. I find it hard to believe that, in the absence of a space program, nobody would have invented the portable vacuum cleaner.

There are benefits from a space program. Government R&D, when spent well, has a huge impact on technological progress (just look at the absolutely incredible technological step change that wars bring). What I think needs to end is the absolute idolisation of the space program. It's an investment, and one which has often shown a poor return.

Re:What Is NASA for? by dkuntz2 on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:44AM (#7191246)
Well, at this point, yes. We haven't used that to go farther.

While the knowledge will hopefully be useful in the future, and we can spread humanity to more than one relatively small, condensed point, at present it's not really helping us, and was pretty much a waste of money. At present.