News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by JazCE on Thursday February 06, 2014 @07:27AM (#7189979)
This is essentialy the same as: Minister of health is not a surgeon.

I do think there is actually a need for a political party whose MP's are actually made up on members of the professions they'll eventually represent (By which I mean they won't represent the actual industry, but the people, but you would have a minister of education who has actual practice of being a teacher or something).

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by WilliamMayor on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:07AM (#7190136)
I've had this conversation with a friend of mine the other day and he raised an interesting point.

When the NHS was first being proposed the doctors at the time were strongly against it. The Health Secretary (Bevan I think) just flat refused to listen to what the doctors were telling him. He told them that it didn't matter what their complaints were, he was going to start a national health service.

If we had a system where you had to be an expert in a field before you could be in government then we would lose things like this. We would also lose problems with idiots running things (cough Gove cough). Overall though, we would never have change, our elected officials would only ever vote to maintain the status quo.

Additionally, we vote for people to represent us in government, I don't know that doctors could ever truly represent my views on health care.

I would just like to add a note that none of the things that I've represented as facts above have been checked. I learnt them in the pub, they might be wrong. Let me know (nicely).

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by czr80 on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:26AM (#7190206)
Wikipedia agrees with you:

On the "appointed day", 5 July 1948, having overcome political opposition from both the Conservative Party and from within his own party, and after a dramatic showdown with the British Medical Association, which had threatened to derail the National Health Service scheme before it had even begun, as medical practitioners continued to withhold their support just months before the launch of the service, Bevan's National Health Service Act of 1946 came into force. After 18 months of ongoing dispute between the Ministry of Health and the BMA, Bevan finally managed to win over the support of the vast majority of the medical profession by offering a couple of minor concessions, but without compromising on the fundamental principles of his NHS proposals. Bevan later gave the famous quote that, in order to broker the deal, he had "stuffed their mouths with gold".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneurin_Bevan

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by choult on Thursday February 06, 2014 @07:29AM (#7189994)
The Minister of Health doesn't go around stating that every schoolchild should learn how to operate on people...
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by w0utert on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:38AM (#7190258)
>> The Minister of Health doesn't go around stating that every schoolchild should learn how to operate on people...

Or how it would 'only take a day' to learn how to operate on people, for that matter.

I'm not so much surprised that someone in her position doesn't know how to code (she doesnt't have to, really), but at the very least I expect you to have a basic understanding of the depth and breadth of the topic, and not make sweeping, distracting and confusing statements like this.

A little preparation, just a few hours of talking to people who are knowledgeable on the topic, would go a long way not making a fool out of yourself.

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by tragic on Thursday February 06, 2014 @09:32AM (#7190532)
>> The Minister of Health doesn't go around stating that every schoolchild should learn how to operate on people... > Or how it would 'only take a day' to learn how to operate on people, for that matter.

...Nor does he lack even a layperson's grasp of what surgery is.

I feel rather sorry for her, though - aren't politicians supposed to be briefed for public appearances nowadays so things like this Just Don't Happen?

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by arethuza on Thursday February 06, 2014 @07:40AM (#7190040)
Don't give them any ideas on how to "improve" the NHS!
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by mattmanser on Thursday February 06, 2014 @07:34AM (#7190020)
In a day.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by moron4hire on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:36AM (#7191207)
Probably does think that every school child should learn biology, though, with a few labs involving animal specimen dissections. We aren't talking about "teaching kids to develop software". This is "teaching kids to put code in a text editor and run a compiler on it."
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by desas on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:00AM (#7190110)
Lottie Dexter is not a politician, she's a civil servant. She should have been appointed based on her professional neutrality and ability to do the job, a substantial part of which appears to be to lead a team promoting how to learn programming.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by arethuza on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:21AM (#7190185)
I don't think she is a civil servant - she is described as "Director" of the Million Jobs Campaign - no idea what the legal status of that is (couldn't find it as a charity or a limited company).

Also, the idea that civil servants are appointed based on "ability to do the job" is, for lack of a better term, amusing.

NB The UK Civil Service is precisely the kind of organization that I suspect Michael Young had in mind when he coined the much-abused term "meritocracy":

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by true_religion on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:40AM (#7190268)
Desas is talking about the way the world should be, not the way the world is.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by arethuza on Thursday February 06, 2014 @09:02AM (#7190382)
Ahhh - I have failed to detect sarcasm, I will surrender my nationality.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by yen223 on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:17AM (#7190172)
That's a fundamental problem with modern democracy - it doesn't optimize for talent, it optimizes for charisma.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by arethuza on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:28AM (#7190211)
Consider Clement Attlee, possibly the most influential PM of the 20th century (yes, even more so than Churchill or Thatcher) was fabulously uncharismatic being described by Thatcher as "all substance and no show":

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1194059/A-giant-ma...

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by yen223 on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:32AM (#7190224)
"...when an interviewer asked if he had any thoughts about the coming general election, replied simply: 'No.'"

I need to have a beer with this guy.

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by arethuza on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:37AM (#7190255)
I can recommend "Live from Downing Street" by Nick Robinson - it contrasts the media styles of all of the PMs (at least since there has been a "media" reporting on Parliament):

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Live-Downing-Street-Nick-Robinson/dp...

Personally, I think this country is long overdue a Attlee, Bevan or even a Thatcher - leaders who actually believed in something.

Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by zbyszek on Thursday February 06, 2014 @10:59AM (#7190971)
The famous jibe is along the lines of "An empty taxi drew up outside 10 Downing Street and Clement Attlee got out", attributed to Winston Churchill, but I think he denied it.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by gaius on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:44AM (#7191243)
Churchill described Atlee as a modest man with much to be modest about.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday February 06, 2014 @09:35AM (#7190548)
I wouldn't expect the minister of health to have a level of knowledge of medicine comparable to that of a practicing medical professional. However, I would expect them to have a level of knowledge that goes significantly beyond what is taught to school-children.
Re:Tory Boss of Government Coding Education Initiative Can't... by colin_jack on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:34AM (#7190238)
> This is essentialy the same as: Minister of health is not a surgeon.

Its more that she doesn't even know what a surgeon does but thinks you can train a surgeon up in a day.