Can they scale what they have to serve the number of SERPs that Google serves? Can they do that cost effectively? Can their algorithms produce as useful results in the face of "optimisations" by 10's of thousands of SEO/SEMs across the globe?
I'm guessing no.
My wife makes the most awesome gingerbread men (and brownies) but that doesn't mean she can put Greggs out of business.
Still props too them, they're doing something awesome.
He certainly raises some questions about blind tests compared to expert opinion, but as far as repeatable, replicable, methodology goes, my trust is in the blind test.
Please explain.
http://www.ted.com/talks/malcolm_gladwell_on_spaghetti_sauce...
Gladwell means that people don't always know what they want (or wont be able to tell you).
That said, after having read some of the comments on the page I think we should cut the guy (or guys) some slack. As jacquesm's link points out 55% of users in a double blind study found gigablast better than Google. We're talking about a couple of guys matching, and maybe beating, one of the worlds biggest software companies at their own game. A couple of guys matching Google's thousands of employees and thousands of servers.
In a word I think they're absolutely fucking awesome and deserve total and absolute respect.