But if you took the same land and used the same money to build a big shopping mall your X and Y would both be much bigger. Every time local governments did a study that compared a new stadium to just about any other use of the land the alternative was better.
I'm not opposed to stadiums, per se, but professional sports teams are businesses and as such need to pay their own expenses.
I would much prefer it if the politicians just came out and said 'we're going to spend your taxes on a great big stadium, because we will get to open it and name it, and you, the voters, like bread and circuses'.
Wrapping tax-spends up as some sort of business case just muddies the waters for people when a real business case needs to be analysed.
Perhaps the answer is that, for a jurisdiction, each time there is an election, a multiple choice question could be at the bottom. We wish to take one of the below actions, please indicate your preference:
1) increase tax by x and build stadium 2) increase tax by y and build hospital 3) increase tax by z and build new water reservoir 4) decrease tax by x and you decide what you want to do with it
My remark is flippant but we seem to be entering a strange world where people believe jobs and taxes can only be created through the application of tax monies to politicians ideas.
If Running a Stadium was profitable, the NFL or the Teams would do it, Since they do not want to touch the stadium with a 10 foot pole, then you know it will not be profitable
Public financing of something like a stadium or arena does three things: eliminates a tax liability for the teams/other users, eliminates risk, as the local taxing authority ultimately owns the debt, and keeps the labor and trade unions happy, and stadium projects keep the guys on the payroll.
Ultimately, all of people in a taxing district bear the burden of these giveaways. If I could apply for a full property tax exemption in NY, the $6,000/year I pay for my modest home would be used for capital improvements like a kitchen, solar panels and siding. That would give some construction dudes jobs, and generate more value. The government easily spent $100m on Super Bowl security. That's a lot of money spent better elsewhere or not at all.
I figure if the team doesn't want to pay for it then get a "buy a brick" drive going and see if it funds the stadium.
You could tweak the idea however you like. Whatever portion of the stadium is publicly funded could entitle the community to a matching portion of revenue generated from stadium events, for example.
At any rate, the idea (from both Easterbrook and myself) is more philosophical and humorous commentary.
Between people and companies fleeing the high costs of New York, enough money flowed in to build stadiums, elevated highways and buildings in the swamp. It's a regional thing, nobody even knows who the mayor of east Rutherford is.
But I noticed something later. When it was done it gave people a sense of community that they might otherwise not have. The players, owners, and financiers were all out-of-towners, but they still daily talked of how "their" team was doing. Even if they didn't make many games, it functioned as a kind of virtual center.
This was familiar. The stadium is a modern medieval cathedral. Its a church.
As a meta issue its a "belief system" so there's no point dragging math and logic into it. Exactly like debating evolution or other topics.
Comically, we got stuck with a new stadium because it was claimed if the local ball team pouted and left, all of us mere consumers would react by making huge piles of paper cash money in our backyards, and then light the piles of cash on fire. A complete lack of reasoning is BAU WRT sports economics.
As a startup issue you see pretty much the same style and type of arguments about the contribution of startups to the local economy.