News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by mtrimpe on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:08AM (#7150414)
> If you feel like the event is too immature, don't show up or organize your own events.

I don't know how you meant that, but it reads very much like STFU or GTFO to me.

> The reason there's so much alcohol is because it acts as a social lubricant.

Except that alcohol is more than just a social lubricant; it's a disinhibitor.

That in and of itself creates an exclusionary environment for many women, because they can't rely on physical dominance to counteract the dangers that come with a large group of uninhibited men.

Apart from that; the simple fact that it might not be appealing to a large group of people you wish to involve in your community should be reason enough in- and of itself, much like how insisting on things like dirt-bike racing for team activities might be considered exclusionary for certain groups whom this would appeal less to.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by runj__ on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:28AM (#7150528)
This is a fair argument.

I have not seen the binge drinking the author brings up other than once at a hackathon but I can see how people could feel discomfort with really really drunk people.

People drink at conferences and meetups but I feel that you could listen to all of the talks without being made fun of for not drinking (to be fair: in in my experience).

Not hanging around after the talks or whatever is over isn't that weird, even finding the people who do not "binge drink" and staying and talking to them wouldn't be impossible.

That said, I feel that it's a different story when it comes to drinking at your workplace.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:01AM (#7150676)
There is more to it. Drinking establishments are great places for unstructured social engagements. There are not a lot of other venues that are similar.

When I was in Pune, I was speaking with people (hi Mayank!) who were trying to set up regular hacker meetups. Scheduling formal lectures was easy. But unstructured social engagements was much harder to set up. I suggested that we did it in bars in NY/London, but due to the cultural issues surrounding drinking in Maharashtra bars were out. This made organizing unstructured meetup time really difficult.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by mtrimpe on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:13AM (#7150718)
Of course; drinking establishments make good money on these events so they have a lot of incentive to make this as easy as possible.

Come to think of it, that's actually a really good example of an area where we can put in a bit more effort to create more inclusive events.

In general it's about finding a format which lets attendees personally contribute to the venue's revenue, which sounds like a problem we should collectively be able to tackle.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:37AM (#7150825)
Personally I'm happy with bars and it seems like most people in the west are, so I'm not going to expend a lot of efforts fixing a non-problem. We don't need the alternative to have a tech community, and the fact of the matter is that any cultural choices we make will "exclude" some people.

(I put "exclude" in scare quotes because it's self-imposed exclusion.)

But if you find a good solution that might be deployable in India, let me know. Pune has a good tech scene but regular unstructured social events would definitely improve it.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by mtrimpe on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:35AM (#7151541)
I find the degree to which you're comfortable using generic statements to define the issue a non-problem for the entire industry quite disheartening.

That you personally don't feel the need to spend energy on these issues I perfectly understand however since it would do little to advance your personal goals. When it comes to those my comments to jiggy2011 might help get you started.

Just like what it would take to make tech events more inclusive; in your case it's also just about finding an existing pattern of behaviour your target demographic already displays which you can most easily latch on to and co-opt to help advance your personal goals: tighter interpersonal integration within the Pune tech scene.

It's late here so I can't ask my Indian co-workers, but I'm fairly confident that their culture also already has patterns to enable spontaneous social interaction. My guess is that it involves food somehow ;)

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:40PM (#7151975)
The goal is to find something good enough for 80% of people - in the US bars are it and they are easy to organize. So for the US, it's a non-problem. In Pune, it's actually a bit more difficult to organize things.

Whatever group activity you pick somebody won't like it. Last year my company had a relaxation day and went to a baseball game. I hate baseball. Rather than whining like a spoiled child about how it's unfair that they excluded me, I just hung out with a pretty girl, watched Dark Knight Rises and ate some Indian food.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by jiggy2011 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:32AM (#7150799)
What would a more inclusive event look like? Going to a bar and having people socialize with a no-alcohol policy? That gives off a weird puritan vibe.

More formal/structured activities are likely to be more exclusionary since people have different ideas about what is fun. Or may not feel comfortable participating in things because of disabilities etc. In a bar at least people are free to make their own fun and come and go as they please.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by mtrimpe on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:16AM (#7151426)
Something that would quickly come to mind is something like dim-sum or high-tea adapted to evenings and crowds of varying size.

Probably just changing the focal point from the bar to the buffet and encouraging seating instead of standing would create a completely different atmosphere.

Another variable you could consider playing with is moving from self-service to being served; where the waiters are instructed to dial down the frequency when guests get too far along.

Ironically enough unlimited drinks is something that could work fairly well in this context, as long as the implication that excessive boozing is discouraged and will not be enabled by the waiting staff.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by nahname on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:45AM (#7150595)
>they can't rely on physical dominance to counteract the dangers that come with a large group of uninhibited men.

I cannot think of a single occurrence of physical violence or rape that occurred at a technical conference. Your projections over all women here are unwarranted.

Maybe you feel this way because men are much more aggressive with other men? That would be a fair statement here.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by InclinedPlane on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:51AM (#7150632)
You aren't paying attention then. There was a very high profile case of sexual assault within the tech industry, and at one of these booze filled conference parties as well, only a few months ago.
Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by onetwofiveten on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:34AM (#7150810)
While the danger of physical violence might not be significant, I can imagine that a big group of drunk men might be very intimidating for some women. We've all read complaints about unwelcome advances, harassment, inappropriate comments and sexist jokes at tech conferences. How much worse would it be with drunk men? How safe from harassment would you feel if you were woman? Imagine if you're in a group conversation and one guy keeps making dirty jokes and staring at your breasts when he says the punchline. Or if a guy is really overly friendly and keeps getting really close and bumping into you "by accident". Or if a guy keeps giving you overly personal compliments that are creeping you out, no matter how much you try to brush him off. In a room full of drunk strangers, you'd probably feel quite isolated, since you wouldn't have anyone you could reliably turn to for help. I can imagine all that being a bit intimidating, especially if you've experienced unpleasant behaviour from men at tech conferences in the past.
Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by mtrimpe on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:56AM (#7150656)
There's plenty of actual harrasment to be found in this list of incidents: http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/index.php?title=Timeline_of_in...

Keep in mind that this is just the subset of women who were strong and determined enough to come out and risk retribution and damaging their career prospects.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:14AM (#7150723)
It's hard to take seriously a list of incidents that starts with "a model was photographed, and the photo was later cropped and used as a test image in image processing." Jumping to the very bottom, I see the Paul Graham non-incident and gendered pronouns.

(Admittedly, I didn't read too carefully after seeing obvious nonsense everywhere I looked. Perhaps a list which is curated and has silliness removed would be a more useful citation, or at least pointing out which incidents on this list you feel are serious.)

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by mtrimpe on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:22AM (#7155984)
How about this one from October 2013 where a 25-year old woman gets talked into doing a body shot in a bar and ends up getting fingered by her boss while lying on the bar? http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Codemash_sexual_assault

That's when limiting myself to bar-related incidents in direct technology events. If you include conferences here's a full on attempted rape from last year: https://web.archive.org/web/20130627000201/http://georgiawei...

I'm even excluding the comic cons because they're arguably not that tech-related but harrasment there seems even more prevalent.

Notice how they also all refer to archive links? That's due to a mix of for fear of the consequences of having these posts be at the top of Google when searching for the victims name and straight-up libel suits being initiated by the perpetrators.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by onetwofiveten on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:17AM (#7150737)
It's not really like insisting on dirt bike racing. The article is like complaining that everyone else likes dirt bike racing and you don't and that makes you feel excluded.

edit: Although I can see the point about men drinking being potentially intimidating towards women.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by jiggy2011 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:22AM (#7150491)
I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing to have multiple events where the vibe is different, a less boozy conference might attract people who would otherwise go to the boozy one if it results in a more productive outcome etc.

Once your community is big enough it gets increasingly unlikely that a single planning committee will be able to design an event that appeals to everyone and that is ok, nobody has a monopoly on Javascript conferences.

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by coldtea on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:59AM (#7151681)
>> If you feel like the event is too immature, don't show up or organize your own events. >I don't know how you meant that, but it reads very much like STFU or GTFO to me.

Well, when you want to change how MOST (by his admission) other attendants have fun, it's really par for the course, isn't it?

>>Except that alcohol is more than just a social lubricant; it's a disinhibitor. That in and of itself creates an exclusionary environment for many women, because they can't rely on physical dominance to counteract the dangers that come with a large group of uninhibited men.

I've never seen women have much trouble attending dance clubs, bars, concerts and the like -- places full of men and women drinking. A conference, if anything, sounds much safer than those.

Are we talking 1950's Alabama women here?

Re:Our Culture of Exclusion (or, why I'm not going to *conf) by mtrimpe on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:34AM (#7156005)
I know that you're not particularly sensitive to these issues, but there's a huge difference between attending a bar by choice for personal reasons and having to attend a bar to be able to fully participate in all parts of professional events.

As for how much safer it is; I've already commented a bit on that here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7155984