News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fighting Against Evidence by jostmey on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @05:30PM (#7147580)
I am torn. On the one hand I firmly believe that medicine should be evidence based. Treatments should be based on the best possible scientific evidence. Inevitably, such evidence will rely on large, randomized controlled clinical trials...

On the other hand, I take it as my own personal responsibility to take care of my own health. This means that I have to rely on a sample size of one. If I try something, and I feel better then I try more of it. My prescription for myself may not work for anyone else, it could be specific to me.

I personally believe that Western medicine is awesome because it is evidence based. At the same time, Western medicine has removed from the individual a sense of personal responsibility, and this must change.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by icebraining on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @05:37PM (#7147618)
Well, Eric Topol[1] argues that evidence-based medicine, coupled with copious amounts of data and better tools, will allow treatments to be much more individualized, not less.

[1] http://www.scripps.edu/research/faculty/topol

http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2013/04/topol_on_the_cr.htm...

http://www.amazon.com/Creative-Destruction-Medicine-Digital-...

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by mchusma on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @06:25PM (#7147880)
First, the concept of "Western Medicine" is a misleading one. It implies there it is the opposite of "Eastern Medicine". Evidence Based Medicine, the subject of this post, is a much better term. Any methodology is appropriate, so long is it is backed by science.

I think Evidence Based Medicine puts personal responsibility on the individual. Individuals need to realize that Marketing does not Equal better care, all that matters is the science.

Evidence Based Medicine has nothing to do with personalized medicine, it is simply a way of analyzing the efficacy of medicine...science.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by Crito on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @06:30PM (#7147925)
The "Eastern"/"Western" dichotomy also ignores the existence of many scientifically questionable/discredited practices that originated "in the West". Homeopathy and chiropractic are both examples of prominent "alternative medicine" from 'the West'.

Similarly, plenty of medical techniques developed in 'the East' are backed by evidence.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by Alex3917 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:34PM (#7148743)
Western medicine or, more accurately, allopathic medicine, is actually a much better term than Evidence Based Medicine because most of medicine is not especially evidence based. There are countless studies and books on this topic.
Re:Fighting Against Evidence by vacri on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:30PM (#7148908)
because most of medicine is not especially evidence based

This is nonsense. Most of medicine is evidence based. Most of what a surgeon does, for example, is being a glorified handyman - staple this bit to that, remove and replace this other bit, all of which has had ample opportunities for study and observation. Or riffling through a MIMS for pharmaceutical information, the bulk of which is backed by drug trials. Cut your finger? Apply some antiseptic perhaps, and cover with a band-aid, both items that have had plenty of testing.

Some parts of modern medicine may have fallen through the gaps, but it's absolute nonsense that 'most' has. The bulk of medicine is boring stuff that no-one ever thinks about. Where modern medicine is weak is in preventative medicine.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by Alex3917 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:41PM (#7148943)
"A simple average of the findings of the preventive care studies shows that about 50 percent of people received recommended care. (None of the studies reported a percentage of people receiving contraindicated preventive care.) An average of 70 percent of patients received recommended acute care, and 30 percent received contraindicated acute care. For chronic conditions, 60 percent received recommended care and 20 percent received contraindicated care. These values do not indicate exact levels of quality in the United States, but they do provide a quantitative sense of how much could be done in all areas to identify and eliminate overuse and underuse of care." Source: http://www.innovationlabs.com/summit/summit3/readings/Schust...

In other words, the percentage of the U.S. population who receives medical treatment based on best practices isn't even close to 50%. And more often than not even doctors who follow clinical guidelines aren't actually following best practices, because most clinical guidelines aren't even correct:

"A study published in JAMA in 1999 evaluating the quality of [clinical] guidelines showed, ironically, that they often fall short of established standards. The following year The Lancet published a report that found that only one of the 20 clinical guidelines examined met established standards of quality for three simple criteria: description of the professionals involved in formulating the guidelines; description of the sources of information used to find the relevant scientific evidence; and grading of the evidence used to support the main recommendations.

In 2000, Canadian researchers from the British Columbia Office of Health Technology Assessment evaluated the quality of the guidelines that addressed the testing of cholesterol levels. They found that four out of five of these guidelines did not reflect the best scientific evidence available. The Canadian Researchers also found that 'the greater involvement of clinical experts in the development process of the clinical practice guidelines, the less of recommendations reflected the research evidence.'" Source: Overdosed America, p. 127

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by vacri on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:55AM (#7149515)
How does 'simple average of 50%', 'average of 70% receiving recommended acute care' and '60% received recommended chronic care' somehow mean 'not even close to 50%'? They're all 50% or higher.

Also, there is a difference between 'not the best standards' and 'not evidence-based medicine'. What might have been the best standard when the doctor trained in 1980, gained from evidence, might have developed further. The doctor is still performing due to their evidence-based training; it's just not current best practises.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by dllthomas on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:55PM (#7148992)
"Evidence-based medicine" is an ideal term for what we seek. Both our existing "mainstream" medical infrastructure and presently alternative therapies should be judged by how well they approximate this. Not all evidence is large, controlled studies - but they do constitute a particularly strong form of evidence.
Re:Fighting Against Evidence by dllthomas on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @07:17PM (#7148182)
"If I try something, and I feel better then I try more of it."

Conclusion: laudanum for everything!

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by Crito on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @06:23PM (#7147867)
IMHO, the problem with "alternative medicine" is less what adults do (or do not do) to themselves, and more with what adults do to children that they have been entrusted with.

Thankfully there has been progress in recent years on this front, with adults who neglected to seek evidence-based medicine for the children that they were entrusted with being charged with homicide (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kara_Neumann_case). There is more progress to be made however.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by npsimons on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @06:23PM (#7147868)
Western medicine has removed from the individual a sense of personal responsibility, and this must change.

I must heartily disagree. Well, perhaps not so much disagree as clarify: Western medicine as it is practiced, perhaps discourages personal responsibility (and how many times would you tell patients to eat better and exercise more if they never did?). Evidence based medicine is just that: based on evidence. There's no "removal" of personal responsibility, there are simply facts, as in your case you have brilliantly demonstrated: when something works for you, you continue to use it. My immediate reaction to "trying something" that you mentioned, however was "how many things did you try?" How many people won't research different options, much less put them into practice, simply because it would require them to try something different, or something hard (like exercise)? How many people would rather take some snake-oil to lose weight than eat less and exercise more? How many people will refuse vaccines because they believe it's a government conspiracy?

And let's not forget all the other confounding factors, such as big pharma with 85+% of their money dedicated to marketing, or the placebo affect, etc, etc.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by jostmey on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @06:51PM (#7148047)
Western medicine has removed from the individual a sense of personal responsibility in the following sense. We are told to ignore what may work for us and to instead try what works a large number of other patients. While the advice may be good advice, it leaves the patient with an attitude that their own ideas about how to treat themselves may be worthless. And this could encourage the patient to place their doctor upon a pedestal - only the doctor knows what is best for you.

Of course, some advice is just always good advice - eat right and exercise. But you don't need a doctor to tell you that. I have observed that it is the same people who take the best personal care of themselves, by eating right and exercising, also engage in alternative medicine. The very act of trying to take control of your own health leads you to focus in on what works (or what you "think" works) for you.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by pekk on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:04PM (#7148642)
How do you know what actually works for you, and what simply coincided with a change that happened for some other reason? It is literally impossible to tease out these questions without some kind of control.

edit: For example, you like drinking diet coke and one morning you find you don't have cancer. Was it the diet coke that drove away the cancer? Did you even have cancer? Just doing things you want to do and approving yourself for them, claiming that they cured you or something, is not responsible and in many cases isn't really even honest

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by glenra on Thursday January 30, 2014 @04:33AM (#7149763)
> How do you know what actually works for you, and what simply coincided with a change that happened for some other reason? It is literally impossible to tease out these questions without some kind of control.

It depends on the question. For lots of medical issues you could serve as your own control. If your medical issue is a rash or acne or trouble sleeping well or high blood pressure or any other condition that persists over time and is measurable, you can just start tracking it then try various changes and see how the metric matches with the changes. Do two weeks on and two weeks off a few times - either there's a break in the chart - a big noticeable improvement - at the appropriate times or there isn't.

I agree this wouldn't work for cancer, but it would work for a lot of things. If the effect magnitude is large enough you don't need a big clinical trial to see it. And if the treatment is cheap and available enough there's no chance in hell that anybody is going to fund a big clinical trial - trials are really only done for drugs that can be patented, so whoever sponsors the tests has a way to get their money back.

So long as it takes hundreds of millions of dollars to get a treatment past the FDA's tests, there are inevitably going to be a huge number of perfectly valid treatment options that nobody has financial incentive to pay for testing in that particular way.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by DanBC on Thursday January 30, 2014 @04:40AM (#7149779)
It really wouldn't work for a lot of things.

Many illnesses just get better over time. Doing nothing is as effective as doing something. But the patient does something and correlates that with getting better and then thinks there is a causal link.

Re:Fighting Against Evidence by kps on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:03PM (#7148636)

  > it leaves the patient with an attitude that their own
  > ideas about how to treat themselves may be worthless.
Well, they probably are.
Re:Fighting Against Evidence by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:18PM (#7148864)
My favorite semi-facetious/sarcastic journal article: http://www.bmj.com/content/327/7429/1459

"Conclusions As with many interventions intended to prevent ill health, the effectiveness of parachutes has not been subjected to rigorous evaluation by using randomised controlled trials. Advocates of evidence based medicine have criticised the adoption of interventions evaluated by using only observational data. We think that everyone might benefit if the most radical protagonists of evidence based medicine organised and participated in a double blind, randomised, placebo controlled, crossover trial of the parachute."

And a less facetious one http://www.bmj.com/content/333/7570/701

Both of which point out obvious shortcomings of slavish reliance on large, randomized controlled clinical trials for every circumstance.