News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by ck2 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:00AM (#7143810)
Everyone has already forgotten Pfc. Manning rotting away for 35 years.

I saw a "free Snowden" sign the other day which I thought was asinine.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by timsally on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:01AM (#7144174)
> Everyone has already forgotten Pfc. Manning rotting away for 35 years.

Please represent the facts accurately. Manning is eligible for release in 7-8 years. I'm willing to make a long bet (http://longbets.org) for $300.00 that Manning does not serve 35 years, or "rot away for 35 years" as you put it. Are you up for it?

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by gamerdonkey on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:18AM (#7144284)
I hate that this nitpicking has become the standard response whenever someone is facing a prison sentence. It utterly belittles the hardship that people like Pfc. Manning actually face, even if it is for 7-8 years in the end.

Additionally, the parole or probation that she faces even after release are still punishment. It's not as though the troubles are suddenly over.

Treating the issue in this way makes it sound like the judge announced the 35 year sentence, slammed a gavel, then looked over to Manning with a wink and a whimsical smile. That's not what happened. 35 years was the sentence, and that is what you should expect to hear in relation to the case, even if it can be reduced with work on the part of the defendant.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by lispsil on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:17PM (#7145221)
Eligible for parole means nothing too. They won't ever let manning out early because they must 'set an example' to deter future whistleblowers, and don't want manning on the talkshow circuit talking about war crimes
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by sliverstorm on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:01PM (#7145959)
35 years vs. 7-8 years is not exactly nitpicking.

What they get out in, is just as relevant as what they were sentenced to. Otherwise, why do we get so mad when a murderer is sentenced to 20 years and out in 2?

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by gamerdonkey on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:38PM (#7147150)
I agree that it is a fairly large difference in number, but I still think that trumpeting on about it distracts from the primary discussion.

At best, this is all speculation. 7-8 years is the time before Chelsea Manning becomes eligible for parole. Whether or not she is actually released will depend on a number of factors, including the political climate at the time. We'll only really find out around 2021.

Finally, and this is something I touched on in my first comment, even 7 years in a federal prison is nothing to sneeze at. A non-trivial amount of time spent on federal probation after release isn't exactly going to be a cakewalk, either. And this is all on top of the time already spent in the military justice system, including almost a year of solitary confinement. Basically, I'm just asking that we don't downplay what must be an awful experience simply because our justice system has wiggle room.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by ck2 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:07AM (#7144662)
After the aggressiveness of the current administration, you think there is a chance the next administration might come along and say "nope, they need to serve the full 35 years".

The sentence is 35 years. They could legally be forced to serve the full 35 for any reason. As far as I am concerned that is the weight being hung around their neck, not the imaginary eight.

And eight years in prison is an insanely long time, don't forget the terrible health care and dangers from other inmates. You can lose all your teeth and die from infections very easily if someone decides to just let you rot.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by MBlume on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:18PM (#7146064)
Your comment is unclear on whether you intend to bet with timsally
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by guelo on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:20AM (#7144770)
He was given 3.5 years for time served. He'll really be eligible for parole after a full decade in jail.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by ck2 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:42AM (#7144948)
Yeah what's a decade in prison anyway.

Go spend 10 days in your bathroom. I bet you cannot do it.

Now realize how incredibly comfortable you are compared to prison.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by untog on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:15PM (#7146049)
How is that a useful comparison to anything?
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by MBlume on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:17PM (#7146061)
She
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by ShawnBird on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:52PM (#7146780)
First I have heard about that. I had to look it up on wikipedia. I have a resentment of gendered pronouns but I don't think there is any realistic hope for change.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by rdl on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:05PM (#7145590)
I'd bet on released at first parole hearing as long as Manning is willing to be "quiet" and just goes on to enjoy life. Which would probably be a desirable outcome, given age. It's pretty easy to make an argument for leniency based on age, irresponsibility-when-committed, and complete life changes (I mean, sex change, the Snowden revelations, by then no troops in Iraq/Afghanistan (hopefully!), stepping down from perpetual war (if for no other reason than economics), and at least one change of President.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by guelo on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:02AM (#7144623)
I'd take the bet if you'd be willing to take the position that he'll be released in 7 years. Betting hat he'll be paroled somewhere between 7 and 35 years is silly.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by kingkawn on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:20AM (#7144294)
I would add another $300 to this bet as well in support of your position.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by duaneb on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:38AM (#7144019)
I'm not sure if either of them deserve the Nobel Peace Prize, but I believe Manning's sentence is reasonable. I'd like to shake his hand, buy him a beer, thank him personally, but it's a decision he made that has severe consequences for a reason. And while I don't like Snowden at all, I think his actions are much more justifiable from an ethical point of view. It's not like terrorists were unaware the NSA was spying before they had proof—the only people being blindfolded were citizens. Manning's actions were more complex and the ramifications were less straightforwardly positive.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by ck2 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:46AM (#7144076)
So by your standard, Martin Luther King Jr. should be getting out of prison just about now?

Manning was a whistlerblower, just like Snowden, with less power and ability for flight to defend themselves.

There was no personal gain ever intended or achieved, yet great personal loss even in the best outcome. They saw something very wrong happening and had little to no way to say "hey there are some incredibly powerful forces in this country doing some very evil things".

The problem is we only treat whistleblowers like traitors legally and Manning's "trial" was a complete scam, zero media coverage allowed on purpose by the government so they could be railroaded.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by bostonpete on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:35AM (#7144410)
I don't purport to be an expert on either of these cases, but my impression as a casual observer was that Mannings leak was just a massive dump of classified documents without any attempt to be selective about which information needed to come to light.

Any sizable dump of classified documents is likely to have some damning pieces in there but that doesn't necessarily justify blindly leaking massive amounts of documents. I think Manning would have gotten a more favorable response by more people if he had been just a bit selective in what he leaked.

Again, I don't have deep knowledge on either of these cases compared to some around here so I'll concede that maybe I'm wrong on some of my facts...?

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by duaneb on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:26AM (#7144345)
It's not even clear Manning is a whistleblower—what the hell did he blow a whistle on? It's not like any widespread scandal, corruption, or conspiracy was revealed.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by joshfraser on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:09PM (#7145165)
I believe this was where it started http://www.collateralmurder.com
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by BlackDeath3 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:16PM (#7145213)
Yeah, I was under the impression that he leaked information on the slaughter of civilians in the Middle East by soldiers/mercenaries. My familiarity is clearly cursory.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by mbreese on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:32PM (#7145339)
Along with a ton of other stuff that wasn't germane to that incident. Manning's big issue was that they released a bunch of classified material without much regard for what it said. It was very broad in scope. Had it been a narrow subset of the data, Manning would have had a better chance of being considered a whistleblower.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by BlackDeath3 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:45PM (#7145437)
OK, that is what I had heard.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:42PM (#7147184)
Let's not compare Martin Luther King Jr. to Snowden and Manning.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by efdee on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:49AM (#7144089)
"I'd like to shake his [sic] hand, buy him [sic] a beer, thank him [sic] personally", "but I believe Manning's sentence [of 35 years in prison] is reasonable". My jaw dropped to the floor. Assuming that you want to thank her for doing that thing that landed her in prison, there is nothing you can say that can reconcile those two statements for me.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by duaneb on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:28AM (#7144365)
Are they contradictory? There are plenty of criminals I like personally who deserve to serve time for breaking the law.

EDIT: I wouldn't conflate ignorance of her gender and disrespect, it's not anything I've ever heard.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by Pxtl on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:49AM (#7144513)
You miss the point. Pfc. Manning now identifies as Chelsea Manning. She is transgendered, and since her military career is toast she has come out of the closet on the subject.

I'm going to be generous and assume that duaneb poster was not closely following the story and is unaware of the above.

Transpersons are always the subject of massive flamewars online, so some folks get really strong kneejerk reactions to misgendering.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by Gracana on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:56AM (#7144567)
I think efbee was responding to "I think what they did was right but also they deserve a 35 year sentence" as the two irreconcilable statements. Misgendering is an important point as well, but it's not what makes the statements contradictory.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by duaneb on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:46AM (#7144983)
I was not aware of Manning's being transgendered, and I don't mean any disrespect—consider it an editorial he given my assumption of gender from sex (I can't edit).
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by sliverstorm on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:04PM (#7145979)
I doubt it was malicious. I read about it right when she made her choice public, and I still forget regularly. I'm just not used to people changing gender, so my mental constructs treat it as kind of a read-only value...
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by hmsimha on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:37AM (#7144918)
So you're saying you like Manning personally, but not for her 'criminal' actions? What about her makes you want to 'shake [her] hand' and 'buy [her] a beer' then?
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by duaneb on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:05PM (#7146881)
Legal actions and actions I approve of are not mutually exclusive.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by hmsimha on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:18PM (#7146961)
You approve of an action that happens to be illegal, and think people who take that action deserve prison time? I don't follow. If a person's actions are noble in my estimation, I wouldn't wish punishment upon them for their actions.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by 7952 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:57AM (#7144145)
There are thousands of people in government and the military who broke the law and defended their actions because they believed them to be morally justifiable. Surely those people should have a similar sentence to Manning?
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by duaneb on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:27AM (#7144354)
Yes.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by schenecstasy on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:00AM (#7144169)
It's going to be tough to buy (him) a beer.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by swalsh on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:28AM (#7143963)
Manning released a bunch of documents, but how did he change the world?
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by pmorici on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:55AM (#7144131)
A lot of the civil unrest that happened in the world in the years following the State Department cable releases is suspected to have been loosely caused by revelations in the cables themselves that often had candid descriptions of corruption and other misdeeds by governments.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by dferlemann on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:44AM (#7144054)
Fuck the world. He's action is true to himself. For that, I respect the guy.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by ck2 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:45AM (#7144064)
If you respect Manning, please stop saying "he" and "guy".
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by CWuestefeld on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:58AM (#7144159)
This is clearly something that we as a society are going to have to wrestle with.

It seems reasonable to me that this person, having XY chromosomes and all the hardware that go with them, may be correctly referred to using masculine pronouns.

There's something to be said for respecting the wishes of the individual in how they'd like to be addressed. But there's definitely a point at which that drifts off into absurdity. Just because I can claim descent from Henry VIII doesn't mean that I can reasonably expect people to address me as "lord".

So I'm interested in respecting people, but think we need to let this percolate through society first, and determine where to draw reasonable lines, before you accuse someone of disrespect for failing to honor someone's alternate world view.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by Pxtl on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:57AM (#7144579)
There's a time and a place to be pedantic, and this really isn't it.

Transgendered people go through a heap of terrible, terrible crap and the least we can all do is give them the dignity of using their identified pronoun. If anybody has earned that respect, it's ms. Manning.

I mean really, how the heck does it hurt anybody to say "She" instead of "He" after you've been informed that's not how she identifies? Does it really matter that much? Obviously the extreme SJW flamewar reaction you usually see on misgendering is excessive, but after being politely informed that's not how she identifies, how are you harmed by going along with it?

Will the ghost of Plato arise and smite you down for failing to properly class something?

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by xaa on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:48AM (#7144998)
My personal value system (and perhaps milord grandparent's) rates the accurate use of words (aka, truth-telling) rather high on the scale of values. Clear thought is impossible without it.

When we, as a society, take words such as "war" and "gender" that previously referred to physical realities and make them highly metaphorical or even completely arbitrary, we dilute our vocabulary. We make it harder to think and communicate clearly.

I find it especially objectionable when the only argument in favor of blurring the definition of a word is "because someone wants me to" or "someone would be offended if I didn't". Our mere preferences don't change reality; why should they change words, which are meant to convey an accurate representation of reality?

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by Pxtl on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:05PM (#7145593)
Look, we're all coders here, I get the instinct to be precise with our words. But what about the cost/benefit trade-off? Is a small matter of personal policy related to definitions really worth hurting somebody who's already a member of easily the most downtrodden and crapped-upon group in modern society? Is preventing a tiny incremental shift in vocabulary really worth kicking somebody while they're down? I mean, I'm as grumpy as the next geek about the literally/not-literally thing, but this?

Also, think of it like an interface - the idea is that you should treat the transgendered person as their identified gender. So if you're planning on treating this person as a woman in every way in respect for her situation, wouldn't the pronoun/terminology actually make the matter clearer?

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by xaa on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:22PM (#7146526)
Obviously I don't condone any mistreatment of or discrimination against transgendered people and think they should have full legal protections. On a personal level, they should be treated ethically and equitably, just like any other person.

But regarding the use of language, and forgive me for invoking the slippery slope argument, where does it end? The two propositions, "Person X is a Y" and "Person X feels they are or wishes they were a Y", are not the same. In fact, they aren't even close. As a society it would be ridiculous and ruinous if we were to conflate the two.

I believe it is possible to respect people and linguistic accuracy ("truth", if you like) at the same time. Also, I don't think respecting someone necessarily means doing (or saying) everything they want.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:48PM (#7147242)
How far do we take this? This is a conversation about the actions of these people. It is not coder pedantry to refer to Manning with male gendered pronouns. Are we now required to know how everyone feels about their gender before we use any pronouns describing them in every context? In fact, we have to keep with everyone's opinions about their genders throughout their whole lives. This is impractical.

I think here, we just have delusion of persecution.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by LukeShu on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:05PM (#7145131)
The word "sex" refers to physical realities; "gender" refers to social constructions. By conflating the two words, you are the one diluting our vocabulary.

Now, it wouldn't be totally unreasonable for you to assert that pronouns should be tied to sex, not gender; but that's not what you're saying here.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by xaa on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:33PM (#7145348)
@LukeShu

I'm well aware of the current usage of "gender" in educated circles. That's why I chose it as an example.

"Gender" previously was essentially a synonym for "sex" (except in the field of linguistics). But now that it has been repurposed in some circles, half the American population thinks it refers to a state of mind and the other half thinks it refers to biology. The result: confusion and miscommunication.

I'm not saying there shouldn't be a word to refer to what is now called someone's "gender identity". I'm saying the repurposing of an existing word which meant something similar, but distinct, has caused confusion. (I do expect the current sex/gender distinction to continue to be the accepted usage, though).

The same confusion is now happening with pronouns. And, yes, I would prefer if something as fundamental to the language as a pronoun referred to a physical reality rather than a mutable state of mind. That is a debate worth having, but all too often it isn't framed as a debate, it's framed as "you're insensitive and politically incorrect if you don't agree to our new terminology".

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by Cushman on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:17PM (#7145683)
There is no debate, because this isn't about correctness. It's about respect. Let me throw out some hypotheticals here:

My given name is Jonathan. I think this sounds childish, so I tell you that I go by Jack instead. But you've seen my birth certificate, so you keep calling me Jonathan.

I got married and changed my last name to my husband's. You think it's confusing to change names, so you continue to write me using my maiden name.

Although I'm married, I don't want to be defined by my marriage, so I go by Ms. You think that inaccurately reflects my relationship status, and introduce me as Mrs. instead.

I have told you that the use of the male-gendered pronoun "he" makes me severely uncomfortable, and ask you to call me "she" instead. You flip up my skirt, take a good survey, and decide it would be dishonest to represent me as if I didn't have a penis.

The issue in all of these scenarios is a moral one: Do I have the right to define my own linguistic identity, or am I stuck with the one I was assigned at birth? Are you going to be an agent of my liberation, or my oppression?

You can make a good case that each of these blatantly disrespectful behaviors is, by some robotic standard, "correct". To paraphrase a great man, maybe you aren't wrong, but you're still an asshole. You can say this is something you would like to debate, but you don't respect me and I don't like to spend time around you, so go ahead and debate by yourself, thanks.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by xaa on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:26PM (#7146113)
I'm sorry, but I'm not quite the asshole you think I am.

If someone asked me to call them by a certain pronoun or salutation (names are different as they are completely arbitrary), I would do it, out of respect for them. But let's be clear about what's being asked: I am being asked to lie -- to misrepresent reality -- to that person, and possibly to other people for that person. That's a (small) favor being asked, and it is somewhat irritating to be asked a favor with the sort of sense of moral entitlement found in your last paragraph (especially when the favor being asked is a violation of my own morals).

Also, unfortunately, we don't have the right to define our own linguistic identities. I know it isn't fair, but this extends far beyond gender. I don't become "rich", "President", "Filipino", "Doctor", or "intelligent" just by willing it or even by asking other people to call me those adjectives. They are fuzzy categories, some people don't clearly fall inside or outside of them, but they do have non-arbitrary (i.e., outside your mind) meanings.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by Cushman on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:53PM (#7146297)
You know what? I'd also be pretty pissed off if I worked hard to be considered an American and you insisted on calling me Filipino because you happen to know where my parents are from. I would be pretty sore if you acted like not doing that was a special favor you were doing me, by "lying" to people about my ethnicity, and not just being a decent human being.

It would sound like you value my expressed wishes for how I am represented less than you value showing off to strangers some secret you think you know about what's between my legs or in my blood that frankly is none of your business, let alone theirs.

I'm not really sorry if that feels like an imposition on your morals, because if it does then your morals kind of blow.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by CWuestefeld on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:14PM (#7146461)
I get a little annoyed when people say that I'm German. I mean, despite my ancestry, I was born in America, and I've never even been to Europe. And I'm a little annoyed other times when people refer to "native Americans" as if I'm not one of those.

Those are little annoyances. I don't believe that the speaker is trying to disrespect me -- certainly not intentionally -- and I take it with a grain of salt.

In other words: this seems like making much to-do over very little.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by orakle on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @06:04PM (#7147768)
If you are an American citizen then you are American. A more apt example is someone living in Philippines wanting to be called American even though they are not a citizen.

Someone living in Philippines who has no citizenship to America says "i am American", you would look at them and say "no you are not". No matter how much they wanted it to be true the facts do not support it.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by DanBC on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:38PM (#7146659)
You appear to think that sex and gender is a simple, binary, option defined by XX or XY chromosomes.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:57PM (#7147314)
I don't want to be too flippant here but you seem to be making case that we would not want to refer to you specifically in any context ever because you are determined to make it frighteningly complicated to avoid persecuting you.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:53PM (#7147280)
You're just wrong here. Whether "gender" is pure a social construction is a matter of debate. Your fallacy is in assuming a position you personally hold is a priori. You're just espousing one particular position.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by alex-g on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:50PM (#7145470)
Which definition is being blurred, exactly? Definitions may be being changed, but that's in order to make our words more accurate and more practically useful.

It's actually quite hard to determine who is the intended target of a word like "he", since experience presents us with all kinds of difficult cases; appeal to appearance or behaviour or even chromosomes doesn't work universally. At some point, we either have to let people decide for themselves what they want, or impose our own arbitrary classification on them. Someone is making a judgement and I'd rather it be "I feel I am male" than "I feel you look male".

Sure, it might be nice if there were a simple flowchart, based on only objectively observable data, that we could follow to end up with either "he" or "she" in the end. But no such flowchart exists. I propose to drop the "objective" criterion and just ask the person what they prefer - especially given that the only reasons for having a he/she pronoun system are historical and social. If you want to talk about what's going on biologically, in great detail, then feel free, but the pronoun system doesn't have to correspond to that.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by orakle on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:13PM (#7146932)
Here is just one sample of such a line. "fallon fox" he is an mma fighter who now fights in womans division. We could get into great detail of the biology, height and so on that a man keeps even after surgery. Hopefully you see some of the real unalterable issues that arise from such things, can't wait till shaq has gender reassignment and fights women.

I shall be called emperor of all, sadly simply saying it doesn't make it true. Facts are stubborn like that.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by wwweston on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:35AM (#7144901)
> Transgendered people go through a heap of terrible, terrible crap and the least we can all do is give them the dignity of using their identified pronoun.

I think we'd do better to make sure they don't go through a heap of terrible crap (no bullying/abuse for personal choices) and leave people some personal freedom to have different views on pronouns.

> Will the ghost of Plato arise and smite you down for failing to properly class something?

Seems to be happening.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by sanxiyn on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:15AM (#7144253)
It seems totally unreasonable to me to intentionally misgender anyone against their wishes even after such intention was communicated. What possible purposes such action can serve?

I think it's more comparable to calling someone by their old name even after someone went through a trouble of changing one's official name because they hated the name given by their parents. You'd agree that's a bad manner.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by king_jester on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:29AM (#7144374)
> It seems reasonable to me that this person, having XY chromosomes and all the hardware that go with them, may be correctly referred to using masculine pronouns.

Gender != your chromosomes and gender != your "hardware" or any other body part for that matter. Gender is about social identity and structure.

> There's something to be said for respecting the wishes of the individual in how they'd like to be addressed. But there's definitely a point at which that drifts off into absurdity. Just because I can claim descent from Henry VIII doesn't mean that I can reasonably expect people to address me as "lord".

Laying claim to a royal lineage is not the same as having a gender. Also, lord is a title and we are talking about pronouns, things used when talking about anyone.

> So I'm interested in respecting people, but think we need to let this percolate through society first, and determine where to draw reasonable lines, before you accuse someone of disrespect for failing to honor someone's alternate world view.

We already know where to draw reasonable lines: Manning has already publicly stated her gender. You have disrespected this person by misgendering them. Manning's world view is not an "alternate" world view and you are being incredibly transphobic.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by CWuestefeld on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:32AM (#7144881)
While I really do tend to lean in the direction you suggest, I don't think it's quite a cut-and-dry as you claim. Here are a few things to consider.

First, we're only talking about language. We get those gendered pronouns not because of a need to distinguish between how a person views his gender (or how the world views it), but because of stupid linguistic convention going back to English's Indo-European roots. You'll see that in many languages in the same family, nouns all have gender, even absurd ones like "airplane" or "shoe". These genders have absolutely nothing to do with sexual identity, they're essentially randomly assigned, conferring no additional meaning (but providing a parity check in communication, helping ensure clear transmission). Coming from this history, we shouldn't be too concerned with the way pronouns correspond to individual humans.

Second, I don't think it's hard to imagine socially-undesirable consequences of honoring anyone's own claimed gender. I'm thinking of a biological-male claiming to self-identify as female, so that he can use the women's locker room at the gym. So under what circumstances do we want to honor their self-image (or, for that matter, to believe their claimed self-image)?

Third, with identity politics still having legal bearing in our system, it seems that self-identification of gender may derail efforts to ensure gender equality. Given that there are legal structures in place to protect females, may I (as a biological male) claim to self-identify as female, and achieve those same protections? May I at least self-identify on official forms (thereby making enforcement of workplace protections unenforceable)?

Not that these things are insoluble, but I think that we need to give thought to the repercussions should we choose to take any person's claims of gender at face value.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by alex-g on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:05PM (#7145125)
You appear to be something of a newcomer to this issue. I can tell you that everything you raise as a concern has been very extensively discussed - certainly in those places which afford legal recognition to gender transition, discrimination protection for trans people, and so on. Systems exist, and, to an extent, they work.

Still, calling somebody by their preferred name and pronouns does not grant them admission to the women's locker room, or anything else like that. It is a matter of courtesy.

The other thing is that often, in order to have a gender change legally recognized, or to access surgery and so on, one has to prove that one has already been living as a member of the appropriate gender. What this means is highly contested, but stuff like "people know me as Alice, not Bob" is part of it. It's difficult enough without people setting themselves up as linguistic gatekeepers, and deciding that they know better than Alice.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by king_jester on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:23PM (#7145261)
> These genders have absolutely nothing to do with sexual identity, they're essentially randomly assigned, conferring no additional meaning (but providing a parity check in communication, helping ensure clear transmission).

Sexual identity != gender identity. Gendered pronouns do have a long and interesting history in languages that have them, but that is besides the point. We are talking about an individual who has clearly expressed their gender in a public and visible way, to disregard that to use other pronouns is disrespectful.

> Coming from this history, we shouldn't be too concerned with the way pronouns correspond to individual humans.

Actually we very well should be concerned with pronouns and gender. Individual people have their to define their own identity, including their gender, and to be referred to with the pronouns they identify with. That gendered pronouns have their own history is besides the point, that history is not immutable nor is it the same for different languages and cultures. Indeed, there have been cultures and languages with built in support for many different kinds of gender and gender expression throughout history.

> Second, I don't think it's hard to imagine socially-undesirable consequences of honoring anyone's own claimed gender. I'm thinking of a biological-male claiming to self-identify as female, so that he can use the women's locker room at the gym.

This is a tired argument. Gender identity is a big deal for trans* people, it isn't something that someone just up and decides to do so they can perv out in a locker room.

> So under what circumstances do we want to honor their self-image (or, for that matter, to believe their claimed self-image)?

As a society we generally honor people's personal decisions about their identity. We do so for religious change, name change, adoption, interracial marriage and dating, and so on. Gender is no different, people should be free to express their gender as they see fit.

> Third, with identity politics still having legal bearing in our system, it seems that self-identification of gender may derail efforts to ensure gender equality. Given that there are legal structures in place to protect females, may I (as a biological male) claim to self-identify as female, and achieve those same protections? May I at least self-identify on official forms (thereby making enforcement of workplace protections unenforceable)?

It is really clear you have no background knowledge on the kinds of difficulties trans* people face. Trans* people face discrimination, violence, and employment difficult at high rates. You are trying to make it sound like trans* women aren't women, when they in fact are. Official gender identity on forms is a long standing problem for the trans* community at large. There are many places where you cannot change your officially recognized gender at an institution without jumping through a variety of hoops. There are many places where even attempting to do so will get you verbally abused by a clerk. In many places even existing as visibly trans* invites violence.

> Not that these things are insoluble, but I think that we need to give thought to the repercussions should we choose to take any person's claims of gender at face value.

Gender identity has been written about for decades and there is a huge amount written on the social and legal structure of our society as it relates to gender and gender expression. That you aren't familiar with it is not an excuse to make a bunch off the cuff remarks that, whether you realize it or not, are transphobic. So please, don't try to justify your disrespect of someone who clearly identifies as a woman as Manning does.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by CWuestefeld on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:46PM (#7145443)
So please, don't try to justify your disrespect of someone who clearly identifies as a woman as Manning does.

Now wait just a moment. Surely if Manning's own identity can only be understood from his/her own perspective, then my own meaning -- whether I am being disrespectful -- can only be seen from my perspective. How dare you project disrespect into what I am communicating.

You are trying to make it sound like trans women aren't women, when they in fact are.*

I never said anything of the kind. What I said was that someone who is not transgendered might claim that they are in order to get some sexual kicks, or to subvert legal protections afforded to women. I'm not trying to take away from the genuinely transgendered, I'm saying that the claim of being transgendered can be misused.

That you aren't familiar with it is not an excuse to make a bunch off the cuff remarks that, whether you realize it or not, are transphobic.

I believe that I made clear in my post that I was largely in agreement, but was playing devil's advocate in order to draw out some deeper understanding -- just vanilla Socratic method stuff. Your reply seems to indicate that someone who is not fully up to speed ought to just shut up, and accept what his betters are telling him.

that history is not immutable

Ummm. How is history mutable?

As a society we generally honor people's personal decisions about their identity. We do so for religious change, name change, adoption, interracial marriage and dating, and so on.

Something I don't get here. I'm married to someone of a different race. I don't see what that has to do with my identity. The fact that my wife and I are married and of differing races, has nothing to do with who I am or who I expect people to see me as. She's my wife, I'm her husband, and that's all there is to it. I fail to see how this is expecting someone to change, or even have, any view of my personal identity.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by king_jester on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:23PM (#7146531)
> Now wait just a moment. Surely if Manning's own identity can only be understood from his/her own perspective, then my own meaning -- whether I am being disrespectful -- can only be seen from my perspective. How dare you project disrespect into what I am communicating.

It is clear that Chelsea Manning is a woman and should be referred to as such. She had a very public message about this. Continuing to refer to Manning with him/his pronouns is being disrespectful. It doesn't matter if you don't understand or believe in trans* as an identity or that people can actually switch their gender, you are intentionally ignoring what someone publicly asked others to do in a way that is most certainly disrespectful.

> What I said was that someone who is not transgendered might claim that they are in order to get some sexual kicks, or to subvert legal protections afforded to women. I'm not trying to take away from the genuinely transgendered, I'm saying that the claim of being transgendered can be misused.

The reality is that nobody does this. The kind of discrimination and violence trans* people face makes it unlikely that someone would pretend to be trans* for a period of time. Without actual evidence of this happening in a way that systemically abuses legal protections or considerations (of which trans* people get less than the rest of us), this is a false argument.

> I believe that I made clear in my post that I was largely in agreement, but was playing devil's advocate in order to draw out some deeper understanding -- just vanilla Socratic method stuff. Your reply seems to indicate that someone who is not fully up to speed ought to just shut up, and accept what his betters are telling him.

Nobody needs to play devil's advocate for transphobic viewpoints, those ideas and actions happen all the time in society today. There is very real data and anecdote about all the things we've talked about. There is no deeper understanding being drawn out here, the arguments you made are common transphobic arguments that don't hold up (confusing gender with sexual identity, confusing gender with biology, unalike comparison with a gender pronoun and a title, appeal to society at large to define trans* identity, gender pronouns as unimportant, straw man arguments about people pretending to be trans, separation of trans women from other women as an identity, etc.).

> Something I don't get here. I'm married to someone of a different race. I don't see what that has to do with my identity. The fact that my wife and I are married and of differing races, has nothing to do with who I am or who I expect people to see me as. She's my wife, I'm her husband, and that's all there is to it. I fail to see how this is expecting someone to change, or even have, any view of my personal identity.

That is fine if you don't consider such a relationship to be a part of your identity in that way. That is for you to define. For some people, their relationship with others does form a part of their identity in a way they consider meaningful. The point is that we don't automatically disqualify that part of said person's identity. When we do disqualify those things, those attitudes are tied to things like racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, and so on.

Chelsea Manning is a woman and asked everyone to refer to her as such. That is all there is to it. There is no need to try and justify misgendering this person for any reason.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by rdl on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:14PM (#7145659)
My difficulty with referring to Manning now as female is that most of the actions which I care about were from when it was PFC Bradley Manning. It's like anyone who changes name partway through a major news story. Chelsea Manning is in prison now, but saying "As an intelligence analysis, Chelsea Manning had access to classified files and got into disputes with her chain of command over both work-product issues and personal conduct." seems incorrect.

If this had been known before the news story, no problem at all. It's just hard to use "Chelsea Manning" or even "Private Manning" to refer to actions undertaken far prior to this.

Ironically I think this was one of the things bradass87 brought up in chats with Adrian.

PFC vs. Private is just as complex. I think there's a military way to deal with that (because ranks usually do increase); e.g. in some contexts is it "Captain (now Major) Snuffy..."

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by king_jester on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:59PM (#7146345)
It is still the same person. Ultimately something like Manning or private/PFC Manning is the most generic way to describe things if you want to cover that era, but something like "Chelsea Manning, then Bradley Manning,..." is also fine. Ultimately if we are talking about Manning in the present, there is no confusion over the gender pronoun to use (the original thing I was responding to).
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by umanwizard on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:14AM (#7144245)
It seems pretty simple to me. If you ask me to describe my best friend, I might say he's smart, studied this or that in school, speaks such-and-such languages, likes such-and-such music, and so on. His height and weight would be pretty far down the list of things I find important.

Similarly, we think of our mind as being our "self" in a much more fundamental way than our toes.

If a person is female in their mind but has a male body, it seems very clear that we should consider the former to be their "real" gender. Why should the body matter more or be more fundamental?

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by hrjet on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:58AM (#7144588)
I would say the the catch phrase in your argument is "best friend". If the person you were describing wasn't your best friend, you might automatically focus more on the physical aspects, since you wouldn't know the intimate details of their mind.

That said, I am not advocating deliberate misuse of pronouns; I am just saying the topic may not be as simple as it seems.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by wavefunction on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:18AM (#7144745)
In polite society we respect the ways that others wish to be addressed, as long as the request isn't unreasonable (I want you to call me 'Doctor wavefunction' yet I lack the credentials).

It is not absurd to refer to someone by the gender they prefer.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by handsomeransoms on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:28AM (#7144359)
This posts reeks of cisgender privilege [0]. Gender is a social construct, not a biological inevitability, and it is disrespectful to refer to someone as a gender that they have explicitly stated they do not identify with.

I'll let you fill in the comparisons to widespread sexism, racism, and homophobia for yourself. Go back to the leaders of the American civil rights movement and tell them to let things "percolate through society" so they can know "where to draw reasonable lines".

[0] http://www.t-vox.org/index.php?title=Cisgender_privilege

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by TillE on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:32AM (#7144392)
> Go back to the leaders of the American civil rights movement and tell them to let things "percolate through society" so they can know "where to draw reasonable lines".

Better, read the Letter from a Birmingham Jail, which deals sharply and directly with exactly those sort of suggestions from white people. It's quite wonderful.

http://www.africa.upenn.edu/Articles_Gen/Letter_Birmingham.h...

> We know through painful experience that freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed. Frankly, I have yet to engage in a direct action campaign that was "well timed" in the view of those who have not suffered unduly from the disease of segregation. For years now I have heard the word "Wait!" It rings in the ear of every Negro with piercing familiarity. This "Wait" has almost always meant "Never."

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by pitt1980 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:15PM (#7145205)
people have a long history of taking offense when you don't address them as they prefer to be addressed

from Mohammed Ali and Kareem Abdul Jabbar, not wanting to be referred to by their given names

to all sorts of doctors and professors wanting to be address by their professional titles

to all sorts of adults not wanting people under a certain age referring to them by their first name

you to intend to offend, by all means, offend away

but don't act under the pretense that referring to someone other than how they prefer to be referred to won't cause offense

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by 01Michael10 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:42AM (#7144951)
I have no problem if someone wants to identity with a different gender but it can get confusing for others as some people don't limit their pronoun choices to "he" or "she" to identify themselves.

How about this for an idea... Pvt. Manning? Easy and no disrespect.

Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by ck2 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:58AM (#7144156)
Did you not see the videos? Did you know the US military was doing that?
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by sp332 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:29AM (#7144851)
Shooting people? Yeah. I didn't know the helicopter crew felt so bad about it though. I thought they had better psychological support, but they sounded traumatized.
Re:Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize by sigmar on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:23AM (#7144316)