Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests
by camelite on Monday January 27, 2014 @01:58PM
(#7132313)
The charge of whataboutism hinges upon the irrelevance of the counter-charge. Since the two are being accused here of exactly the same crime, the charge fails. Not to mention that, from reading the wikipedia article, the inspiration for the term comes from a situation where the counter-charge comes from the initially accused party, which is not the case here.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
No it doesn't. Read some articles about it. The problem with Whataboutism is that two wrongs don't make a right, and that "you're a hypocrite" is a very superficial rebuttal to an otherwise valid criticism.
There's nothing to rebut. The guy is pointing out an inconsistency in the way law operates. Fairness hinges on consistency. He is identifying the whole affair as unfair which is a valid statement to make.
The "you are hypocrite" fallacy only applies when it is in the form of "you are a hypocrite, therefore what you are saying is false".