News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by pnathan on Monday January 27, 2014 @01:36PM (#7132146)
This is a classic Whataboutism[1], used to derail discussion.

In this case, the topic is BTCKing et al, and this post I am responding to is a "What about HSBC".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by camelite on Monday January 27, 2014 @01:58PM (#7132313)
The charge of whataboutism hinges upon the irrelevance of the counter-charge. Since the two are being accused here of exactly the same crime, the charge fails. Not to mention that, from reading the wikipedia article, the inspiration for the term comes from a situation where the counter-charge comes from the initially accused party, which is not the case here.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by tptacek on Monday January 27, 2014 @04:22PM (#7133321)
No it doesn't. Read some articles about it. The problem with Whataboutism is that two wrongs don't make a right, and that "you're a hypocrite" is a very superficial rebuttal to an otherwise valid criticism.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by kentrado on Monday January 27, 2014 @09:04PM (#7134843)
There's nothing to rebut. The guy is pointing out an inconsistency in the way law operates. Fairness hinges on consistency. He is identifying the whole affair as unfair which is a valid statement to make.

The "you are hypocrite" fallacy only applies when it is in the form of "you are a hypocrite, therefore what you are saying is false".

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by camelite on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @11:43AM (#7138078)
I didn't read the original comment as calling out "hackernews hypocrites" but rather the justice system.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by SilasX on Monday January 27, 2014 @02:31PM (#7132544)
Let's say that I get arrested and hit with a possible 50 years in prison for driving while slightly tired. Not "drowsy" per se, just slightly tired. And the reason is that "hey, you're putting other people at risk -- you could have killed someone there!"

Let's further say that a wealthy businessman killed 1,000 people to harvest and sell their organs. And his punishment is a fine equal to 2% of the profits earned that way.

In that situation:

- Yes, you would be correct to say that the organ harvester guy's actions do not absolve me of responsibility for putting people at risk.

- OTOH, it would be a perfectly valid question to ask why I'm facing such a stiffer penalty for a significantly less harmful act than someone else.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by gnaritas on Monday January 27, 2014 @05:07PM (#7133654)
> - OTOH, it would be a perfectly valid question to ask why I'm facing such a stiffer penalty for a significantly less harmful act than someone else.

No, it really isn't. Your crime stands alone, that someone else may have gotten away with something has no bearing on your case unless that other case established some legal precedent, which it didn't. Another crime doesn't excuse yours.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by onetwofiveten on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @07:47AM (#7136724)
One crime doesn't excuse another. However, a discrepancy between sentences indicates either that one sentence was too harsh or one sentence was too soft. It's a valid question to ask which is true.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by SilasX on Monday January 27, 2014 @05:17PM (#7133720)
That's why I said the bullet point before the one you quoted.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by gnaritas on Monday January 27, 2014 @05:31PM (#7133811)
Which is where you should have stopped; but you said OTOH, and I'm saying no, no OTOH, that's not a valid reason.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by TomSawyer on Monday January 27, 2014 @01:43PM (#7132199)
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by onetwofiveten on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @07:54AM (#7136750)
I think it's okay for the topic of conversation to move from this particular money laundering case to recent money laundering cases in general. It wouldn't be reasonable for BTCKing to use the HSBC case in his defence, but that's not what is happening here. This is a discussion about a news post, it makes sense to widen the discussion to include other related news topics.