News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by untog on Monday January 27, 2014 @11:54AM (#7131379)
Note that this isn't an arrest just for operating a Bitcoin exchange. It's specifically to do with Silk Road.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by thisiswrong on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:02PM (#7131449)
From the BBC article: ''The authorities said the pair were engaged in a scheme to sell more than $1m (£603,000) in bitcoins to users of online drug marketplace the Silk Road.''

This is ridiculous! Please tell me how selling Bitcoin to someone is illegal? What that person does with the Bitcoin they acquire not the responsibility of the exchange. This smells like another case of gvt scare tactics to protect the bankers and their out-dated & thieving business models. Anyone remember liberty exchange ?

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by matthewmacleod on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:05PM (#7131470)
"Each defendant is charged with conspiring to commit money laundering, and operating an unlicensed money transmitting business."

Does that answer your question? It's far from ridiculous.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by coldtea on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:06PM (#7131491)
>This is ridiculous! Please tell me how selling Bitcoins to someone is illegal? What that person does with the Bitcoins they acquire not the responsibility of the exchange.

You know that it's illegal for actual banks to assist in money laundering right?

Money has to pass through specific channels and be exposed to specific checks to be wired from country to country (in some countries even from person to person after a certain amount).

Else you're liable to be caught for assisting in money laundering.

So, yes, if you help people to move money, you can be held liable for what they're doing with it.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by 300bps on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:17PM (#7131577)
You know that it's illegal for actual banks to assist in money laundering right?

You know that when a bank does it though, nobody gets arrested right? They just get a small fine that is a fraction of their net profit from their illegal activities. When someone with Bitcoin is accused of money laundering, everyone involved is arrested and every asset they have is immediately frozen. It's a tremendous double standard.

http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/outrageo...

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by coldtea on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:42PM (#7131767)
>This issue was brought to my attention by pals who had investigated Julia and rejected it for this very reason.

You know that it depends, right? With some heavy big banks nobody gets arrested, with others, and especially smaller ones, people go to jail. Also the US isn't the only country with such laws -- people have gone to jail in other countries.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by logfromblammo on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:38PM (#7131726)
From the evidence available to us, HSBC has been a naughty, naughty bank, laundering drug money with impunity. The fines levied against HSBC for these activities have been laughably small.

It's not really a double standard, though. It only appears that way if you believe our society to be founded upon the foundations of justice and law. If you believe it is founded upon the premise that the powerful cannot be wrong, it makes perfect sense.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by grkvlt on Monday January 27, 2014 @08:17PM (#7134641)
You know that when a bank does it though, nobody gets arrested right? They just get a small fine that is a fraction of their net profit from their illegal activities.

That is to say: 'You know that one of the times a bank did this, nobody got arrested right? ...'

You can hardly generalise from the one exceptional case recently involving HSBC to the conclusion that all banks everywhere always get away with money laundering.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by gnaritas on Monday January 27, 2014 @05:20PM (#7133746)
> It's a tremendous double standard.

And a terrible legal argument.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by dreamdu5t on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:32PM (#7131686)
ALL the major banks in the US are involved in handling money for criminal enterprises. Washovia (now Wells Fargo), US Bank, and HSBC have been caught doing this yet nobody was arrested of course. Those are just recent examples too!

Guess how Wachovia got out of criminal charges? They settled!

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by rayiner on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:08PM (#7131504)
Selling Bitcoin isn't illegal, and the indictment actually says something to that effect. What got Shrem in trouble was conspiring with BTCKing to deliver him Bitcoins that bypassed BitInstant's anti money laundering controls, for the specific purpose of facilitating illegal activity on Silk Road.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by berberous on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:08PM (#7131502)
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by objclxt on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:10PM (#7131524)
It's called being an accessory to a crime. It's not a new concept.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accessory_(legal_term)

If you ask me to front up some money for you to buy some drugs, I'm an accessory to your drug transaction. Similarly, if I sell you some Bitcoins and I know that you're going to go and buy drugs with them...well, you get the idea.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by frobozz on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:24PM (#7131631)
Selling bitcoins (or any other currency or asset) to someone for money that they have obtained illegally is money laundering.

Obviously, all transactions cannot be held to the same standards of diligence. e.g. How can a bureau de change at an airport be expected to know that it is accepting a £5 note from a pickpocket?

However some transactions are expected to attract a degree of diligence, either based on magnitude or some other circumstance.

It is clear that they appear to have been attempting to sell a large sum of bitcoins to people who are at least on the grey side of the law. In such a situation, one might expect that a quantity of the money they receive from the transaction might be dirty.

Whether the defendants are guilty of (attempted) money laundering is for a jury to decide.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by mkautzm on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:06PM (#7131482)
It is the literal definition of money laundering dude. If you purchased something illegally with some currency or good or service with the intention of converting that currency, good or service into a different currency, that's called money laundering and it's illegal.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by hcal on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:12PM (#7131533)
I'm guessing we'll find out that the government thinks they were somehow specifically and knowingly facilitating money laundering for the silk road to hide drug trade profits. Again, thats just a guess.

If they specifically sought out the users or owners of the Silk Road and told them they could convert their bitcoin to dollars anonymously, than thats a little different than if they were just operating a regular exchange that regular investors use.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by aestra on Monday January 27, 2014 @03:06PM (#7132805)
That's like asking "how is buying a TV illegal?" When you knew the TV was stolen.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by coldtea on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:03PM (#7131454)
Well, since they were arrested for "money laundering" it can easily be generasiled to any Bitcoin exchange...
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by tlrobinson on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:23PM (#7131622)
It sounds like Shrem was allegedly engaged in un-kosher business directly with a Silk Road exchanger.

"SHREM, who personally bought drugs on Silk Road, was fully aware that Silk Road was a drug-trafficking website, and through his communications with FAIELLA, SHREM also knew that FAIELLA was operating a Bitcoin exchange service for Silk Road users. Nevertheless, SHREM knowingly facilitated FAIELLA’s business with the Company in order to maintain FAIELLA’s business as a lucrative source of Company revenue. SHREM knowingly allowed FAIELLA to use the Company’s services to buy Bitcoins for his Silk Road customers; personally processed FAIELLA’s orders; gave FAIELLA discounts on his high-volume transactions; failed to file a single suspicious activity report with the United States Treasury Department about FAIELLA’s illicit activity, as he was otherwise required to do in his role as the Company’s Compliance Officer; and deliberately helped FAIELLA circumvent the Company’s AML restrictions, even though it was SHREM’s job to enforce them and even though the Company had registered with the Treasury Department as a money services business."

http://www.businessinsider.com/report-ceo-of-major-bitcoin-e...

Anyway, the market doesn't appear to be crashing, yet.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by ytNumbers on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:11PM (#7131526)
This seems to me like the US government is just getting started regarding Bitcoin exchanges. Government authorities always move slowly, and usually go after the most egregious cases first. This reminds me of the US arrests that occurred regarding overseas poker sites when their executives got pulled off a plane that was making a stopover in the US en route to Central America. This sort of thing does make you wonder if any Bitcoin exchanges and their employees can ultimately avoid US charges of money laundering?
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by TacticalCoder on Monday January 27, 2014 @01:13PM (#7131983)
Yes it's not unlike what happened with Poker sites but... Pokerstars, who had its Pokerstars.com seized (for a few weeks IIRC) by the FBI/DoJ is still, today, raking million of dollars daily in rake (and tournament fees) totally legally (and often with business deals with brick'n'mortar casinos) in nearly the entire world... Except the U.S.!

Should the U.S. decide to "start a war" against bitcoin just like they did with Poker, we'd end up in the same situation: servers outsides of the U.S., not using .com domain names, without the reach of the U.S.

I'm pretty sure that any Bitcoin exchanges outside the U.S. (like MtGox, BTC-E, Bitstamp... which are the three biggest ones) and their employees are shielded from U.S. laws. If they can't extrade Snowden out of Russia, I don't see how the U.S. could reach the BTC-E russian Bitcoin exchange.

The U.S. have been unable to stop online poker worldwide. Should they try to stop bitcoin worldwide, they'd fail too.

Now that said I don't think the U.S. government is going to ban bitcoin or to go on a crusade against bitcoin. At least I hope not.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by andyakb on Monday January 27, 2014 @02:17PM (#7132445)
None of the servers for Pokerstars we in the US, and none of their bank accounts were either, however the DOJ was still able to seize those accounts. The US is not trying to stop online poker worldwide, they are trying to stop online poker sites from offering their services to US customers.

The major charges against Pokerstars were bank fraud and money laundering. If those crimes occur in the US, the DOJ does not care where you are based.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by smsm42 on Monday January 27, 2014 @03:15PM (#7132872)
Don't get too optimistic. They'll get there eventually, just as they are getting there with international money transactions. There was a time when keeping money in Swiss bank was a sure way to hide it from US authorities. Not anymore.
Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by dragonwriter on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:14PM (#7131553)
> Well, since they were arrested for "money laundering" it can easily be generasiled to any Bitcoin exchange...

How? Are you saying that BTC exchanges necessarily fail to comply with money laundering laws in the way the offenders here are accused of? They weren't charged with money laundering for selling bitcoins, they were charged with money laundering for doing things that would have been money laundering if they were done with dollars, euros, or anything else.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by coldtea on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:46PM (#7131788)
>How? Are you saying that BTC exchanges necessarily fail to comply with money laundering laws in the way the offenders here are accused of?

No, but

a) a lot don't,

b) all are way smaller than banks, much less cautious with accounting practices and with much reduced legal representation (lawyers) and political pressure.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by dragonwriter on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:51PM (#7131828)
> > Are you saying that BTC exchanges necessarily fail to comply with money laundering laws in the way the offenders here are accused of?

> No, but

> a) a lot don't,

Well, yeah, I would a assume a lot don't fail to comply the way that occurred here (that is, a lot don't have their official responsible for AML compliance actively conspiring with money launderers to enable violations of the exchange's own AML policy and to conceal those violations from both the government, other officials of the exchange, and business partners of the exchange.)

That's rather my point.

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by shawabawa3 on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:13PM (#7131541)
To any exchange that launders money...

I personally wouldn't put it past the US government targeting honest bitcoin exchanges but that doesn't seem like the case here

Re:US makes Bitcoin exchange arrests by TacticalCoder on Monday January 27, 2014 @01:03PM (#7131904)
Erf!?

Most bitcoin exchanges require proof of identity, proof of residency, only accept wire transfer coming from the same identity as the owner of the account, etc. I wouldn't be surprised if they were soon to add a token sent by snailmail to the address given (like Poker sites in Europe do).

Transaction of fiat to/from Bitcoin exchanges are basically one of the easiest thing to track.

Many honest people are using Bitcoin exchanges and doing legitimate trading. Some may be doing "money laundering" just as criminals are using $100 and 500 EUR bills and are using highways. Most people using highways and bills are still honest people...

This entire "Bitcoin is only about money laundering / selling cocaine" is getting a bit old (but maybe I misunderstood your message).

I don't think VCs (and now business angels) would all be investing in Bitcoin / cryptocurrencies startups if they thought it was mostly money laundering.