Re:Stallman on GCC, LLVM, and copyleft
by thatthatis on Monday January 27, 2014 @06:06PM
(#7134045)
At debate, inasmuch as there was a debate, was the rights you have in work done on top of gpl vs bsd style codebases.
Bsd gives you all of the rights you mentioned that gpl code does and more.
BSD gives the rights for a specific copy. GPL gives that rights for that specific program, and thus exist in all copies.
Copy != program.
If I take Firefox and make it Iceweasel, it is still Firefox but under a few changes. It is still the program that Mozilla developers built, and it is still the result of the hard work they spent.
The GPL can be described in pure terms of personal rights provided to the recipient of the software. It declare that a user has the right to be left alone when they run, modify or share the program. That naturally include not being harassed by legal or technical measures by whoever provided them with a copy, be that version modified or not.
There is no trade offs between different parties. The right to be left alone, or negative rights as its called by philosophers and political scientists[1], has a long history. It is also not a balancing act. It is simply Classical liberalism.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights