Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by birken on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:23PM
(#7118153)
Just to put this in context, any game in which you checkmate your opponent in under 20 moves is considered to be an incredibly quick game, where your opponent must have helped you by playing a really horrible move. The game is over before it has even started to develop. To be checkmated in 9 moves means you basically were making the worst possible move many times.
It would be easy for any marginally skilled chess player [1] to survive 20 moves against even the world champion. If Magnus was specifically playing to checkmate you quickly, 30 moves would be difficult and 40 moves would probably be impossible.
1: ~1500 UCSF strength
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by baddox on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:50PM
(#7118355)
I wonder how many moves a random valid move generator would be expected to survive against a master.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by gk1 on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:45AM
(#7121068)
You mean if the generator chose a random move from the available legal options? Could easily be beat in ~10 moves or fewer, I'd bet.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by avenger123 on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:36PM
(#7118241)
I just find the amount of time he lasted respectable. He could have lost based on the time running out. 9 moves is still better than losing out on 4-7 moves.
I don't play chess competitively or under a time clock so seeing that was impressive (I would have likely just frozen). Your point taken though.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by pkaye on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:43PM
(#7118294)
What is the fewest number of moves than one can lose a game of chess assuming the losing side is trying to the worst possible.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by drewinglis on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:46PM
(#7118312)
The game can be over after each player makes two moves. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fool's_mate
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by goldenkey on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:10PM
(#7118050)
There's nothing super special about an amazing chess player that would let them check mate you in 9 movies unless you play horrendously. Grand Masters are not super heros of chess. They are 'comprehensive.' Lets be real rather than gaudy.
I should mention that I am a chess master and have played GMs online.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by swombat on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:18PM
(#7118121)
Having only two minutes on the clock and an opponent who plays really quickly would unnerve any inexperienced player and turn them quite easily into a horrendous player, IMHO.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by mphillips2357 on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:17PM
(#7118110)
This. Bill is a smart guy but that doesn't mean he played impressively well at all.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by rizzom5000 on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:38PM
(#7118255)
Yeah, this looks like it was filmed live during a talk show. I highly doubt there was any interest from anyone involved, especially the audience, for a lengthy game.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by RoboTeddy on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:02PM
(#7118423)
If an amateur had 10 hours to think about each move of a chess game, and the GM he was playing against had 1 second for each move (and couldn't think on the amateur's time), the GM would still _crush_ the amateur. GMs kind of are super heroes of chess.
(it is true though that 9 moves is a silly short game. most amateurs would last longer)
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by kurumo on Saturday January 25, 2014 @06:08PM
(#7122956)
That is simply incorrect. A GM can perhaps give a strong amateur (2000+) 1 to 5 time odds, maybe 1 to 7, in under a minute time controls. Larger odds would be arrogant, foolish or even suicidal, depending on the specific GM (rating, opening repertoire, etc.)
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by RoboTeddy on Monday January 27, 2014 @07:44PM
(#7134448)
By amateur I was imagining ~1500. If in chess circles "amateur" means "anyone other than a master/grandmaster", then my statement as written is probably false!
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by NAFV_P on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:48PM
(#7118338)
Have you ever played against a formidable electronic opponent? I've heard they sometimes use unusual tactics.
Re:Bill Gates loses to Magnus Carlsen in 9 moves
by georgeecollins on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:34PM
(#7118223)
I have read that bridge is his passion. Probably that is what he is better at.
I agree that it is cool that he did this.
I'm not an avid Chess player but to play at that speed with his obviously gifted opponent and last that long is respectable.