News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by hacknat on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:17PM (#7116997)
If LLVM is so bad why are the people who make it so much easier to work with? You shall know a tree by it's fruits. It wouldn't bother me one way or another whether LLVM was copyleft or not, the people who run it are more pleasant to work with.

I think the biggest hurdle to people caring about copyleft is the sheer tonnage of disrespect people like RMS show to others. Nobody wants to work with a curmudgeon.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by jjoonathan on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:00PM (#7117533)
> If LLVM is so bad

RMS doesn't have a problem with LLVM because it's bad, he has a problem with it because it's good.

> the biggest hurdle to people caring about copyleft is the sheer tonnage of disrespect people like RMS show to others

No, the biggest hurdles to people caring about copyleft are by far the incompatibilities with accepted practices and existing software that make it a lot of work to comply with copyleft ideals.

RMS's tone never seemed disrespectful to me. Uncompromising and occasionally blunt, yes, but never disrespectful. What would you have had him do differently? Compromise his ideals? Spin out a comforting but insincere apology that focused on licensing technicalities rather than the underlying philosophical issues?

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by Tloewald on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:51PM (#7117920)
I find it telling that RMS explicitly has a problem with LLVM because it helps private companies "as well as us" instead of only helping us. It's literally zero-sum for him. He doesn't want companies to benefit in any way from open source.

I think there's a big problem with copyright and software -- the goal of copyright is to provide public goods, but the public goods that copyright protects is the source code, not the binary, yet there are no guarantees that the public will ever get the source code. I think if this problem were addressed (e.g. all software that seeks copyright protection must have its source code placed in escrow) then a lot of RMS's legitimate issues with closed source software would be mitigated. I'm sure he would still resent code being closed source, but at least we'd know that in 25 years or whatever the source code would become available to all.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by erikpukinskis on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:35PM (#7118237)
> He doesn't want companies to benefit in any way from open source.

He never said that, and you're really failing to see his point. He doesn't want GCC to be broken up into tiny bits and have each of those pieces replaced by non-copyleft equivalents. Because he doesn't want the hard work of the GCC community to be used as a scaffold for creating a non-free replacement.

He is totally happy for companies to use and benefit from GPL'ed software in all the ways the license permits. He is totally happy for companies to use and benefit from non-free open source software (like Klang) however they like.

He also has no problem with people forking GCC and splitting it up however they want to. He doesn't think that's a good use of resources, and he thinks it's harmful, but he has no interest in stopping them.

What is is not happy for, and what he is standing up against, is companies making changes to his branch of GCC. The GNU project is a group of people maintaining their versions of various Free Software. You can fork any of those projects and make different choices. But within the context of that project, amongst his collaborators he has opinions about what changes to make, and how best to further the goals of the project. And he thinks this change will be bad for the project.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by dllthomas on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:37PM (#7119610)
I'm not sure if Klang is another software project, but if you meant Clang it is not non-free. Because it is not copyleft, its code can be used in things which are non-free. There is a distinction.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by dllthomas on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:41PM (#7118685)
You're conflating "companies" and "creators of proprietary software". There is substantial overlap, but the "other" that RMS opposes is the latter.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by chongli on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:53PM (#7118367)
No, rms doesn't really care about source code. He cares about user freedom. He wants every user of software to have the same freedom to experiment, modify and redistribute that its original developers had. Placing source code in escrow would not accomplish any of these goals.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by Tloewald on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:17PM (#7119153)
It would accomplish all of these goals in the long run.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by chongli on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:44PM (#7119439)
I doubt that. Look at all the proprietary software that's abandoned right now. Are you telling me that if all that old source code was suddenly released it'd be every bit as good as software which has been free for the same number of years? Of course not.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by joelangeway on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:28PM (#7118611)
> It's literally zero-sum for him.

Well it is. There are a finite number of consumers of C++ compilers. He is competing for the attention of potential free software advocates.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by stonemetal on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:29PM (#7117748)
>What would you have had him do differently?

The only code that helps us and not our adversaries is copylefted code.

I would have him not view people on the other side as advisaries. Sure FreeBSD and Konquer didn't gain much from Apple deciding to use their code, but they also didn't lose anything either. It isn't a zero sum game.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by geocar on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:59PM (#7117978)
> Sure FreeBSD and Konquer didn't gain much from Apple deciding to use their code, but they also didn't lose anything either.

I disagree.

In fact, I think the GPL probably saved the World Wide Web.

That Konquerer was GPL was the single advantage it had over anything else. It used to be a buggier, and slower, and generally worse web browser, but every time someone made an improvement, the GPL made those improvements Free; When Apple improved it, it was the GPL forced them to make those changes available to everyone else, and while the code being available is what helped Google start their web browser, it was the GPL that fed those improvements back into the community.

Perhaps Mozilla (open source, but not GPL) would have remained an acceptable way to search wikipedia, but I struggle to believe it would become good enough to be embedded in nearly every operating system and WWW-capable device.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by epistasis on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:05PM (#7118826)
>That Konquerer was GPL was the single advantage it had over anything else.

This is simply not true, and if it were, you'd be implying that Apple chose Konquerer over Mozilla because they preferred GPL to MPL. In reality, Konquerer had a much cleaner architecture that Apple thought they had a better chance of adapting to OS X.

The GPL had nothing to do with any of these events, the key feature was open source, not GPL. And if Apple had not turned Konquerer into a first-class user agent, Mozilla still would have had a first class open source user agent.

I think the web is one place where the GPL has demonstrated that GPL is not a key desirable feature in open platforms. GPL has had remarkably little to do with any of the web, as it is only used in one of three major user agents, and in almost none of the web-specific server stack.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by chris_j on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:21PM (#7119165)
I interpret geocar's point as being that the (L)GPL is the reason that Apple had to contribute the improvements that they made to Konqueror/KHTML back to the community in the form of WebKit: sure, they chose KHTML because of its technical merits but, having done so, they were obliged to make their improvements to the LGPL code available under the same license, thus allowing Google to use it in Chrome.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by lstamour on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:46PM (#7119890)
Actually, in the Debug podcast, it was revealed that they were going to go with Mozilla's effort and all that held them back was that KHTML was so much simpler to explain, though the simplicity was something it lost in rewrites. WebKit, regardless of original License, was likely going to be open source either way just as Darwin was even without the License requirement. The point here is that non-free uses inside OS X helped rather than hindered the development of KHTML software. By non-free I refer less to the availability of source code as to how copyright around branding forces a schism for normal folks between Chrome/Safari and WebKit/Blink projects. Few will download or trust a silver WebKit experimental build or blue Chromium over their official variants, particularly if functionality is crippled because of the lack of proprietary extensions that would normally ship or easily integrate. Sometimes FSF users simply aren't "the rest of us," which is why it's normal to have competing licenses. I hope this encourages both projects to become more active developing end-user appreciable features, though perhaps I'm more pragmatic that way.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by geocar on Saturday January 25, 2014 @03:18AM (#7120252)
> Actually, in the Debug podcast, it was revealed that they were going to go with Mozilla's effort and all that held them back was that KHTML was so much simpler to explain

Actually, that's completely irrelevant.

The GPL ensured that Google could benefit from Apple's decision to use KHTML.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by nzp on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:16AM (#7120989)
That's exactly relevant! Your premise is that <insert entity> (in this case Apple) objects to releasing things free, and the only thing that made them do it is GPL. GPL is simply not relevant here, no one cared. Apple in turn benefited from Google's improvements of Webkit, etc. People who make decisions in companies, and indeed people in general, are perfectly able to understand the enormous benefits of cooperation. No need for any kind of force or coercion, thank you very much.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by geocar on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:31AM (#7124671)
> the only thing that made them do it is GPL

That's the only thing making them do it.

Whether there are other benefits to giving away source code is not relevant. What they might have done is not relevant. No one could ever say whether Apple and Google and Samsung would have gotten together and made a web browser in collaboration without the GPL.

The fact is that they did not do it without the GPL.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by dllthomas on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:17AM (#7120998)
But there can be greater benefits of defection, particularly in the short term.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by nzp on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:04AM (#7120949)
Your argument, that GPL was KHTML's only advantage, doesn't make any sense because it then follows that Apple chose KHTML because they just love GPL and won't accept anything else despite KHTML's supposed technical inferiority. In other words, you're saying Apple chose KHTML because their only concern was apparently to get to be forced by GPL to release improvements. Because if KHTML was so inferior and forced them to release improvements (let's imply Apple didn't like this), what reason would they possibly have to choose KHTML? "Oh, look, there are these other engines which are better than KHTML but unfortunately their licenses don't force us to release our work, so no, we choose GPL."

In reality KHTML was a much better code base than other options, and Apple didn't really care that much about the license.

Let me tie in this comment with the whole thing about GPL vs. non-copyleft free software drama in general, and why I think GPL has become harmful: what you said I think illustrates a kind of thinking mode that the idea, the practical working principle, behind GPL breeds. The idea is to use force and coercion to make entities do what you want them to do. That road naturally leads to a mindset where every behavior is seen as necessarily motivated by coercion. And that leads one to normalize and accept coercion as an acceptable, even necessary, mode of social relations. I see this mode of thinking a lot with strong advocates of GPL. It's always in terms of someone being forced to do something good, and if they aren't being forced no good shall come out. This is a horrible, horrible way to look at the world. If we take Apple as an example, they open-sourced a lot of stuff they had no legal reason to release, some of those things very non trivial.

I have to point out that I'm writing all of this as someone who respects RMS and FSF's cause a great deal, I even use the term free software rather than open source (in my native language, fortunately, there's no confusion about "free", free as in freedom and free as in bear are not homonyms). However, I do not think GPL and strong copyleft licenses are an acceptable, or even a good way, to accomplish freedom in this domain of life. GPL is maybe a great tool to destroy proprietary software (well, almost, but not quite), but a horrible way to accomplish software freedoms in general.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by chii on Sunday January 26, 2014 @09:10AM (#7125102)
relying on the goodwill of an entity will almost always get you nowhere. Apple (or any other major corporation) does what they do purely for profit - and of their decision to unilaterally release source code (without coersion from a license) is made based on the positive PR gains, on the fact that releasing software to commoditize the competition will help their own business, or for some other publically unknown reason.

It's always better to encode, into law, ethical behaviour we want, instead of hoping for it from people. Doubly so when the 'person' is a corporation.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by Avshalom on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:13PM (#7118076)
To be fair the Mozilla Public License is also copy-left it just uses a weaker (but also more clearly defined) barrier.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by geocar on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:29PM (#7118191)
To be fair to whom?

People can and did extend Mozilla, and they can and did keep those changes non-free because the MPL allows for non-free linking and binary-only redistribution.

While the GPL does not.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by forgottenpass on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:02PM (#7117996)
I would have him not view people on the other side as advisaries.

"Competitor that through their marketplace success makes us further from our social goal" doesn't have all the same connotations as "advisory", but given their goals I don't see how it's not an accurate descriptor.

No, the software marketplace isn't a zero sum game. I'm not even a believer in free software, but it still frustrates me to no end when someone says "not a zero sum game" in a conversation that is so obviously about market share.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by nullc on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:10PM (#7118054)
"Us" is literally the entire world, _including_ the proprietary software companies— up to the point where they start making encumbered versions of the program. So it is far from as simple as straight up competition.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by stonemetal on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:18PM (#7118119)
It isn't about market share it is about users getting what they need. Sure you can measure users in terms of market share but that doesn't make it about market share.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by smithzvk on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:53PM (#7118366)
To RMS and the FSF, what users need/deserve is Free Software.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by belorn on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:58PM (#7117966)
BSD and Konquer are not the adversaries to RMS.

People who threatens others with lawsuit for doing modification or sharing are adversaries to RMS. For example, he seems to dislike Apple because they threatens jailbreakers with million dollar lawsuits and jail, and do not want his code to contribute to that misery.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by _delirium on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:05AM (#7120954)
> I would have him not view people on the other side as advisaries.

A big part of the impetus for the FSF was an early instance where they were adversaries, at least in RMS's eyes. The MIT AI lab had an open culture of sharing code, which was "taken proprietary" by several spinoffs in the early 1980s, who hired away some of the AI-lab hackers and stopped sharing improvements with the remaining not-hired-away AI-lab hackers. Stallman saw that as a bit of a betrayal of trust, not to mention damaging to the open development of software, and users' ability to have the source to & freedom to modify their software.

His solution was twofold: 1) start his own competing spinoff (the Free Software Foundation) which would employ its own set of hackers to develop the "public", non-proprietary codebase; and 2) license their contributions under a new license, the GPL, which would ensure that extensions to their code couldn't be taken proprietary.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by hacknat on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:43PM (#7117864)
I didn't mean bad as in poor.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by quenlinlom on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:15PM (#7117647)
The problem with RMS is that he always assumes people to agree with his way of thinking. His uncompromising tone is also a big problem.

I know, programmers are supposed to be emotionless meritocratic robots, but this Old Boys Know Best attitude is precisely why RMS and GCC is losing user share so quickly these days: the extremist meritocracy of programming culture is actually highly male-centric, and it simply scares off all women and any men who are not sexists.

This is why LLVM is gaining so much support these days: it's technically superior, and its development community isn't sexist.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by tptacek on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:27PM (#7117732)
This isn't a problem with RMS. It's a fact of RMS, and such a well known fact that it practically defines him. People working on FSF projects tend to understand that.

If you actually read what RMS just wrote, or, for that matter, anything RMS has written in the last decade on similar subjects, it's clear that "losing user share" isn't a meaningful metric to the FSF. If you lose user share by strengthening non-free software, then there was no point to the FSF to begin with.

By starting your comment with "the problem with RMS", you might as well be pointing out "the problem with free software". Which, fair enough, but it's not like people didn't realize that non-free software could edge out free software on functionality or user-friendliness.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by jitendrac on Saturday January 25, 2014 @03:29AM (#7120274)
Still community needs such the persons.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by streptomycin on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:34PM (#7117302)
If LLVM is so bad why are the people who make it so much easier to work with?

Who said it was bad? People have said it is not copyleft.

I think the biggest hurdle to people caring about copyleft is the sheer tonnage of disrespect people like RMS show to others. Nobody wants to work with a curmudgeon.

I think that's ridiculous. Do you really think corporate backers of LLVM would just ignore their economic incentives for a non-copyleft compiler if RMS was friendlier?

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by dragonwriter on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:40PM (#7117377)
> Who said it was bad?

RMS.

> People have said it is not copyleft.

RMS says that it is bad because it is not copyleft. Specifically, he says "The existence of LLVM is a terrible setback for our community precisely because it is not copylefted and can be used as the basis for nonfree compilers".

Do you not think that "terrible setback for our community" is a subset of "bad"?

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by streptomycin on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:45PM (#7117427)
I interpreted "bad" in his post to mean "technologically bad" not "morally bad". On second thought, I might have misinterpreted his post. In that case, then the obvious answer to "If LLVM is so (morally) bad why are the people who make it so much easier to work with?" is that niceness and political ideology are only very loosely correlated, at best.

The other part of my comment still stands, though (I think).

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by mverwijs on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:53PM (#7117488)
The license is bad, not the software.

> If LLVM is so bad why are the people who make it so much easier to work with?

How is the license being bad influenced by, or of influence on, the attitude of the developers? Are you saying that surely the license can't be that bad, since the software is written by nice folks?

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by Xurinos on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:24PM (#7118154)
> You shall know a tree by it's fruits.

Don't judge a book by its cover. Follow the money. A witty saying proves nothing.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by Someone on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:35PM (#7117320)
I think the FSF would argue that desperate cases require desperate remedies. You shouldn't expect your army to behave nicely at all times, even while defending your freedom. RMS isn't disrespecting others, he just has been at war so long that he isn't aware of their sensitivities.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by burntsushi on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:51PM (#7117917)
What desperate cases?
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by Someone on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:55PM (#7118770)
The fight for users to be able to change their software, for example to add a 'print is done' feedback message to the software driving the print queue (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman#Background:_ev...)
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by burntsushi on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:12PM (#7119372)
I'm not convinced we're in desperate times. There are several significant open source communities built on copyfree licenses that flourish.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by skywhopper on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:07PM (#7118457)
Does RMS go trolling on dev lists for permissively-licensed projects? The FSF has been around for decades with the same goal. ESR comes in and starts needling over the philosophy behind the GPL on dev lists. Who's showing disrespect to whom again?
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by microtherion on Sunday January 26, 2014 @01:04PM (#7126015)
> Does RMS go trolling on dev lists for permissively-licensed projects?

Are bears catholic?

https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/comp.lang.tcl/7JXGt-...

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by nzp on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:24AM (#7121021)
> Does RMS go trolling on dev lists for permissively-licensed projects?

Actually, he does. I remember when he went to an OpenBSD list a few years ago[1] and insisted they take out ports for non-free software out of the ports tree.

[1]: Too lazy to find the link.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by philh on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:34PM (#7117304)
I don't think anyone said LLVM is technically bad; and there's no particular reason that pleasant people with good intentions can't be bad for a community that they don't explicitly identify with.