Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
by chris_j on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:21PM
(#7119165)
I interpret geocar's point as being that the (L)GPL is the reason that Apple had to contribute the improvements that they made to Konqueror/KHTML back to the community in the form of WebKit: sure, they chose KHTML because of its technical merits but, having done so, they were obliged to make their improvements to the LGPL code available under the same license, thus allowing Google to use it in Chrome.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
by lstamour on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:46PM
(#7119890)
Actually, in the Debug podcast, it was revealed that they were going to go with Mozilla's effort and all that held them back was that KHTML was so much simpler to explain, though the simplicity was something it lost in rewrites. WebKit, regardless of original License, was likely going to be open source either way just as Darwin was even without the License requirement. The point here is that non-free uses inside OS X helped rather than hindered the development of KHTML software. By non-free I refer less to the availability of source code as to how copyright around branding forces a schism for normal folks between Chrome/Safari and WebKit/Blink projects. Few will download or trust a silver WebKit experimental build or blue Chromium over their official variants, particularly if functionality is crippled because of the lack of proprietary extensions that would normally ship or easily integrate. Sometimes FSF users simply aren't "the rest of us," which is why it's normal to have competing licenses. I hope this encourages both projects to become more active developing end-user appreciable features, though perhaps I'm more pragmatic that way.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
by geocar on Saturday January 25, 2014 @03:18AM
(#7120252)
> Actually, in the Debug podcast, it was revealed that they were going to go with Mozilla's effort and all that held them back was that KHTML was so much simpler to explain
Actually, that's completely irrelevant.
The GPL ensured that Google could benefit from Apple's decision to use KHTML.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
by nzp on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:16AM
(#7120989)
That's exactly relevant! Your premise is that <insert entity> (in this case Apple) objects to releasing things free, and the only thing that made them do it is GPL. GPL is simply not relevant here, no one cared. Apple in turn benefited from Google's improvements of Webkit, etc. People who make decisions in companies, and indeed people in general, are perfectly able to understand the enormous benefits of cooperation. No need for any kind of force or coercion, thank you very much.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
by geocar on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:31AM
(#7124671)
> the only thing that made them do it is GPL
That's the only thing making them do it.
Whether there are other benefits to giving away source code is not relevant. What they might have done is not relevant. No one could ever say whether Apple and Google and Samsung would have gotten together and made a web browser in collaboration without the GPL.
The fact is that they did not do it without the GPL.
This is simply not true, and if it were, you'd be implying that Apple chose Konquerer over Mozilla because they preferred GPL to MPL. In reality, Konquerer had a much cleaner architecture that Apple thought they had a better chance of adapting to OS X.
The GPL had nothing to do with any of these events, the key feature was open source, not GPL. And if Apple had not turned Konquerer into a first-class user agent, Mozilla still would have had a first class open source user agent.
I think the web is one place where the GPL has demonstrated that GPL is not a key desirable feature in open platforms. GPL has had remarkably little to do with any of the web, as it is only used in one of three major user agents, and in almost none of the web-specific server stack.