News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by VikingCoder on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:56AM (#7115898)
That's the thing though - Hawking is saying it's not "inescapable."
Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by ck2 on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:08PM (#7115970)
I think he is saying the gravity is not even enough to have that effect and therefore would be points that are escapable?

I always wondered if a black hole could become completely visible again if it collected enough mass to spread its surface area out so that gravity would become thin enough for light to escape again. Kind of like how only the surface of a pond sometimes freezes.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by lmm on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:22PM (#7116057)
No; adding mass doesn't make it less dense (well, it's a singularity, so it's always infinitely dense. But even if it weren't, normally when you add mass to something it becomes more compressed and gets denser, not less dense), just heavier.

(Of course, singularities don't make any sense - which is part of what Hawking's talking about. But that's the classical model of a black hole)

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by waps on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:25PM (#7119572)
It's only necessarily infinitely dense from an outside reference frame. Inside you could have anything you'd want according to GR.

One certainty is that the space inside a black hole is bigger than the size of the black hole observed from outside of it. So it's entirely possible that you could have a solar system or even an entire universe on the inside. According to GR the space inside a black hole should pretty much behave like the rest of the universe, as long as the black hole is growing. As for "not getting out", well it's impossible to approach the edge of the universe too, despite that border having a physical location. But it's expanding at light speed, so ... no way to get there.

So density of a black hole is an entirely different concept from the outside and the inside. Seen from the outside it is infinite. Seen from the inside it is probably not infinite.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by pdonis on Saturday January 25, 2014 @01:51AM (#7120106)
it's impossible to approach the edge of the universe too, despite that border having a physical location.

No, it doesn't. There is no edge to the universe. Our best current model is that the universe is spatially finite, but even if it turns out to be spatially finite, it is unbounded--the spatially finite model is a 3-sphere; like the surface of the Earth but with one more dimension. The surface of the Earth is finite, but it has no edge; a spatially finite universe would be the same way but with one more dimension.

Seen from the outside it is infinite.

No, it isn't. Seen from the outside, the hole has a finite mass in a finite volume, so its density is finite. (The finite volume an outside observer would assign, based on the surface area of the hole's horizon, is not the "actual" volume of the hole; but it works well enough as an "effective volume", the volume that the hole occupies from the standpoint of the rest of the universe.) The singularity can be viewed as infinitely dense, but the singularity does not occupy the entire black hole; it only occupies the center at r = 0.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by fennecfoxen on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:24AM (#7119964)
> One certainty is that the space inside a black hole is bigger than the size of the black hole observed from outside of it. So it's entirely possible that you could have a solar system or even an entire universe on the inside.

That is not a certainty at all. The entire premise of Hawking's paper is that the object we call a 'black hole' is just a really degenerate dense lump that slowly turns incoming matter/energy into background radiation with as much entropy as possible. And that's it. No fancy Time Lord bigger-on-the-inside science proposed here.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by Steuard on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:01PM (#7116719)
The "surface area" of a black hole is defined precisely as the area of the boundary beyond which light cannot escape, so I don't this angle will work the way you're thinking it might. (It's fairly straightforward to show that that surface does indeed expand as more mass is added, too.)

It's pretty neat, actually: if you had a black hole containing the mass of a whole galaxy (which isn't unthinkable, especially in the distant future), local space-time at the event horizon would seem completely ordinary (at least as far as we understand from classical relativity and semi-classical quantum corrections like Hawking radiation). You wouldn't have the foggiest idea that you had crossed that fateful line... until you caught on to the fact that you weren't actually making any progress when you tried to turn back.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by saalweachter on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:23PM (#7117150)
This has always bothered me.

I am not a point mass. If I can cross the event horizon and not know it, then there is a time when my feet are on one side and my head on the other. If signals cannot cross the event, how would I not notice my missing feet? If signals from my doomed feet can reach my not yet doomed head, then how is it the event horizon?

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by Steuard on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:00PM (#7117535)
Well, your feet aren't ever "missing": as far as classical GR is concerned (even with Hawking's semi-classical quantum corrections included), your experience would be perfectly comfortable and unexceptional as you drifted in. The issue is that in that scenario, your head isn't on an escaping trajectory: the nerve signals from your feet might be moving "outward", but your head will be moving inward, and the signal will only get to your brain after your brain has also crossed the horizon.

Now, if you were wearing some sort of rocket collar that fired powerfully just before your head crossed the horizon and carried it safely away from the black hole (or even just held it there), you're right: you wouldn't ever receive that signal from your feet. But I'm pretty sure that would be the least of your worries! (And you would notice your missing feet. And torso.) Roughly speaking, the only non-orbital trajectories close to an event horizon that don't fall straight in must be moving pretty close to light speed as seen by infalling observers.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by codeflo on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:36PM (#7118656)
To state that point in another way, the key here is time dilation. (Please correct me if that's wrong.) Let's assume that your feet send a periodic signal to the brain, a "tingling" that let's you know your feet are still there. As your feet approach the event horizon, the tingling will get slower and slower, because time passes much faster for your head than for your feet. As your feet pass the event horizon, the tingling has become infinitely slow (relative to your head). But there's no sharp line where suddenly something happens as your feet touch the event horizon. (All of this of course only in principle and under the premise that you're not smashed to bits at that point.)
Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by pdonis on Saturday January 25, 2014 @02:00AM (#7120123)
(Please correct me if that's wrong.)

It's wrong. Time dilation is not something you observe yourself to experience; it's something another observer observes you to be experiencing. "Time" is relative, so you can feel your own time to be ticking away perfectly normally while it appears to be ticking much more slowly to someone else.

As your feet approach the event horizon, the tingling will get slower and slower, because time passes much faster for your head than for your feet.

No, this is not correct. As you fall toward and through the horizon, signals travel between your head and your feet just fine, and you don't notice any difference in how fast they travel. But, as I posted upthread, if your foot emits a signal towards your head when it's below the horizon and your head is above it, then by the time the signal reaches your head, your head will have fallen below the horizon.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by Steuard on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:02PM (#7119495)
I'm not sure that this captures the physics accurately from the perspective that you're describing here. The extreme time dilation that occurs as you approach a black hole's event horizon is really a "global" effect rather than a "local" one: it is defined by the relative difference in how time progresses close to the black hole vs. very far away. When you're falling through the horizon (particularly for a black hole so large that the tidal forces at the horizon aren't deadly), your whole body is "close", so there isn't substantial time dilation between your head and your feet.

This is a little bit weird, I know!

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by millstone on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:35PM (#7119235)
I would say this isn't quite right. It's true that time passes more slowly for your feet than your head, but this is due to tidal forces: your head and feet are different distances away from the black hole. For very large black holes, the tidal forces at the event horizon will be small, and the event horizon is the unexceptional, smooth spacetime that Steuard described.

So in your example, for a large black hole, you will experience no difference in the rate of tingling as you cross the event horizon. This is what the principle of relativity tells us: you are in free fall, so the laws of physics must appear the same to you.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by pdonis on Saturday January 25, 2014 @01:57AM (#7120119)
If signals cannot cross the event, how would I not notice my missing feet?

If your feet are below the horizon and your head is above it, then you must be falling through the horizon; it's impossible to remain at a constant altitude at the horizon, even for an instant. So a signal emitted by your foot would still reach your head; but by the time it reaches your head, your head will have fallen below the horizon.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by rca on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:55PM (#7117503)
What if the signals emitted from inside the horizon do reach your head, but only once your head have crossed the horizon?

Basically, you can change your reference point and consider that the signal is not moving, but your head is still moving towards the signal. This way, you're still seeing your legs. (Note that I have no idea what I'm talking about)

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by marcosdumay on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:48PM (#7118328)
Thinking about non-ponty masses on General Relativity makes me dizzy (no kidding, I'm quite sure I know the difference between being in a cenrifuge or on the surface of a planet), but you can take for granted that you'll be dead way before reaching the event horizon of a macroscopic black hole.
Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by codeflo on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:46PM (#7118716)
Is it easier to think about point masses held together by invisible springs? The point masses being atoms, and the springs being electric fields. Not a perfect analogy, but it should work to visualize a lot of the macroscopic effects of gravity.

BTW, it's not hard to convince yourself that masses and springs in a centrifuge behave exactly like those near a large body. (In Newtonian mechanics even.) How are you sure you know the difference?

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by panzi on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:02PM (#7116300)
What surface? A point has no surface.
Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by rosser on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:34PM (#7117310)
The event horizon isn't the surface of the black hole. As classically defined, the event horizon is the point at which the black hole's gravity becomes inescapable. That's not at its surface.
Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by pdonis on Saturday January 25, 2014 @02:03AM (#7120129)
The event horizon isn't the surface of the black hole. As classically defined, the event horizon is the point at which the black hole's gravity becomes inescapable.

But the horizon isn't a point; it is in fact a surface (a 3-surface in 4-dimensional spacetime). Whether you want to call that the "surface" of the black hole is a matter of terminology; the hole is not a solid object--it's not really an "object" at all in the ordinary sense of the term, so it doesn't have a "surface" in the ordinary sense of the term.

Re:Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes' by panzi on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:27PM (#7118934)
Exactly.