It's wrong. Time dilation is not something you observe yourself to experience; it's something another observer observes you to be experiencing. "Time" is relative, so you can feel your own time to be ticking away perfectly normally while it appears to be ticking much more slowly to someone else.
As your feet approach the event horizon, the tingling will get slower and slower, because time passes much faster for your head than for your feet.
No, this is not correct. As you fall toward and through the horizon, signals travel between your head and your feet just fine, and you don't notice any difference in how fast they travel. But, as I posted upthread, if your foot emits a signal towards your head when it's below the horizon and your head is above it, then by the time the signal reaches your head, your head will have fallen below the horizon.
This is a little bit weird, I know!
So in your example, for a large black hole, you will experience no difference in the rate of tingling as you cross the event horizon. This is what the principle of relativity tells us: you are in free fall, so the laws of physics must appear the same to you.
Now, if you were wearing some sort of rocket collar that fired powerfully just before your head crossed the horizon and carried it safely away from the black hole (or even just held it there), you're right: you wouldn't ever receive that signal from your feet. But I'm pretty sure that would be the least of your worries! (And you would notice your missing feet. And torso.) Roughly speaking, the only non-orbital trajectories close to an event horizon that don't fall straight in must be moving pretty close to light speed as seen by infalling observers.