News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by tumult on Friday July 17, 2009 @09:02PM (#711158)
consider Apple iTunes -- if your hard drive fails you have to re-purchase everything

Or you could, like, make backups. Which iTunes even pleads you to do.

Re:Amazon is not the enemy by grandalf on Friday July 17, 2009 @10:39PM (#711269)
I consider it an example of a bad business decision. Suppose I buy a bunch of content on iTunes -- soon I have about 200GB of video and music... so now I have to be able to engineer a reliable and convenient backup system for this... all because Apple doesn't make it easy to deactivate old DRM and re-download the content?

The point of DRM is that it should be able to allow Apple to risklessly let me re-download content. As it stands, and as someone else pointed out, Apple gives you one "lifetime" re-download for whatever music you own at the time. I have used mine, and incidentally I ended up losing about $50 worth of music which Apple claimed it no longer sold, even though the items were clearly still available in the iTunes store.

My point in mentioning backups was to show how unfriendly Apple's overall service is to customers. DRM is a technology which should be able to elimiate Apple's risk, allowing it to deliver superior customer service.

But sadly Apple has gone in the other direction...

Re:Amazon is not the enemy by randomwalker on Friday July 17, 2009 @09:11PM (#711169)
I'm guessing his point was that it is perfectly technologically feasible for iTunes to let you re-download songs if you lose them. The Kindle does that. I have to agree that except for the occasional SNAFU (which affects a small handful of users), the Kindle DRM doesn't inconvenience the user much, or at all.
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by sjs382 on Friday July 17, 2009 @09:39PM (#711193)
it is perfectly technologically feasible for iTunes to let you re-download songs if you lose them

They have let me do this once before.

Re:Amazon is not the enemy by grandalf on Friday July 17, 2009 @10:39PM (#711270)
you get one per lifetime :) I used mine.
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by sjs382 on Saturday July 18, 2009 @11:20PM (#712544)
Is that really a hard restriction? Curious whether anyone has tried to do it more than once. I needed to do it for only a few songs because my backups were corrupt (or incomplete) when a drive died.
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by grandalf on Saturday July 18, 2009 @04:26PM (#712126)
Apple now lets you restore content from an iPod, but at the time my drive crashed, iTunes would immediately delete songs from an iPod that were "purchased" by some other iTunes instance (even if it was under the same account).

For the second crash, I had way more content than the 30GB capacity of my iPod -- my backup drive died and only 30GB were on the iPod.

This is just silly considering that I've spent probably thousands of dollars in the iTunes store and I haven't downloaded any illegal content since the first day I started using iTunes years ago.

Re:Amazon is not the enemy by ajg1977 on Friday July 17, 2009 @09:43PM (#711197)
Apple will actually let you do that, they just don't advertise the fact.
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by grandalf on Friday July 17, 2009 @10:40PM (#711273)
You get one per lifetime. I used mine already. Is it my fault that I have had two hard drive failures? How much energy should I have to put into backing up something that Apple could easily let me re-download if it wanted to?
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by ajg1977 on Saturday July 18, 2009 @09:14PM (#712422)
No, but it is your fault that you didn't learn about the value of backups after the first time.
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by grandalf on Sunday July 19, 2009 @03:33PM (#713292)
My point is that DRM is a technology that should remove the annoying requirement of having to back up songs -- I could see having to back up songs downloaded via bittorrent, etc.

Apple offers the worst of all worlds by imposing DRM and also not allowing a simple re-download option.

I really don't want to spend $100 on a backup drive and then have to back up my iTunes folder after every purchase. That is totally not how things should work in 2009.

Notably, all my other data (code, documents, etc.) is easy to back up (documents on google docs, code on github)... so the only thing I ever need to worry about is music.

Re:Amazon is not the enemy by CamperBob on Saturday July 18, 2009 @02:05AM (#711436)
Where is it documented that you get one re-download per lifetime?
Re:Amazon is not the enemy by grandalf on Saturday July 18, 2009 @02:47AM (#711469)
I was told this by Apple customer support when I informed them that my hard drive crashed and that I didn't have a backup.