News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The RedMonk Programming Language Rankings: January 2014 by pjmlp on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:01AM (#7107253)
My first contact with the language was in 1998, when I had to port a particle simulation engine done with Objective-C/Renderman to C++/OpenGL. From a dying NeXT Cube to then raising Windows 95 mainstream systems.

Objective-C has a nice appeal given its Smalltalk semantics for OOP.

However I don't like:

- lack of modules, using prefixes is so 70's!

- @ in all keywords and Objective-C literals

- manages to have method names even longer than Java enterprise frameworks do

- the way properties are declared

> Heck, even back in the day, the first browser was developed in it, as well as the first true first-person-shooter.

Historical accident, as these were the systems those developers had available to them.

Re:The RedMonk Programming Language Rankings: January 2014 by coldtea on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:58AM (#7107360)
>However I don't like: - lack of modules, using prefixes is so 70's! - @ in all keywords and Objective-C literals

No disagreement there. Though those are historical baggage, like C has. I see Apple fixing the module issue at some point though.

>manages to have method names even longer than Java enterprise frameworks do

Not true, most method names are short. Except if you also count the parameter names -- but then that's another story, and it has other benefits (knowing what every parameters does and self-documenting your code for example).

>Historical accident, as these were the systems those developers had available to them.

Not true, in fact they had to get out of their way to have these machines compared to the standard unix workstations of the day or PCs. Carmack has access tons of other machines at the time. And both TBL and Carmack waxed about the NeXT / objective-c environment afterwards.

Re:The RedMonk Programming Language Rankings: January 2014 by pjmlp on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:38AM (#7107432)
> Not true, most method names are short. Except if you also count the parameter names

Parameter names are part of the method name.

> Not true, in fact they had to get out of their way to have these machines compared to the standard unix workstations of the day or PCs.

CERN had quite a few NeXT stations available to them. When I worked there, there were workstations collecting dust.

Carmack used C, not Objective-C, the NeXT advantages were mainly due to tooling

http://www.gamasutra.com/php-bin/news_index.php?story=21405