John Forbes Nash, Jr. is the math guy.
Graham Nash was the lead singer of the Hollies and a member of Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young.
Both of these guys' work is worth checking out.
Agree with you about Graham Nash, also worth checking out ;)
this
Math education is mainly suffering from a PR problem right now. Most people associate the word 'math' with memorization of facts and rote learning of arithmetic steps. These are boring and unpleasant activities: if this is what math is like, then I don't like math either!
It's end time we re-associated math with abstract thinking and modelling of the real world. It will make it much harder to be a math hater... Anyone interested in rekindling their relationship with math and physics can check out my book http://minireference.com/
> Math (I'm talking about the US based university approach) changes dramatically once you get to "upper division" coursework.
It's not just a dramatic change; for most, it's a cliff thrown in the middle of the learning curve. There are many reasons for it: some high schools passing students along when they shouldn't, some professors doing the same thing when students get to college, and the ever-so-fetishized focus on applications over concepts. In short, it's a cultural problem. And at this point, I have no idea how--or if--it can be resolved.
When I transferred to a new university I was placed in their first year calculus program over my own protests. I had already done AP Calculus in high school, and completed the first year calculus course at my previous college, which was admittedly of much lower quality than the university I was transferring to. I thought this new one would be a complete waste of my time.
The first thing we covered in this new course were limits. I rolled my eyes; everyone knows how to find a limit. Was this really the kind of thing we were going to cover in this class? Then the professor said these words I had never heard in relation to limits before, "epsilon" and "delta." And here my troubles began.
That turned out to be one of the hardest courses I've ever taken, I had to relearn almost everything I thought I knew about math.
In Calc I, I kept my eyes out for two groups of students: those who did really poorly on the first exam, and those who did really well. The first I watched for obvious reasons, but some of the folks in the latter group--especially those who took some calculus in high school--would start to think "Oh, I know all of this now! Cool. Easy A." and then coast. And they'd be mincemeat somewhere in between implicit differentiation and related rates.
None of it really made any sense to me, and in retrospect, the only reason I even managed a passing grade in the course was because I'd been taking a statistics course at the same time that covered many overlapping topics (sets and relations, discrete probability, etc) in a "use these things to calculate this other thing" way that actually meshed with my previous education.
Proofs were the real killer out of all of it. I still today have barely any idea how to manage a formal proof or what elements are involved in one, because at the time trying to figure out what the hell was going on with this notation and formatting and abbreviations everywhere that I'd never seen before and trying to make any sense of the weird self-referencing logic of it was unpleasant enough that I just fumbled through the bare minimum to get a passing grade whenever they were involved.
I think it's reasonable to assume, given what he stated, that Ross does in fact conceive of math that way. It blows my mind that one can get through a discrete math class and still think of math as basically computational in nature, since as far as I know most curricula treat the course as an opportunity to introduce the sort of concepts that typically figure into an introduction-to-higher-mathematics-type course, such as proof techniques, basic number theory, and so on.
It is, of course, possible to agree with a conclusion while disagreeing with the reasoning behind it. I completely disagree with a couple of statements here. Again, this is probably because as a math major (and as a short-lived doctoral student in an engineering department that was heavy on proof based math theory around optimization and stochastic processes), I've experienced "math" very differently from most people, including engineering or science students who have done a substantial amount of math (say, the calculus sequence through differential equations).
Math (I'm talking about the US based university approach) changes dramatically once you get to "upper division" coursework. Real Analysis is very, very different from the differential equations course that is about one-fifth math majors and four fifths engineering or hard science majors. There's very little "applying an equation" going on. And the notion that there is "one answer" is remarkably incorrect (I suppose it's correct if you define "TRUE" as the one correct answer to fermat's last theorem, but there are often so many different correct ways to go about a proof).
I remember a story about Graham Nash (the Nash equilibrium guy - this is all from memory based on his biography, so I may have some of the details wrong). Nash proved a very difficult and elusive theorem early in his career. It was later discovered that a different mathematician had completed a proof for the same theorem a short time earlier (I think it was a few months). Nash was apparently very depressed by this. However, he shouldn't have been - the other proof was by contradiction, whereas Nash's proof was more direct and contained the structure for an algorithm, and would probably be more influential.
This isn't at all unusual in math. There are a huge number of different angles on a problem.
Part of the problem here is what is meant by "math"... it is a shame that someone could get as far as second year university math in the US and still see it as a field where you simplify things to the point where you can apply a formula to arrive at the one right answer. In Ross Hunter's defense, he didn't say that's all that math is, he said "People who are good at math are good at breaking problems down into parts, recognizing patterns, and applying known formulae to those parts to arrive at the one right answer."
But you know, people who are good at math do far, far more than that. I know, because oh my god math got harder after the standard "calc through diff eq" sequence.