News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Mixing: economic analysis and design guidelines by SilasX on Monday January 20, 2014 @05:56PM (#7092260)
Well, we already have desired situation with a different kind of snow -- cocaine.

Right now, most bills are (supposedly) tainted with cocaine. And yet holding bills with detectable cocaine is not admissible as evidence against you.

That's what these pools are going for: so that every bitcoin has touched every transaction. So yes, you can prove that a bitcoin previously touched a crime at some point ... but that fact has zero evidential value.

Re:Bitcoin Mixing: economic analysis and design guidelines by sliverstorm on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:26PM (#7092362)
Dollars are not an analogue though, because we don't have a record of every time a dollar bill changed hands. Or at least so my thinking goes.
Re:Bitcoin Mixing: economic analysis and design guidelines by SilasX on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:54PM (#7092470)
They're close enough for purposes of understanding the dynamics.

For example, cash bills weren't well-mixed, then finding cocaine on your money would indeed be evidence that you were one or two levels removed from drug handlers, and may (legally and rationally) justify a look at the people you've been in contact with.

Likewise, when it's not regular practice to mix up your bitcoins through pools, then holding a marked coin would be evidence of wrongdoing.

(And I've argued elsewhere that that's also a reason for prosecuting mixing pools as money launderers!)