News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by danso on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:11PM (#7086505)
> When I first met Jobs, I had EVERY Dylan album. I was a hardcore fan. I had bootlegs too. Jobs knew a few popular Dylan songs and related to the phrase "when you ain't got nothin' you got nothing to lose." I showed Jobs all my liner notes and lyrics and took him to record stores near San Jose State and Berkeley to buy Dylan bootlegs. I showed him brochures full of Dylan quotes and articles and photos. I brought Jobs into this Dylan world in a big way. I would go to the right post office at midnight, in Oakland, to buy tickets to a Dylan concert and would take Jobs with me. Jobs asked early on in our friendship whether Dylan or the Beatles were better. I had no Beatles album. We both concurred that Dylan was more important because he said important things and thoughtful things. So a Beatles fan was kind of a pop lamb to us. Why would they portray us in the movie as Dylan for Jobs and Beatles for me?

It's sad that besides being underappreciated for engineering feats that are, even today, awe-inspiring, Woz is often thought of as the stereotypical nerd with no interests outside of tech. He was just as passionate about music as Jobs was, and has a great sense of humor besides.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by waterlesscloud on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:22PM (#7086560)
Woz did things everyone knows they can't do, so he's marginalized as a freak.

Jobs did things everyone thinks they can do, so he's worshipped as a god.

I'm half-kidding. Half not.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by nostromo on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:34PM (#7086606)
To me they are the quintessential yin-yang startup duo.

You don't have to pick a favorite. You don't need to figure out which one pulled more weight. It seems likely that if you removed one, the other would have failed.

edit: chill out folks, I don't mean either guy would have been a penniless itinerant without the other. I'm saying they were much more successful together than apart. I know it's popular here to hate on the charismatic businessperson and praise the technical genius, but the best companies will have both.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:50PM (#7086656)
You should read or reread Woz's comment from OP. He was already quite successful, and widely respected. He may not have ended up being a billionaire without Jobs, but he wouldn't have been a failure.

Jobs on the other hand struggled in nearly every aspect of his life, he couldn't stick with college, he got a job at Atari based on someone else's work, he was such a giant douche to everyone there that they wanted to fire him, he lied to the few friends he had and manipulated them to get money, he knocked someone up and then pretended that his daughter didn't exist, the list goes on.

Steve Wozniak would have had a great life either way. Jobs would probably have died homeless and friendless if Apple never existed.

Jobs proved his talents in many ways as the CEO of Apple, but if it weren't for Wozniak, Jobs likely would have never had a chance to show us what he could do.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by jaredsohn on Sunday January 19, 2014 @09:29PM (#7087188)
>He may not have ended up being a billionaire without Jobs

I don't think he is a billionaire. Googling "net worth woz" finds several articles citing a net worth around $100 million.

But the point still stands (just at 1/10 the level.)

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by markdennehy on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @08:28AM (#7095053)
Wow.

You do get, don't you, that there's no real difference between personal wealths of $100 million and $1000 million? And that there shouldn't be? Why do so few people get that there's a ceiling here? You earn enough money so that you can live off the interest of what's in your bank account, and congratulations, your financial worth is now $MAX.

Seriously. $MAX is a real thing in the real world. It's where you can stop working for money and start spending all your life with your kids, or doing the things you want to do regardless of the mortgage and the food bills and the school bills and so on.

Folks who think $MAX is a naive concept... need to grow up a little bit and remember that life ends and if you don't enjoy it during it, you don't get to enjoy it afterwards.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by jaredsohn on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @08:35AM (#7095089)
There is a big difference. A person with a wealth of $100 million shouldn't be called a billionaire which is why I wrote that comment. :)

I don't get why you wrote what you did as a response to mine; I just made a factual correction. (I even stated that the point still stands.)

Edit:

This was not an argument over the meaning of the word 'billionaire'; the post I replied to likely assumed that Wozniak was a billionaire (defined in the way that over 99% of Americans would understand it) and I mentioned that it doesn't seem that is the case.

If you're arguing about the alternative definitions of 'billionaire', it could have been an interesting sidenote, but ultimately the definition that I am using is what most Americans (i.e. the country Woz lives in) would assume and to use another definition in this context is poor communication.

The whole point of the post I responded to was just saying that if Woz wasn't working with Jobs, he might not have been as rich as he is now; no judgment was made on what it means to be "rich enough", etc.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @11:58PM (#7100827)
I was assuming that Woz actually had over a billion dollars in the literal sense. I was clearly mistaken and I did appreciate the correction.

Not sure why a simple correction turned out to be controversial. I was wrong and you corrected me. I'm not offended so no one else should be either.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by markdennehy on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @08:55AM (#7095187)
Because if you want to argue over the meaning of the word billionaire, you start with why we shouldn't have changed the meaning of the word billion :)

When you're talking about personal wealth, there's a real danger of money going from a tool to do stuff; to being a way to keep score. And that latter road leads to the worst kind of arsehole-ry (damn, that needs a better word).

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Sunday January 19, 2014 @09:55PM (#7087265)
Thanks for the correction.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by caycep on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:09PM (#7086941)
That isn't to say Jobs didn't have his own talents, but he had to find the best way to use them. He said himself that getting fired from Apple was the best thing that happened to him. Some would argue that the later years w/ the iMac, iPod, iOS, etc wouldn't have happened without this.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by vasilipupkin on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:20AM (#7088909)
My guess is if it werent't for Wozniak, Steve Jobs would have found himself another Wozniak or would have put himself into a situation where he would have not needed a Wozniak. What has Wozniak accomplished since he left Apple?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by varjag on Monday January 20, 2014 @07:35AM (#7089153)
> My guess is if it werent't for Wozniak, Steve Jobs would have found himself another Wozniak or would have put himself into a situation where he would have not needed a Wozniak.

Unless you're religious or believe in fate, Jobs life would probably be very different. He could become a successful artist or car salesman or crack cocaine dealer, but unlikely a tech visionary.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by vasilipupkin on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:12PM (#7092986)
Steve Jobs left Apple, wasn't Wozniak there that whole time? Then he came back and lo and behold, not just did a good job of running the company but turned it into world's biggest company by market cap. Could Woz have done that? Once they parted ways, Woz did not much ( relatively ), while Jobs did a lot.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by varjag on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @03:22AM (#7094076)
> Steve Jobs left Apple, wasn't Wozniak there that whole time?

No, he left shortly after.

> Then he came back and lo and behold, not just did a good job of running the company but turned it into world's biggest company by market cap.

The company struggled when Jobs was outed in the first place.

> Could Woz have done that?

Probably not, Wozniak is not a businessman. But I have a better question, could Jobs become a leader of Apple and figure of note in first place if he had not walked on Wozniak with already complete Apple prototype? There's a lot to be said to being in the right place at the right time.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by vasilipupkin on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @10:38PM (#7100530)
Since we all agree that Jobs was a great businessman, my guess is he would have found another way to realize his talent.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by pbreit on Sunday January 19, 2014 @10:27PM (#7087364)
I suspect the opposite but we'll never know. It seems clear to me that jobs had the vision and ability to make things happen which is typically more important than the technical know-how.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by mandeepj on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:06PM (#7086722)
"Jobs would probably have died homeless and friendless if Apple never existed." - so funny.

Besides Apple, Pixar and Next made Jobs billionaire too. So, no jobs would not have died homeless and friendless :-) . Jobs was a natural leader and visionary.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:24PM (#7086781)
>Besides Apple, Pixar and Next made Jobs billionaire too.

If Apple had never existed, he wouldn't have had the hundreds of millions dollars that he spent on these endeavors.

>Jobs was a natural leader and visionary.

Jobs was good at recognizing when the right time to bet on a technology was. When you are filthy rich, you can turn this talent into a license to print money. When you aren't already rich, it just makes you the average person on HN.

I can predict the success and failure of specific technologies with a staggering degree of accuracy, and I'm sure that most of the techies here can do the same thing.

Was anyone here surprised that RIM's brushing off of the capacitive touch-screen launched them into a death-spiral?

Was anyone here doubting that moore's law, flash memory, and high-resolution touch-screens would eventually make it possible to create a tablet that consumers would actually want?

Was anyone surprised that Android overtook a platform that was designed from the ground-up to serve as a symbol for exclusivity? Guess what happens when you launch with only one of the four major carriers? You just gave up any advantage you gained from being first to market.

This shit is obvious to people who live for technology. Steve Jobs didn't create the iPhone or the iPad, the electrical and computer engineers who saw it coming a few decades ago did. They saw potential and so they spent the best years of their lives developing the technology that would one day make it possible.

I'm not saying that Steve wasn't talented, because he was. I'm just saying that it takes more than talent, intelligence, and leadership ability to succeed at the level he did. There's a random element to it, and this random element is the largest factor.

There are thousands upon thousands of talented, smart people with ideas that could change the world. Most of them, if they ever even get a chance to try, will end up being crushed by a world that is reluctant to change.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by macspoofing on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:40PM (#7087030)
You don't need millions to make technology bets. You were so sure RIM was going to implode? Why didn't you short the stock and laugh all the way to the bank?

I'll tell you why. Things aren't so obvious when you have some skin in the game.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Sunday January 19, 2014 @09:48PM (#7087238)
>You don't need millions to make technology bets.

To become a household name as a genius capable of predicting the future you most certainly do.

>I'll tell you why. Things aren't so obvious when you have some skin in the game.

I'll tell you the real reason why: I make enough money to cover my living expenses, and that's about it. I am right about technology most of the time, but I don't have enough expendable income to afford ever being wrong. I'm not saying that I would be a wealthy investor if I obtained a few million dollars to get started with, there are a lot of other variables that determine how well suited a person is to that kind of work, and I'm fairly certain that its not for me.

I'm just saying that Jobs wasn't some kind of futurist demigod.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by jaredsohn on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:04AM (#7087846)
I think there are virtual stock markets that you can partake in to see how good you are (although this likely requires investing time which won't directly get paid back if you do well at it.) I wonder if people who do especially well in them can use virtual stock market success as a stepping stone to managing other peoples' money (and getting a cut).
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by nicholas73 on Monday January 20, 2014 @07:14PM (#7092532)
It's well agreed upon that paper trading is nothing like trading with money on the line. It's ALL about psychology.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by markdennehy on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @08:43AM (#7095126)
> It's well agreed upon that paper trading is nothing like trading with money on the line. It's ALL about psychology.

It's also pretty well agreed on (mainly from scientific studies into the actual results of investors) that this is not only bullcrap, but believing it's true was a major contributing factor in the enormous economic disaster we're all still living through right now. I'd like to say how galling it is to see someone hasn't learnt the basic hubris-based lesson we paid so much for -- except that I really can't express that in words adequately.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by macspoofing on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @10:15AM (#7095700)
>It's also pretty well agreed on (mainly from scientific studies into the actual results of investors) that this is not only bullcrap

Are you sure you actually understand what nicholas actually argued? All nicholas (as well as me) wrote is that your decision making changes completely when you have something on the line. And of course it would! So what are you talking about?

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by nicholas73 on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @02:03PM (#7097438)
When I say money on the line, it really means your own money on the line. The disaster you refer to is when people trade other people's money for a share of profits but no liability.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by jimbokun on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:36PM (#7087021)
"Jobs was good at recognizing when the right time to bet on a technology was. When you are filthy rich, you can turn this talent into a license to print money. When you aren't already rich, it just makes you the average person on HN."

Jobs recognized the right time to bet on the personal computer when he had almost no money, and started Apple. You seem to be inferring Jobs always had a lot of money, which just isn't true.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Sunday January 19, 2014 @09:52PM (#7087250)
The conversation was under the hypothetical context of Apple not existing.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by snowwrestler on Sunday January 19, 2014 @10:36PM (#7087396)
Yes but the point is that Apple only existed because Jobs worked to make it exist, despite not having any money of his own.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:04PM (#7087492)
>The conversation was under the hypothetical context of Apple not existing.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by mandeepj on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:44PM (#7086852)
> If Apple had never existed, he wouldn't have had the hundreds of millions dollars that he spent on these endeavors.

Steve jobs was an entrepreneur. He did not had millions of dollars when he started with Apple so he could have also started with something else besides Apple and money would have came along as it did with Apple.

I agree with you there are so many genius people in this world. Not everyone gets to see Jobs like magnitude of success. I guess luck, tireless persuasion of your dreams, target also play part in your success rate

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by bdcravens on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:44PM (#7087044)
he could have also started with something else besides Apple

Assuming he had a Woz, perhaps. Perhaps he would have found another engineer, or perhaps Woz had a unique combination of skills that really meant Jobs was in the right place at the right time.

Jobs failed in his vision - a lot. Had the Apple II not kept Apple plodding along - remember what Woz said about Jobs's desire to kill it - and some of the strategic investments along the way from outside (Microsoft's investment of $150M when Apple was on the verge of bankruptcy), Apple would be a memory today.

I know that violates the meme on HN and elsewhere that Apple's success is purely the result of Jobs's genius and vision, but that's a rewriting of history.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phektus on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:27AM (#7088057)
>Jobs was good at recognizing when the right time to bet on a technology was. When you are filthy rich, you can turn this talent into a license to print money. When you aren't already rich, it just makes you the average person on HN.

Hahahahahaha. Yes.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by ehsanu1 on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:18PM (#7086765)
You can't really tell either way. The road to NEXT and Pixar was through Apple. And I do hear his role in Pixar is often portrayed as being much more than it really was.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by Shamanmuni on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:22PM (#7086982)
Most of what's usually said about Steve Jobs' role in Pixar is a complete myth. It's quite outrageous the level of falsehood when you read about it from those who were there before Pixar was big.

For starters, Steve Jobs didn't invest in the Pixar that you know (the one which makes films), it was a hardware company and it never occured to him to make an animated movie, just sell hardware. It was the people working there that saw the potential for films made 100% with computers.

He didn't even pay much attention to Pixar until after they made the deal with Disney to make Toy Story and critics started saying it was going to be huge. After that the "visionary" took charge and, of course, took all the credit for himself.

You can read more about it in the link below. You aks who Alvy Ray Smith is? Well, one of the cofounders of Pixar and its first Vice President. And by the way, he was the inventor of the Alpha Channel. http://alvyray.com/Pixar/PixarHistoryRevisited.htm

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by rblatz on Monday January 20, 2014 @08:29PM (#7092815)
Wow, Alvy sure has an axe to grind. And he tries to sound it objective and talks about himself in 3rd person the whole time.

But he fails so hard on so many things, like the Steve Jobs investment didn't save Pixar rant. He says Steve's money didn't save Pixar and then says that Steve pumped more and more money in until it was actually worth something.

Whatever points he makes that may be valid are completely made suspect by his tone and spiteful attitude.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by dllthomas on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:54PM (#7086670)
Depends how you define "failed", in Woz's case.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by JAFTEM on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:30PM (#7086595)
Many people usually go under-appreciated for their work that leads to major engineering feats. It seems to me that society likes to look at the past and attribute one thing or one person to what changed everything, when in reality it is the accumulation of several events that lead to major breakthroughs. Thomas Edison never invented the light bulb, but he did find a filament for the incandescent lamp so that it could be mass produced.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by WalterBright on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:46PM (#7087047)
Edison invented a practical light bulb.

He also invented the industry that was able to deliver power to homes so they could use those light bulbs.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by JAFTEM on Sunday January 19, 2014 @09:32PM (#7087197)
Which is what I said and my point stands: how many people can actually give the correct answer to who created the first light bulb? Edison was attributed all of the credit when he built off the work of others, which isn't to say that's a bad thing but that this is usually how breakthroughs usually come about.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by WalterBright on Sunday January 19, 2014 @10:24PM (#7087348)
I have mixed feelings about the "correct" answer. Davy showed that wires glowed when enough current was passed through them. Does that count? Swan improved on that with his lightbulb lasting longer, but a few minutes life is incomplete. Edison finished the invention.

Me, I tend to give the credit for the invention to Edison, while acknowledging that he stood on the shoulders of others. It's how credit is done for most inventions.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by markdennehy on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @08:48AM (#7095153)
You might give more credit to the hundred or so people (all the equivalent of our PhD graduates today) who were doing the actual work for him.

Edison's contribution was to pay them enough so they could eat and live, and point them at a project.

And Edison's an even more interesting example to bring up in a Jobs discussion because of the whole history between himself and Tesla (and if nothing else tells you about the man's character, the elephant-electrocuting nonsense during the current wars would tell you all you needed to know).

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by WalterBright on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @03:53PM (#7098279)
> Edison's contribution was to pay them enough so they could eat and live, and point them at a project.

Edison's long string of inventions suggest his contribution was far more than that. (And the money used to pay his staff came from his prior inventions, Edison was not born rich.)

> elephant-electrocuting nonsense

We find that reprehensible today. But people at the time did not, and it's better to judge him in the context of his time.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by xerophtye on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:52AM (#7087966)
>He also invented the industry that was able to deliver power to homes so they could use those light bulbs.

Correct me if i am wrong, but i thought Edison was a proponent of DC current, rather than AC (it was tesla who pushed AC). I might have those two mixed up though.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by WalterBright on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:01AM (#7087982)
You are correct. The industry was invented by Edison using DC; AC was an improvement that came later.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by logicallee on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:19PM (#7086972)
I think even when there is a single founder, those are the two things you have to do.

I think investors, employees, and the public, want/need to be lied to about how easy it all is. You have to do impossible things but then completely deny all the work that goes into it, and act like it's just because you're great.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by vezzy-fnord on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:19PM (#7086535)
I'm not really familiar with this stereotype.

Quite the contrary, it seems to me that a lot of geeks and nerds are very passionate about their musical tastes. Classic example is Patrick Volkerding and Grateful Dead.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by noname123 on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:25PM (#7086570)
I think Woz is responding the myth that somehow Jobs has taken the aesthetics and free-spiritedness of the 60's counter-culture revolution and infused into Apple and that's what has made it stand out and thrive in comparison to the staid counterparts in computing (e.g., IBM/HP/Microsoft). Also, there was a long-standing rumor that Jobs had a long-time "under-the-table" liason with Joan Baez who was also a long time music collaborator and lover to Bob Dylan.

Tbh, it's sad that Woz comes out of the woodwork once in awhile to carp on his one-time partner. Yes Jobs was an ass-hole but Woz has all of the money in the world to get high, get a young nice-looking woman and play League or Dota2. In terms of the "intellectual man" who got snubbed by the "type-A asshole," Woz should learn from Paul Allen who reinvented himself as a renaissance man who long moved on from computing to owner of the Seattle Seahawks and blues guitar extraordinaire who jams with Clapton. At the very least, try going to the gym to get rid of that atrocious love-handle of his.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by phaus on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:54PM (#7086672)
>Tbh, it's sad that Woz comes out of the woodwork once in awhile to carp on his one-time partner.

It dishonors both men to allow falsehoods to become the accepted truth. If someone tried to convinced the world that everything that you accomplished in your life was the result of someone else's effort, and they all bought into it, I'm sure you'd be at least a little upset by it.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by jbuzbee on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:07PM (#7086727)
I wouldn't hold Allen up as an example of reinvention as his "renaissance" activities now include patent trolling. And Woz is none too happy about that:

http://www.geekwire.com/2011/woz-paul-allen-stop-patent-trol...

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by grey-area on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:36AM (#7088075)
Woz has been very, very generous to Jobs.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by angersock on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:13PM (#7086517)
He actually threw music festivals and was a notorious prankster.