News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by DanielBMarkham on Thursday July 16, 2009 @12:36PM (#708275)
Great comments, and I agree with all of them (although I do not consider myself deterred. After all, the point was to get feedback, see if anybody was interested)

The best comment so far that I've heard is to begin implementation in a walled garden in niche subject area. See if that works, then expand a bit at time into larger (and foreign) sites.

There's a fascinating question here about who owns what part of the content. If you write something, you own it, but if I say something to my friend like "check out jerf's last blog beginning about half way down -- that really pissed me off" obviously that content is mine. Now the interesting part is: who owns the connection between those two concepts? I don't think it can be you. ???

Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by jerf on Thursday July 16, 2009 @03:07PM (#708548)
"although I do not consider myself deterred"

Not my intention. I do seriously consider it unethical, but it's a very intellectual sort of thing; I'm not emotional about it, and more data may yet prove me wrong.

"begin implementation in a walled garden in niche subject area"

Probably your only hope of success.

"There's a fascinating question here...???"

Only because you asked: http://www.jerf.org/iri/blogbook/communication_ethics . It's pretty easy for me to go on... and on... and on... about this topic, so I try not to without a lot of provocation now. :)

Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by revorad on Thursday July 16, 2009 @01:16PM (#708353)
>begin implementation in a walled garden

Why don't you start experimenting with your own blog?

Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by DanielBMarkham on Thursday July 16, 2009 @07:14PM (#708995)
I was thinking a custom site, set up around a small niche where users "drill down" from entry to entry.

Perhaps a product review site.