Your kids didn't ask to be born. You decided to have them. If you're going to raise your kid by simply providing for them, and not nurturing them and spending time with them, then all of your "providing for" is worthless. If you decided to have kids when you could barely afford it, and had no extra time to do anything besides work, then they are right to consider you a bad parent.
Go listen to Cat's in the Cradle by Harry Chapin.
Your kind of judgmental attitude is of a piece with the helicopter parent Amy Chua bullshit that makes so many have fewer, more stressed, stressful kids rather than have more and just let them be.
There is more than one acceptable combination of parental responsibilities and time outlays, even in America.
We don't have any obligation to live up to your ideals.
You're exactly right. There's a lot of crap culture and values in the world.
> Children can adapt to and thrive in much worse environments than mostly only see Dad at the weekend.
True as well. Doesn't make it any less horrible.
Rationalizing away being a good parent is selfish. My mother died when I was 11 and my father (a director in his company) worked incredibly hard to manage the balance of the demands at work and taking the time and care to raise my sister and I. He did an extraordinary job and was very self-sacrificing, and so when I see comments along the lines of "I'm going to do what I want to do with my life and the kids will just have to adapt", it really kind of pisses me off.
But don't be seen 'not to be contributing' because your partner works at home while you work at an office.
The misunderstanding is the assumption that the wife was not working all day. IF she has a job, then she was working. If she stays at home with kids, she was also working.
Coming home and relaxing, saying, "Hey, I'm paying the mortgage" is also saying, "Hey, the work my wife did today was worth nothing."
That is a recipe for a very bad, broken marriage. You are invaliding the feelings of your spouse, and dismissing the work she does.
And if you are doing that, THEN something's very wrong.
I think it's reasonable to believe that some jobs are harder than other jobs. Staying home with the kids, while hard (and maybe even boring) isn't as demanding as the jobs that some people have.
I have to tell you that I'd rather the person who operates on a heart or a brain or flys a 777 (and there are many more I'm just picking a few obvious ones) focus on their job 100% and get rest to function at a top level. Raising children can be hard but it's a different type of hard.
Edited for clarity..
I've done a fair bit of the stay-at-home dad thing and I found it HARD. There something unremitting about dealing with the demands of small children while trying to keep the house clean and food on the table (and while my office life was all about getting rid of repetitive tasks, stuff like cleaning and cooking just has to be done again and again, which I found very hard to deal with).
I used to look forward to the days I went to the office; they were like days off.
No, I would never say that "staying at home with the kids" was the easy option.
Or get an iPad.
Of course it's a lot easier in the short term to get away with being a crappy parent than a crappy pilot...
Then those people should probably think long and hard about having families, right?
I'm of the opinion that if you really want to devote yourself to a career, you should skip having kids. Interestingly, the same traits that help in career advancement (hard work, willingness to sacrifice) are the same traits that help foster a successful marriage and family. Certainly, a few people can pull off both, but I suspect those people are the exceptions, not the rule.
I think you have it precisely the wrong way around.
Assuming someone providing 'is not contributing to the house' assumes their providing has no value.
This is modern feminist reduction of the value men (who most often perform this role) provide, and it's shameful.
It does not matter if there was a reason that it happened ("pay the rent"). It just means a life went the wrong direction. And it can't be fixed after it happens.
I'm not sure about children being born with the expectation of fatherly company. Historically it wasn't universal. Some native Americans had separate housing for men and for women and children. In other ancient societies men would leave en masse on hunting expeditions for whole seasons. Of course those civilizations were much more communal than ours and contained many more children.
If you read those, there's poor people, people starving to death, people out looking for firewood in the winter, etc, etc. And while some kids just accept it as-is others ask questions. Yes, at 4. It _really_ depends on the child.
I also didn't really understand what his job meant, but I knew it was among the "stuff that needs to get done even if you don't like it and don't know why you have to", of which I had my own share (cleaning the room, etc).
It was never a (big) problem when he or my mom weren't around for reasons we didn't understand; what mattered was that when they were with us they were WITH US. Reading, telling stories or listening to ours, going hiking or playing sports, teaching maths or showing how to beat an egg.
If they are raised to believe that work is necessary and the spouse who is with them while the working spouse is away doesn't whine, complain or fight with them about it then they will learn that it is something necessary. And guess what? If they don't that's to bad. You do what you think is in the best interest of your children long term not short term because you won't be around. In no way are they going to understand why you can't be at the ball game or the school play but later if you are out of work and/or you can't pay for their college that they will understand and they won't say "oh that's ok at least you came and saw me make that basket".
There's a difference between saying kids aren't capable and kid's aren't commonly knowledgeable or taught. I'll agree with the latter but I'd disagree with the former.
Your role is to nourish their brains and souls not just cover their heads and bodies.
Take out the trash and change a lightbulb by all means, but seriously if you're providing for your family, it counts.
If his children don't think he's pitching in by paying the rent /mortgage, then something's very wrong.