News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by jacquesm on Thursday July 16, 2009 @10:36AM (#707998)
I think it is a very neat concept, and not everything has to make money to be successful (see youtube), as long as someone with pockets deep enough believes in it.

The reason I mentioned the post-its is because your idea seems to be a special case of those, you could easily extend such a post-it like application to become what you describe.

One really sad thing is that with all the cross-site scripting jerks out there some of the nicest things that you could do with javascript (layers on top of other websites) are no longer possible.

I've been playing around with something like that on cameria.com (now absolutely defunct, but I do still have all the code in a repository somewhere) which basically dropped a chatroom on top of every website where you wanted one, using little avatars and balloons.

The idea was to recreate the feeling that you have when you visit a mall or a store but then to apply that to a website, you'd basically 'see the crowd' of the other people visiting that site (limited to some geographical filter and a maximum number of users).

This also allowed all kinds of interesting bits like crowdsurfing (before it had a name) and 'guided tours' across the internet.

Alas, the 'holes' in javascript (that I thought were neat features) got closed to stop cross-site scripting attacks and the project died.

So now everybody that wants to do any kind of layering has to either have a friendly relationship with the website that they want to display the layer on (for instance analytics makes use of this through their tag) or you have to cache the data and spit it back out.

Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by DanielBMarkham on Thursday July 16, 2009 @10:44AM (#708025)
I did something like this a couple of years ago with a blog toolkit. Basically you signed up, added some javascript, and then we could come into the client during page load and provide all kinds of interactive stuff on top of your blog page.

Back then we just loaded JSON in javascript from a foreign server. I'd be surprised if that loophole was closed because if you can't load JS from a foreign server lots of stuff is not going to work anymore (like Google analytics)

Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by jacquesm on Thursday July 16, 2009 @10:47AM (#708028)
That's what I meant with the 'friendly relationship', the owner of the page has to place a tag. But what I was getting at was on any page, regardless of tags, simply by embedding the page in a frame and then accessing the content of the foreign frame. That is - alas - no longer possible because it causes security issues.
Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by DanielBMarkham on Thursday July 16, 2009 @10:51AM (#708038)
Can't you just drop a JS link into the page on load from a plug-in? I think that would work.
Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by jacquesm on Thursday July 16, 2009 @11:00AM (#708061)
Yes, but that requires the installation of a plug-in and I wanted to avoid that kind of change.

The reason is that as soon as your project requires a plug in or a download the size of the 'universe' is only a fraction of what it would be otherwise.

Re:HN Rate My Idea: Socratic Linking by DanielBMarkham on Thursday July 16, 2009 @11:19AM (#708107)
Wonder if you could do it via js insertion in something like adsense? Probably not that particular product, but most pages get JS from all sorts of places. Lots of opportunities to piggy-back.