At best, init scripts are 5 lines of actual functionality and 100 lines of boilerplate, and in my experience very few init scripts are at their best. With systemd, the config file contains the 5 lines that actually matter and nothing else. I'd consider the latter to be much more simple, clear, and understandable.
First example where a project maintains both - a particularly verbose service file, compared to an average init file; compare not just line counts, but complexity (variable-filled function calls, branching logic, etc, vs a set of key=value pairs)
https://github.com/varnish/Varnish-Cache/blob/master/redhat/...
https://github.com/varnish/Varnish-Cache/blob/master/redhat/...
I wouldn't describe them as simple at all. What init.d/rc.d scripts amount to is pushing all the pid0 init work out to every individual service and making them figure it out on their own.
Any distro which takes them away stops being my friend.