Some teachers ARE lousy. And some teachers present the course material in an engaging, captivating manner.
And yes, some students are lazy. But others want to learn, preferably from the latter type of professor. Labeling any student who forms an opinion about a professor as an "entitled [student] who failed after submitting a paper a month late" reveals a lack of faith in the ability of a young adult to take a genuine interest in his educational experience.
> Some teachers ARE lousy.
Very much so — I am one, and I’ve always told that most of my teachers at my school were criminally bad. (I did take steps to have some of them sent to jail.) I do not remember arguing the opposite.
> “Open” and teenagers with social bias don’t mix nearly as well as one would love.
Who cares about that level of reviews? The validity is weighted by the source and level of discourse.
I have seen such websites rare last (and publicly shame) very demanding, very good at that level of teaching, socially awkward teachers — in a way so aggressive that can only de described as late-in-life bullying. I was part of a group of students who personally intervened to avoid a suicide.
This is now my second favorite self-rating statistic, after "50% of males rank themselves in the top 10% in athletic ability".
So I don't see why anonymous reviews should fail in a similar case.
I strongly doubt that with the ratio of entitled students in the US, and the authority they wage over other students, this would be nearly as functional there.
Yale understandably knew that such platforms can be useful, but need some tweaking: anonymous reviews tend to aggregate YouTube-grade insults — and people who dedicated decades to their expertise do not react well to being openly and repeatedly described as “sucks ASS and Booawles!!!!!” by entitled students who failed after submitting their papers a month late.
“Open” and teenagers with social bias don’t mix nearly as well as one would love.