News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s... by jerf on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @12:33PM (#705982)
Nobody worth listening to is saying, "Hey, I don't want that guy to have health insurance! I want that guy to die in pain!"

It's just that when you get past the touchy-feely "Nobody should be poor! Everybody should have health care! Why can't we all just get along‽", and down into the real world of economics and finite resources, it's not so easy. It isn't all that hard to create a universal health care system that is worse than the one we have now, and there are all kinds of other issues, too.

You might get me to sign up for health-care vouchers provided from the government if you really insist, but all current proposals seem to just beg for further increasing costs as the health care industry is further isolated from pricing signals and beg even harder for regulatory capture within five years by the already-powerful health care lobby. (The idea that the medical lobby will be defanged by centralizing all the power is so absurd I can't believe anybody who can think the words "regulatory capture" can believe it for more than five seconds without bursting out in laughter.)

Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s... by profquail on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @12:57PM (#706041)
Like I wrote in my reply to "DanielBMarkham" above, I've actually heard people say that they aren't paying for someone else's health care, and that they simply don't care what happens to people without it. That's just a personal anecdote, but I'm sure the people who said that to me aren't the only ones out there.

I understand the real-world economics of the problem, but I think the real underlying issue is that many (not all, but a significant) number of Americans have simply become too selfish over the past 100 years or so. Those people simply aren't willing to sacrifice a little bit of their time and money to build a stronger community, because they don't see that they have anything to gain.

I also think that however this thing works out, it's going to become such a bureaucratic mess that it really won't be worth anything except to the most desperate people. The worst part is that we'll still spend the money, and it'll all get funneled away into mega-corporations without any real improvement in anyone's standard of living.

Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s... by jerf on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @03:24PM (#706360)
That's part of what I mean; "I don't want to pay for it" is simply one facet of the limited resource side, just phrased oddly. Moreover, you call it "selfish" but that is leaping to conclusions. Some people really can't pay for others, and the fact is that all of us have limits on how much more we can pay for. I'm not entirely averse to some contribution, but I do have my limits, both to what I'm comfortable with and what to what I can sustain even in theory, and in light of the creation of a system disconnected from price signals and with no particular incentive to stop consuming it's not "selfish" to become concerned; it's just rational.

I think a lot of these people, though by no means all, have far more complicated motivations and opinions than you think, and only a handful are really, truly saying "screw you all". (I think it's nonzero, but that gets into the "not worth listening to" class of people. These marginal people exist for all topics, though it's important to not classify large numbers of people that way.) Most people are not going to eloquently describe their full belief system, anymore than I have my own here, and even if they did, you probably wouldn't listen. (Any more than I would; this is not a criticism.)

Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s... by javanix on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @01:35PM (#706132)
Unfortunately, there just isn't anything you or anyone else is going to be able to do to combat people's "selfishness".

It may not be the way we want things to happen, but nobody is going to be able to convince every facet of the population to give up portions (however small) of their livelihoods to "build a stronger community" for exactly the reason you mentioned: nobody can see that they have anything to gain.

Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s... by tptacek on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @01:47PM (#706177)
But because insurance works best when the risk pools are largest, and irrational behavior among consumers (ie, spending zero in your 20s and free-riding in your 50s) will prevent those pools from being built organically, this seems like a perfectly sensible place for the government to apply regulation.
Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s... by javanix on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @02:30PM (#706274)
Oh, I completely agree on the regulation front - health care in this country is broken right now. I'm not in agreement with the current Administration's plans to fix it, but something needs to be done.

I just think that when people start claiming that "selfishness" is the underlying problem with our broken health care system, they're ignoring the pressures that brought on this "moral decline".

It's really no different than the far-right nutjobs who blame the state of our inner cities on the "laziness" of the people living there.

Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s... by dan_the_welder on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @02:07PM (#706233)
I'd like to address the finite resources thing.

The American government has completely failed it's citizens. There should be plenty of money for us to have a vibrant all encompassing economy.

We are the most productive nation on earth per capita. We should be rolling in it.

But it's all gone. To the Caymen Islands, Austria, Switzerland and China. In private bank accounts and foreign government coffers.

That does not even include all them good old American Dollars held by all the drug traffickers or used by all those poor people in countries whose national currency is a joke where the defacto currency is the greenback.