News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by fit2rule on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:09AM (#7057740)
How ironic will it be if the next generation of German kids has to rise up to fight the totalitarian might of the USA? I see it happening, already .. truly a staggering circumstance that we are here now in the 21st Century, and not even Germany can stand up to the tyrants.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by bananacurve on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:17AM (#7057790)
That is a lovely fantasy but I'd be surprised if they even cut back on US military bases.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by aluhut on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:34AM (#7057922)
They won't. The cuts on the German Army bases is already considered a mistake. Forcing (no idea how) the US to close down bases would only hurt the local and regional politicians.

I don't belive it at all.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by marktangotango on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:12PM (#7058193)
Why was it a mistake? Just curious. When I was stationed over there in 98-00, we pumped A LOT of money into the local economies, I personally bought a lot of beer! I love Germany, such a beautiful country, awesome people.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by aluhut on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:52PM (#7058489)
I'm sorry, I guess there was a misunderstanding based on my bad choice of words. I ment the Bundeswehr bases. Because of that decission many german soldiers are forced to move or travel a lot. Currently the new Defence Minister tries a more US approach on military bases by intergrating some kind of infrastructure within the bases.

And yes, the US (as well as german) bases pump really much money into local economies. And local economies are suffering from closed down bases a lot.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by gadders on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:14AM (#7057769)
The US are tyrants? Seriously?
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by phaer on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:24AM (#7057833)
In the context of international politics they are a clear match for most definitions of tyranny. Killing civilians based on behavioral profiles (look up "signature strikes drones") without any declaration of war against the countries in question (Pakistan, Yemen) is just one example. The relations between the US and most south-american countries is another one.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by josefresco on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:25PM (#7058293)
Official declaration of war on a state entity is almost quaint given how modern conflicts are now waged. If only it were as easy as declaring war on country "X" with complete disregard for native and non-native controlling factions.

What happens when your old rules of warfare aren't followed by your new enemy? Do you stand by those rules or adapt to the new reality?

Targeted drone strikes based on human and data intelligence is light years beyond declaring official war and shelling/bombing an entire region to the ground with no regard to what side the inhabitants may be on.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by eliasmacpherson on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:23PM (#7059098)
Not if your intelligence is worthless. If your intelligence is worthless, it's almost indiscernible.

You're creating a false dichotomy between "targeted" drone strikes and shelling and bombing an entire region. By the way, each perpetrator of shelling and bombing entire regions has historically made similar claims of "targeting/precision".

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by josefresco on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @10:23AM (#7063770)
Your points are right on, and I think as technology gets better, civilian deaths do decrease. However what happens is we start to cringe at the effectiveness of a cruise missile or drone attack forgetting that the alternative is bloodier, more dangerous and arguably a lot less effective.

How do we balance our tolerance for casualties with our tolerance of more and more effective weapons?

My point was not to say that drone strikes were wrong or right, only that the technology shouldn't be on trial, the intelligence, effectiveness and purpose should be.

I'm sure when airplanes and modern firearms took over the battlefield many thought they were "unfair" and dehumanized the process or war. And I don't doubt that in the future we'll be equally scared of newer more effective weapons.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by eliasmacpherson on Thursday January 16, 2014 @06:11AM (#7068920)
It's not a war. No more than the war on drugs is a war.

I don't agree that as technology gets better that the number of civilian deaths decrease. I would point to the atom bomb and chemical warfare. As drone technology gets cheaper, I don't see why civilian deaths would decrease. This is not an argument for ludditism.

You're presenting regional carpet bombing as the only alternative. This is not the case. There are alternatives other than drone strikes, and regional bombing that you seem to be ignoring.

Using your terms, how many countries is the US at "war" with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_United_States_mili... These are not wars, this is unilateral, self appointed world policing.

Unfortunately, the drone technology is not sufficient to guarantee accuracy. You can tell this because of how civilian deaths have been "redefined" by the US administration and the US military. Both refuse to publish their statistics. Historically, US intelligence has been anything but accurate, maybe the refusal to publish is another example of this.

I question the effectiveness of attacking funerals and weddings half way across the world, under the guise of preventing terrorism. Particularly with spectacular failures recently making the news.

The technology is not on trial, the US's reputation is. The technology has already been shown to be bunkum - the US's defence is that it's cheap bunkum. This isn't progress on any front. The US does not need cheap drone strikes in these countries, nor does it need to bomb the regions.

It's not the weapons people are scared of, it's who is using them.

[0] http://www.livingunderdrones.org/numbers/

[1] http://amanpour.blogs.cnn.com/2013/10/25/confessions-of-an-a...

[2] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/dec/29/drones-...

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by fit2rule on Thursday January 16, 2014 @02:52PM (#7072064)
Intelligence is worthless if it results in someone getting killed.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by fit2rule on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @05:20AM (#7062545)
Just like McD's is a nice form of bbq. Got it.

What's next, dial-a-bomb? You do realize you are justifying tyranny with precisely the mechanism of the tyrant: this 'elite' state is 'better' than 'anything else'.

I can think of a 1,000 better ways to solve the peace problem than dropping bombs on kids. The US invests in Death machines. That same technology, with different people, could be just as easily used to deliver tools of life...

But, 'war happens', right? The right to murder another human 'just happens', out there in the big world.. sorry, but no. If you claim sovereignty, then you must not be sad when others disavow you of it. That is the price. The USA respects no sovereign but itself: tyranny.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by ihsw on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:23PM (#7058281)
Your post implies that the US operates in Pakistan and Yemen without their consent -- there is definitely consent. Pakistan and Yemen want the US to bomb their country, for a variety of reasons that are as silly and contradictory as one can imagine.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by scarmig on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:55PM (#7058518)
Silly and contradictory enough that it's probably more confusing than not to imagine a Pakistan or Yemen with a united will.

The weak and fractured governments of Pakistan and Yemen want the US to bomb there. Yemen's being so weak it barely deserves the name.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by res0nat0r on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:57PM (#7058937)
The recognized leaders of these countries are the ones who are allowing this. Read Dirty Wars by Jeremy Scahill for more.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by gadders on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:45AM (#7058019)
I think compared to the Soviet Union they are positively benevolent.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by sp332 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:24PM (#7058286)
I don't think we should make the Soviet government the standard.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by gadders on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @10:42AM (#7063908)
No-one is making it the standard, but it is relevant seeing that NATO and the US were the only things that guaranteed West Germany's safety from Soviet Russia.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by phaer on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @02:34PM (#7065572)
...that might have been an argument almost 25 years ago, but the NATO continues to exist while the Soviet Union is long gone, and its questionable if that's for the benefit of the worlds population.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by fit2rule on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:12PM (#7058192)
Yes. This fact is becoming increasingly more clear to the rest of the world.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by mortyseinfeld on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:27AM (#7057853)
We saw what happened when Germany "rose up" in the middle of the last century. I guess Germans though the jews were tyrants back then.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by smackay on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:55AM (#7058074)
you forgot the homosexual tyrants, the gypsy tyrants, the slav tyrants and not forgetting the tyrants with disabilities.

The takeover of the German state by the National Socialist party was little more than a coup by a gang of thugs, psycopaths and criminals. The persecution of Jews and other minorities was just a convenient scapegoat to drag the majority of the population along. The horrible crimes perpretated during this period cannot in anyway be ascribed as a (popular) uprising.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by scarmig on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:59PM (#7058554)
German Nazis and German Communists (who were very much not the fluffy Euro-Communists of the Cold War) made up a majority of the German population. The ends to which people were forming active, violent militias were different, but when massive groups of people are taking up arms, a society has chosen the path of violence. German elites, conservatives, and moderates actively chose to let the Nazis take power, because it seemed superior to the alternative at the time.
Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by Dewie on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:41PM (#7058413)
The Jews etc. were the scapegoats of Germany, and the party and their leader rose to power because Germany was the scapegoat of WW1 (justly or not). I don't imagine that Hitler and his party would actually have gotten such a foothold if it wasn't for the fact that the German people were resentful for being under everyone's heel, and that Hitler's leadership brought Germany out of a slump in the 30's.

No? My knowledge of history is rusty.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by brazzy on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:59PM (#7059298)
I believe the main reason for the failure of the Weimar Republic was that most people actually didn't want a democracy. Right-leaning people saw it as a decadent and weak form of government and wanted the monarchy back, and left-leaning ones were split between a dozen different brands of communism or anarchism.

And of course it didn't help that previous military leaders had been worthless cowards who continued a losing war to a point where they could not longer sue for peace, then leave it to the newly formed democratic government to accept the onerous conditions imposed by the opponents and end up getting blamed for something they had neither caused not any choice in.

Re:Germans abandon hope of US 'no-spy' treaty by gdy on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:24PM (#7059431)
>justly or not

German started WW1, btw