News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by kalleboo on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:39AM (#7056925)
I had to use a secret browsing window to read this without signing up, so here it is for anyone else who has trouble loading the page:

--------

Chalk one up for the enemies of patent trolls: The Supreme Court on Monday threw out a request for trial from alleged patent troll Soverain Software.

The case, called Soverain Software LLC. v. Newegg Inc., is one of three such cases the Supreme Court is expected to consider this year. While the Court will likely hear the remaining cases, which deal with finer points of patent law, its dismissal of Soverain speaks to the potential frivolousness of its claims.

Soverain acquired the rights to numerous pieces of code tied to the online shopping cart, developed in the 1990s. In recent years, Soverain has gone on a litigious tear, suing more than two dozen companies including Amazon, Nordstrom, Macy's and Newegg, an online retailer, which all use shopping carts for internet sales.

Soverain had some success suing on the state level, where a Texas jury awarded the Chicago-based company $2.5 million in damages against Newegg. However, Soverain lost on appeal last year in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, which ruled the shopping cart patents owned by Soverain were too general.

Patent trolls typically acquire rights to fallow or soon-to-expire patents with no intention of using the patent. Often patent trolls set up shell companies whose only assets are the patents, which means they have no real revenues or assets. Their sole purpose is to harass small businesses, which usually settle rather than pay for extended and costly litigation.

Patent law was originally written to protect the patent holder, making it easier for the patent holder to prevail in court. For the patent infringer to win, rather, the defendant must prove exceptional circumstances--namely that the patentee acted in bad faith and made baseless claims. This is hard to do. While the patent holder can be awarded "treble damages," or three times the damage claimed, the most the infringer can ever collect is attorney fees.

The remaining cases before the Supreme Court will deal with these finer points.

Congress is examining legislation that would fight patent trolls and their frivolous lawsuits by making them liable for court costs, should they lose their cases.

Small businesses mounted 3,400 legal defenses in 2011 for patent cases, a 32 percent increase over the prior year, according to a research paper from 2012 by Boston University law professors James Bessen and Michael J. Meurer. That cost to small companies was about $11 billion in 2011, also a 32 percent increase over the prior year.

The total median awards to trolls is now nearly twice as high as those to legitimate patent holders, whose median reward fell about 30 percent to $4 billion, according to a 2013 report by PriceWaterhouseCoopers.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by dded on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:48AM (#7056967)
Sorry, I suppose "secret browsing window" is my default, and I did not notice any access restrictions.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by commandar on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:57AM (#7057347)
It's probably like a lot of publishing industry paywalls. It doesn't kicked in until you've viewed X number of articles in Y time span.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by vacri on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:33PM (#7060277)
Or have javascript turned off.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by mattmanser on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:42AM (#7056939)
So you'd thought you'd break the law and steal their content?
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by austerity on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:26AM (#7057184)
I've just checked and the content is still there, so he clearly hasn't stolen it.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by throwawaykf03 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:07AM (#7057405)
Well, people were going to that site to get the content, and now they are not (all) going there. Clearly the site has lost something, especially something that ties directly into their revenue. If one considers the content as a proxy for the lost revenue -- which is reasonable, since it's the content that attracts traffic -- one could say it's been stolen.

Of course, since it's not your work that is being mis-appropriated, you're free to look at it another way :-)

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by chongli on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:43AM (#7057577)
I would surmise that most readers of Hacker News either use an ad-blocker or don't click on ads often/ever. Viewed in this light, traffic to the site from here might even be considered a cost!
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by chaz on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:47AM (#7057592)
Revenue is to be made on unique visitors and impressions. No clicks are required.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by 6cxs2hd6 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:24AM (#7057836)
So the loss of traffic is a good thing because advertisers aren't paying for impressions that aren't actually seen? ;)
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by chaz on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:27PM (#7058314)
The advertiser usually doesn't care, since most ad blockers prevent the ad call, and their budget will be spent on another visitor. The ad blockers that render the ad off-canvas are bad for the advertiser, since they're getting charged for an ad that has no possibility of being seen.

Sites want as many unique visitors as possible because larger sites get more attention from advertisers, it permits better frequency capping, and enables better segmentation of audiences. Even though they get paid per impression, larger uniques tend to allow for higher CPMs.

Separately, it's worth considering that many writers are measured on metrics: uniques, minutes, shares, comments, etc. In some places, they might even get paid on such performance (I think Gawker did this). When content gets copied, the writer can be deprived of such credit.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by TeMPOraL on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:53PM (#7059269)
> The ad blockers that render the ad off-canvas are bad for the advertiser, since they're getting charged for an ad that has no possibility of being seen.

I was wondering whether such ad-blockers exist. Searching for one and installing it now.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by chaz on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:45AM (#7057583)
We all know that he means copyright infringement: the content was reproduced without permission. Using the literal definitions of the words "stealing,""theft," and "piracy" mistakes pedantry as rebuttal, and helps no one when discussing copyrights.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:28PM (#7058736)
It's not quite the same as pedantry; it's using sarcasm to make the point that copyright infringement is not the same thing as theft and pretending that it is is misleading and deceptive.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by DougBTX on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:57AM (#7057659)
I'm all for using the actual meaning of words. If that means it is harder to make emotional arguments, then so be it.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by chc on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:37PM (#7059192)
Words do not have an "actual" meaning. They have definitions assigned on a more or less arbitrary basis, and there may be multiple conflicting definitions for any one word†. The Greeks used to believe that foreigners were stupid because they spoke something that was not proper Greek. Nowadays we laugh at their naïveté, but then turn around and talk about the "actual meaning of words." It's just silly.

† Just within English we have words like "cleave," that are widely accepted as meaning both "hold on tightly" and "separate." And in Spanish, we have "dame" which means "give," while in Japanese they use the same word to mean "don't do that." Can we declare the Spanish or the Japanese to be wrong about what that word means?

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by Crito on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:24PM (#7059434)
> Words do not have an "actual" meaning.

When they are terms of art, they frequently do.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by chc on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:45PM (#7059591)
No, they have an accepted meaning among practicioners of that art. That meaning is not more "real" than other meanings, though is more likely to be contextually appropriate. The fact that "reduce" is a term of art in programming for "debug" does not make somebody who uses it in cooking instructions wrong.

Basically, what I'm saying is, the fact that you and your friends use a word a certain way doesn't automatically invalidate other people's usages. It is true that mattmanser's use of "steal" was not legally precise, but neither are many colloquial uses of the word ("It was such a steal at $5!", "He's stealing third", "Great artists steal", "His identity got stolen", etc.). You would be right to object if he had been raising a legal argument based around the concept of theft, but he wasn't, so it seems overly pedantic to me.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by Crito on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:55PM (#7059646)
> No, they have an accepted meaning among practicioners of that art.

You are getting close to the point here.

Why does a term of art have a specific meaning to a practitioner of that art? Answer that, and you will have determined why words have meanings in any context.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by mchaver on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @01:48AM (#7062013)
It makes it easier for the practitioners to discuss their art. Jargon is useful if all parties understand the concepts and the forms (words assigned to the concept) used to represent them. Otherwise you have to expand the jargon into larger units.

Borrowing words across fields (because of similarity) can cause confusion. One person may assign a meaning from a different field than the other interlocutors are using.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by BlackDeath3 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:40PM (#7058400)
Though I had a good chuckle at the grandparent post, it seems to be less about preventing emotional arguments and more about derailing a legitimate concern (potential loss of revenue or whatever) with pedantry.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by chaz on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:01AM (#7057692)
I am, too, but like "hacking," those horses have long left the barn.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by ToastyMallows on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:51AM (#7056985)
I had no problem getting in, this isn't behind a paywall of any sort.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by Flimm on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:57AM (#7057025)
It's probably a violation of copyright to copy an article and paste it here. Copyright automatically applies, paywall or not.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by bananacurve on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:10AM (#7057086)
The copyright holder is free to send pg a takedown request letter.

https://news.ycombinator.com/dmca.html

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by sizzle on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:15AM (#7057776)
thank you
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by officemonkey on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:51PM (#7058897)
I would argue that the Fair Use Doctrine means it's probably not a violation.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by smartwater on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @01:07PM (#7064913)
You can't use 100% of something and claim fair-use, that's not how it works.
Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by officemonkey on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @09:43PM (#7067726)
Yes you can.

Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright law sets out four factors to be considered in determining whether or not a particular use is fair.

* The purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes

* The nature of the copyrighted work

* The amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole

* The effect of the use upon the potential market for, or value of, the copyrighted work

You don't have to prove all four factors. You just have to prove that the use is fair. For example, if I write a haiku and someone writes an article analyzing my haiku for educational purposes, the use may be considered fair, even if they use the entire poem.

Re:US Supreme Court declines to hear appeal by patent troll by kalleboo on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:45AM (#7057291)
Yes.