Re:The Problem With The Big Bang Theory
by mcphage on Monday January 13, 2014 @08:37AM
(#7050414)
I've read theories like this before, and I gotta say, I don't agree with them. A big part of his argument hinges on "The humour in The Big Bang theory relies on the audience siding with and relating to Penny, the character coded as “normal” in comparison to the main four guys."... and maybe we're watching different shows, but the one I watch has more humor from the guys' standpoint (and often at Penny's expense). Yes, there is some humor from her standpoint, for people that identify more with her—but there should be, she's a member of the cast, and there are people who relate to her. But there's far more humor for people who relate to the geek characters (since there's more of them).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There's also significantly more deprecating humor aimed at the geeks, which for me offsets any humor I derive from relating to them.
Plus, the geeks really come across to me as too overly stereotypical to be relatable.
Re:The Problem With The Big Bang Theory
by lostcolony on Monday January 13, 2014 @08:58AM
(#7050544)
And even that would be relatable if it was self-deprecating. The article is right, the audience is positioned as an outsider; "It's funny because he mentioned that thing which is nerdy" rather than any realization of the character that Penny might find that reference impossible to relate to. You're clearly intended to identify with Penny.
I guess just making it sound nerdy/technical should be enough for most of the audience to think it's nerdy as hell and thereby funny, even if it is nonsense? Like "I'll make a GUI interface in Visual Basic to track their IP". :) I haven't watched the show myself.
That might help. Instead, it's something like "... I would do this like Spock <pause for laughtrack>"