I've known people in real life similar to all the main characters of BBT. The BBT characters are more concentrated, so I'd have to use maybe 7 or 8 people to span the characteristics of Sheldon, Leonard, Howard, and Raj, but I don't think that invalidates the point.
In fact, I knew such people at Caltech, which is where BBT is set.
As a Caltech graduate, I see no problem with their portrayal of Caltech people. It is the portrayal of the facilities that bugs me. They have geologists in the same building as theoretical physicists!
The "likes BBT" (x axis) vs "viewer intelligence" (y axis) curve seems to be, as far as I can see, convex.
I probably should have just went with the original quip I had, which was "People you consider idiots like it, and people who consider you an idiot like it", but that seemed a little insulting so I dropped it.
[1] or at least ordinary people and extremely smart people who do not like it do not seem to complain about the show online.
While I am no Hawkins, I do have first hand of experience of these levels of genius. I have met three nobel prize winners. I have never met anyone as dysfunctional as Sheldon. From what I have read, even Erdos had a sense of humour.
Unlike other popular TV shows like Friends, which are a very realistic depiction of what it's like for young people to live in the big city?
The Moss joke is that he is the only person able to actually memorise that (useful emergency) number, which shows he is better than the outside, that the normal world is the object to laugh at.
IMHO UK's IT crowd is a much better and funnier depiction of geeks (albeit Moss is a bit exaggerated too).