News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by ig1 on Monday January 13, 2014 @05:25AM (#7049806)
How would you feel if you paid quarter of a million euros for your taxi licence (maybe by mortgaging your property or going heavily into debt) only to be undercut by illegal taxi drivers who didn't bother to get licensed and didn't follow regulations ?

Obviously it's not an excuse for violence, but it's important to remember there are always multiple sides to any argument.

Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by trigger on Monday January 13, 2014 @06:07AM (#7049935)
This is exactly what happened here in Ireland in 2000. The market was deregulated overnight and there was a flood of new taxis on the roads.

Needless to say existing taxi drivers weren't very happy as a lot of them had paid around €100,000 for their license. They were effectively worthless after deregulation.

All this was great news for consumers of course. Before deregulation it was practically impossible to get a taxi in Dublin on weekend nights. I can recall queuing for hours in the cold and wet for the privilege of being dropped home.

The taxi drivers mightn't like deregulation but you can't hold the general public to ransom by operating a closed market. Of course the government should have handled the whole thing better by doing some sort of deal with the drivers who'd paid so much for licences thinking it was a long term investment.

Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by icebraining on Monday January 13, 2014 @05:56AM (#7049901)
I'd be pretty pissed at the guys who forced me to pay a quarter of a million euros.
Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by InclinedPlane on Monday January 13, 2014 @06:19AM (#7049968)
Because the system is broken and people are heavily invested in the current system and it being broken...

What? What's the logical conclusion to that sentence in your mind?

Should we keep on running the war on drugs because there are so many people who make a living off of it? Should we maintain copyright law the way it is today because companies have invested so heavily in it? Should we maintain software patent law the way it is because some folks have spent billions acquiring patent portfolios?

Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by EliAndrewC on Monday January 13, 2014 @06:32PM (#7054354)
There are a lot of middle-ground options, such as "buying back" taxi medallions before opening the floodgates and letting anyone run a taxi. This is obviously a tricky approach for a lot of reasons, but certainly there's a middle ground between "taxi medallions forever" and "all taxi medallions are worthless overnight".
Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by InclinedPlane on Monday January 13, 2014 @09:56PM (#7055072)
Having a competing service like uber is actually precisely that middle ground, since taxi medallions are not worthless overnight.
Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by rodelrod on Monday January 13, 2014 @06:36AM (#7050014)
Was there a good reason to have allowed the licenses be traded in the open market? This is what has driven their values to these outrageous levels.
Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by brohee on Monday January 13, 2014 @11:37AM (#7051580)
Because if they weren't traded openly, they'd be traded on a black market anyway.
Re:Taxi protest in Paris turns to guerrilla warfare as Uber ... by nraynaud on Monday January 13, 2014 @09:49AM (#7050819)
that's why they added 1000 licences, to deflate slowly the market. The are going from 17000 to 18000 licences.

The market got corrupted by artificial scarcity, it has to go back to a normal level, those who speculated will have to pay for it, as they are part of the problem. They know it and that's why they are so violent, they have no hope.